Question: Server licensing 1:2 ratio

When we buy Windows Server Standard for our physical host (16 physical cores), we can also license up to 2 VMs on that host using the same license.
Does that mean there is a same 1:2 ratio for any additional license we purchase (for example: 5 licenses to cover 10 VMs in total on that same host)?

Posted May 11, 2023, 4:20 PM UTC

19
NoinsPanda•

Nope. If you want to add more VMs to a Windows server standard you have to license the full host again. Let's say there are only the minimum of 16 cores in the host, that would mean:

2 VMs = 16 core licenses 4 VMs = 32 core licenses 6 VMs = 48 core licenses ...

If you want to license more than 2 VMs running a Windows server standard OS, you should either look into the licensing of the virtual machines (a rather new option for windows server standard licensing) or buy windows server Datacenter.

2
Technical-Message615OP•

So you're confirming my assumption or am I missing something?

Since we have only 16 cores, we would add (the cost of) 16 cores for every 2 VMs.
So ~5K in spending without any room to grow or ~6.5K with unlimited room to grow.

1
NoinsPanda•

I didn't take the new licensing option for virtualized Windows Server VMs into consideration.

Server Licenses (per core) – Licensing by Individual Virtual OSE

Available for subscription licenses or licenses with active Software Assurance only. All CALs used to access the software under this model must also be acquired as subscription licenses or have active Software Assurance.

  1. Customer may use the server software in one Virtual OSE on the Licensed Server, provided it acquires sufficient Server licenses as described below.

  2. The number of Licenses required equals the number of Virtual Cores in the Virtual OSE, subject to a minimum of 8 Licenses per Virtual OSE.

3.Customer may reassign any of its Licenses to any of its Licensed Servers located within the same Server Farm as often as needed. Customer may also reassign these Licenses from one Server Farm to another, but not on a short-term basis (i.e., not within 90 days of the last assignment).

​

Here is the link.

Edit: Formatting

1
Technical-Message615OP•

Yeah no subscriptions or SA here. But I do like the reassignment option. Comes in handy when you have multiple hosts and need to shift things around.

Time to contact the vendor. Thanks!

2
NoinsPanda•

You are welcome

1
TheAnswer229•

I’ve seen you answer a few times prematurely without confirming additional considerations, until challenged by OP. Might want to validate before giving such confident incorrect responses :)

1
NoinsPanda•

Ah, I guess I'm fine thanks.

1
johnnypark1978•

If you wanted to license more VMs on the host, you can stack those licenses on the host to get 2x VMs per set. If your host has 24 cores, you'll need 24 cores for each set of 2 VMs you want to license.

There's a breakeven point where it's just easier to buy the Datacenter licenses once and run as many VMs as you want. DC is roughly 6x standard, so beyond that, just get DC.

Things get more complicated when you start talking about bigger environments and VM clusters and using vMotion/LiveMigration. If you're using Standard licenses, you have to basically license the high water mark. "This server might at some point have 10 VMs, so I need 5x the Windows Server core licenses." Datacenter Edition just makes things easier.

1
Technical-Message615OP•

Thanks! I'll get in touch with our vendor.

1