r/Cooking•
TidalPod

Advice on an Oven Safe Skillet

Open Discussion

I am pretty new to trying to cook more complex things and looked up a recipe for Sheppard's Pie. It says I need an oven safe skillet. Do I need some big cast iron deal or are there other types of skillets? Is it going to be a skillet I am going to need to worry about seasoning? I would like a skillet that I could just soap and water clean afterwards or am I stuck getting something requiring a whole ritual after use? Thank you for taking the time to read this.

Update: Based on what some people have posted, it seems I do not need a skillet. It seems like the recipe only calls for a skillet out of laziness. It sounds like a enameled cast iron or some other casserole dish that can survive an oven would be the way to go. The recipe only suggested a skillet so you could be lazy after cooking the beef. Thank you for all your help.

Posted May 8, 2023, 4:35 AM UTC · edited

317
Veering_Trinity•

Stainless steel or cast iron. I prefer enameld cast iron. Lodge makes a good one. Le crueset makes a much much more expensive one. No special cleaning for enameld. Wash it and dry it

4
TidalPodOP•

How difficult are the Le Crueset ones to clean?

2
Veering_Trinity•

Not difficult at all. The enamel washes off like any other dish. Soap and water and dry and you're done.

For the price, the lodge enameld cast iron is just as good.

2
TidalPodOP•

I put in an update, but it seems the recipe is just being lazy with a skillet, that way you don't have to transfer the beef to a casserole dish. I am just going to find an oven approved casserole dish and I should be good to make it.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ceallachdon•

Oven safe for a skillet primarily means a handle that won't melt or burn. Non-stick coatings depend on the manufacturer of the coatings, but Teflon is safe under 500F (don't leave them overheated on the stove) , and skillets routinely get temps over 400 on the stove top so almost all coatings used on a skillet should be oven safe at the temperatures used in a shepherds/cottage pie .

3
fjiqrj239•

This. They don't want you putting in something with plastic or rubber bits that will melt.

I have a big, high sided stainless steel frying pan with a long handle on one side, and a small grabbable one on the other, so i can easily lift it to carry it in and out of the oven. I can take steel wool to it if I need to scour it clean.

1
TidalPodOP•
2
[deleted]•

That's a very large shepherds pie. I've got both steel skillets with steel handles that can go in the oven, and a round, 3" high straight walled heavy bottomed steel pan that works as well. I also have 2 steel soup pots that fit. Anything without plastic.

1
MaryN6FBB110117•

I have never made shepherd's pie in a skillet in my life, and I've made it lots of times. I use a casserole dish.

2
TidalPodOP•

Looking into it further, the recipe is just being lazy by having you keep it in the skillet. Your comment brought me to this conclusion.

1
Scoobydoomed•

Stainless steel pan with a stainless handle. Easiest to clean (with some steel wool and soap).

1
kweefersutherlnd•

Cast iron is your best bet by far. It’s not hard to clean or season, it’s cheap, it lasts forever, and really makes the food better.

1
BD59•

Steel or iron. No plastic handles. Silicone sleeves on handles are OK, up to about 450°F. (235°C)

1
Adventux•

you could also go enameled cast iron. that is what I would use. can go in the oven then to table. and clean up is basically washing the pan. no worries about rust since it is enameled. Staub. Le Crueset. Lodge(tis what I have).

1
spade_andarcher•

They almost definitely mean a cast iron skillet.

But also if you own a baking or casserole dish, you can just use that for shepherds pie. There’s no need to use a skillet specifically. Just a big oven-save vessel will work.

Also you can totally use soap and water to clean cast iron. I do every time. You do have to fully dry it. I usually toss mine on the stove for a min but that’s not totally necessary. But you don’t have to wash it with salt and pray over it like some people suggest. Soap and water is just fine.

0
TidalPodOP•

There are some cool pyrex casserole dishes that I like. Will there be an issue with how the pyrex conducts heat versus a pan?

1
teetauri•

The Shepherd’s Pie recipe I follow involves finishing under the broiler: if that’s the case with your recipe, then Pyrex would not be a good choice; but if it’s just baking 425 or below, then the Pyrex would work.

2