r/Miata•
AudioIsland

From modern to Miata: is it the right call?

Question

So I’m growing tired of 2012 Jeep Liberty. I know how to drive stick and want a fun, reliable, manual car. The caveat is I live in New Jersey where it rains and snows for half the year.

I found several NB Miatas (the one I’d prefer) near me that are in my price range (Sub 10k) that are in what appears great condition.

My question to you is this: is it financially silly to sell my Jeep and purchase a car much older than it to daily in a snow state? Is the snow going to absolutely DEMOLISH the poor Miata? I don’t have enough money to finance a daily and a Miata and my Harley Davidson, ergo why i would daily the Miata and hock the Jeep.

I’d also love to hear your Miata purchase stories!

Posted May 5, 2023, 7:15 PM UTC

16
magnavah•

" want a fun, reliable, manual car" - This defines the Miata.

It will rust in a few years if you winter drive it in a salted road state.

6

Is it silly? Maybe. Will the snow destroy that NB? Probably.

Maybe look at NCs. They're newer, less chance they'll already have rust, and tend to be a better value than the NAs and NBs.

2
StRyMxStormy Blue NC2 BBR 200•

My Miata purchase story origins in dreaming of the (original) Fiat 124 Spider in the years they were new.

Fast forward a few decades.

A second car became practical and affordable. Bought a NC1 1.8 Niseko PRHT Icy Blue. Loved it. I like the looks of the NC. Just need room for a sax and a weekend bag.

Then the itch came over me of wanting to be faster than the eco turbodiesel family car. Sold Icy for the money I bought it for (after 3 years!) and went for a clean 2011 2.0 GT-L PRHT. Added some torque and gave it a Dinitrol rustproofing treatment (they use salt in winters overhere).

For an all season daily a PRHT is a sublime solution. Good ones will hold their value if you can keep it rustfree.

Good luck, stay safe.

PS: NC2 is as modern as a 2012 Jeep.

2
Cheetah-kins•

I wouldn't buy a Miata for the use you're talking about, OP. I definitely think it won't last long under the snow and rain conditions of the northeast. I'd wait until you live in another part of the US more conducive to Miata ownership.

2
AudioIslandOP•

Thank you for the honest reply! I’ll consider a different daily driver.

1
joncaseydraws•

Second the vote for NC. Do some research on options for sealing the underside and wheel wells, there’s boat paint and protecting oils you can use. I did this research a couple years ago for an NA I bought with rust that I managed to clean up, fill, reseal and paint. Regardless the salt will find a way in and rust it out in a few years.

1