r/Design•
HROthomas

Design decision for a main menu for a mobile game. Left or right?

Me and my partner are arguing which main menu is better. Its for a simple Match3 game if its matters. The left or the right? Thanks for your opinions! http://imgur.com/aKpVo

Posted Nov 16, 2012, 12:02 PM UTC · edited

211
namanyaygWeb Designer/Developer•

You're over-complicating it :)

Choose any, it doesn't really matter. Better yet, agree to your friend's option, this will give you automatic right to decide the next time you have a quarrel (Hopefully on an important issue)

EDIT: Was a fool and thought OP was talking about alignment.

I'd say go with the left, but add a play icon to the play button, or make it 'separate' in some way. NinjaSOUP is right.

2
ninjaSOUP•

Choose any, it doesn't really matter.

Isn't it the designers job to care about the design?

This is the first time a user will be interacting with this game. To me, that's a pretty important moment.

1
namanyaygWeb Designer/Developer•

Oh wait. F*ck.

I didn't see the image and assumed it was talking about alignment :/

I feel stupid.

2
ninjaSOUP•

No worries; the text was confusing. Though I come here strictly for the images, secretly hoping there will be cats. :3

1
namanyaygWeb Designer/Developer•

Hahaa kittez :3

1
Hannachomp•

Oh man, I thought the same too.

1
namanyaygWeb Designer/Developer•

And changing from left to right will affect anything HOW? :/

1
ninjaSOUP•

They both need serious work, but I prefer the one on the left for clarity.

Icons & text > text > icons

2
BonzaiThePenguin•

I prefer the one on the right by far. I'm not sure how throwing every single feature onto a single screen is supposed to be a good thing.

2
HROthomasOP•

My concern aswell. Most games have very clean main menus so the player doesnt get lost and just starts playing

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
generichuman2794•

Icons with text is better. You'd be surprised how many people don't know what icons mean. Or how many of the same icon can mean so many different things.

I prefer the left one. It tells me what mode I'm going to be playing, what that entails, and my score. It is definitely too busy, but I really think it's way more grounded and easy to understand.

2