Under desk treadmill vs. standing desk elliptical

Halp

I'm looking to add some more mobility into my workday beyond just standing up and sitting down while working. I've narrowed my suitable options down to either an under desk treadmill or a standing desk elliptical (used while standing up), but can't decide. Older posts I found typically compared a treadmill to an under desk elliptical used while sitting down, which isn't of any interest for me.

I'd love to hear opinions about either option. I've written some pros and cons down below and am wondering if there are potential important up-/downsides that I'm missing.

Some notes: Burning calories isn't relevant for me. Either of these would only be used at consistently low intensity and low speed to supplement higher intensity workouts away from my desk. My main goal is just having more consistent movement throughout the day.

Under desk treadmill

+ Forces you to keep walking

+ More natural motion resulting in more balanced muscle activation?

- Bulky, more annoying to put away (may discourage usage)

- Louder (irrelevant)

​

Standing desk elliptical

+ Cheaper (not relevant as prices are fairly similar in my location)

+ Lighter and smaller

+ Less impact on joints

- Allows you to stop easier if distracted? (unsure if this is actually the case or it would just cause you to slow down while continuing the movement, which would not be a problem for me)

- More up and down motion which could be annoying while typing?

- Risk of leaning against desk/bad posture?

I've marked certain aspects that I'm unsure about with "?", so any feedback on those would be particularly helpful. So far, I'm leaning towards the elliptical for its ease of use, but am concerned that it may feel less comfortable during longer periods of use or may cause me to drop when getting distracted.

Posted May 13, 2023, 2:14 PM UTC

312

I have been using treadmill desks for 14yrs, bikes and ellipticals before that when seeking what's best.

Go with a walking desk, it promotes better natural form vs elliptical, we are made to walk, not be on an elliptical. Impact is naturally low, your walking, I walk in socks 8hrs a day 5 days a week, no leg or back issues.

Honestly, when the front is tucked under the desk, it sticks out no further than a chair does, so no need to move it away, ever, also having it permanent encourages you to use it. If you really need to sit, get a $15 stool to put on the treadmill, again, will encourage you to use it more.

On the noise issue, any model under $1k is a poor investment, parts will burn out fast, e.g. motor and belt/electronics. Lifespans are great models, on the quiet end of motorized, has good warranty. You can go full manual, but I would only recommend Walkolution models, the best walking desk treadmills out there.

Typing and using a mouse, your body adapts faster than you think, you should see no issue with two days of use, you will adapt. Its pretty minimal.

More important factors to consider is your actual ergonomic setup, if your hunched over, leaning, neck bent, any setup will be uncomfortable. Use a visual guide from standing desk ergonomic setups, you can find plenty on google images.

Ellipticals will get uncomfortable, so discourage use, bikes will make your ass sore after a day of use and less of your body is in use.

2
DukeSlothOP•

Thanks a lot for the excellent reply, this is exactly what I was after! Definitely makes me prefer opting for a treadmill.

Unfortunately, none of the models you suggested are available in Australia. Lifespan used to sell their better models here, but switched to just selling flimsy foldable ones that are produced by a 3rd party right before I pulled the trigger on one of theirs. Walkolution models don't seem to be available at all.

I may opt for a cheaper option first and see if I like it in general and then possibly upgrade if it burns out and/or any of the better models ever become available in Australia (again).

1

No worries! Ha, well I am in NZ and have two spare Lifespan models I am looking to sell, moved here with them from the states. They would require a step down transformer though, and I imagine shipping may be pricey. Yes, they are hard to find outside of the US, and costly to ship far because of their weight/need to be boxed.

You can find the Walkolutions here, https://walkolution.com/products/mt300-new-work-treadmill

The best manual treadmill out there for desk usage, its an investment, but again, if you are using it for years, worth it. They are built like tanks, nearly no noise, requires no maintenance and look stylish.

1
DukeSlothOP•

I appreciate the offer, but the shipping is likely outside of my current budget.

Thanks for linking the Walkolution as well! I've used a similar kind of treadmill before, it felt absolutely fantastic to use. I wonder if they really work that well for desk work. While walking on them feels a lot more natural, it's comparatively easy to end up standing still if you're distracted on the model I used.

1
Melodic-Matter4685•

I am not coordinated enough to use my treadmill while working. Others are. Now I stand on my treadmill while working and use it when I don't work.

1
DukeSlothOP•

I would imagine that it this was a concern for me, it would apply for both the treadmill and the elliptical. I should be fine though, have no issue using things like balance boards while working!

1
oughandoge•

I would guess treadmill is much much easier to maneuver around, for when you want to take breaks where your desk goes back to normal

1
DukeSlothOP•

Standing desk ellipticals are actually much smaller than treadmills! They're basically just foot pedals.

1

I am not sure what the question is, but I am using a standing desk with a under desk treadmill (LONTEK) and I am extremely satisfied. Putting it away is extremely easy (at least for me).

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
DukeSlothOP•

Thanks for the suggestion! I actually have one already. They're decent, but I'd prefer something more active.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
DukeSlothOP•

I'm not sure what your budget/location is, but wobble boards in particular aren't very expensive on ebay or AliExpress. They aren't the fanciest option but they all do the same job anyways.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1