r/Destiny•
MasterYI

Where does the "welders make 6 figures in two years" talking point come from?

Discussion

I commonly hear from people promoting trades that you should go into welding and you can make 6 figures in two years. This was even repeated in Steven's debate during the whatever podcast and Destiny seemingly endorsed that stat.

As far as i can tell, this seems to be a complete meme that's repeated by those trying to denigrate the usefulness of college without actually being true.

Source 1: Median pay for a Welder 1(Early career) is $45,477, Top 10% is $58,107.

Source 2: Average base for a welder is 45k.

Source 3: This one is from the U.S. government Bureau of Labor Statistic. Median wage for Welders, Cutters, Solderers, and Brazers at any point in their career is $ 47,540 with the top 10% being $ 68,750.

And to be a little more anecdotal i just picked out a random job listing on indeed where a welder III position is being offered with a pay range of $24 - $28 an hour in Pomona CA, a city on the outskirts of LA, where you would expect the salary range to be one of the highest offered in the country. (Though maybe this company just offers shit pay).

Where does this fantasy of making 120K two years out come from? Why do i hear this repeated so commonly? If welders really made so much for relatively little training it would be taken up by a lot more people.

Only thing i could see is if you work a fuck ton of over time, or are able to go into a very specialized subset of welding like under water welding or start your own business you can be breaking 100k. But if that is what people mean when they say "welders make 6 figures two years out" that is misleading at best.

Posted May 17, 2023, 11:18 PM UTC · edited

9585
lalalu2009•

Trade salary gets insanely bloated when the right (wrong) people reference them. Some tradies do make bank, mainly because they work ludicrous hours. Generally for the work they do, their hourly is pretty mediocre. The average tradesman who has an employer and works on a site with some site boss for 40 hours a week doesn't make insane money.

72
Hobbitfollower Exclusively sorts by new | dggL•

What do you consider insane money?

1†
fuck_me_like_that•

Prolly like the 120k a year figure mentioned in the post... I'd guess

30
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Magnamics•

The clip makes it clear that they are saying 2 years after you start training you will be making 100k+ a year.

1

The only people making serious 6 figure or higher money in trades are people that own a successful trade business. We have electric companies around where I live pulling down low 7 figures, along with similar expenses for staff, work trucks, etc. The owners are able to bring home hundreds of thousands though if they choose not reinvest that profit.

Note that most tradesmen are terrible business owners, even the successful ones.

1
ChewchewMotherFF•

$50,000 each year x 2 years = $100,000

Gigachads

65
argonautdice3•

Economists don't want you to know this easy way to double your income.

12
joselcioppa•

I think it comes from this

52
Eradose•

He could talk about anything and it would be funny.

14
Tcvang1•

I dont get it. Am I too zoomer or do I just know jack shit about the world

4
struckfreedom•

No thats the proper response. Norms comedy is that he's the best at telling jokes or stories, the jokes themselves are bad on purpose. Thats why the moth story works.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n3LMSflEN54

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJN9mBRX3uo

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VkSMSbFV_q0

9
joselcioppa•

The punchline is normally "nonono I'm not ACTUALLY a miner", like wearing a mining mask, but Norm being Norm he just doubles the absurdity by making it welder instead of miner, almost like he's retelling the joke but doesn't quite get the punchline (which obviously he does, that's part of the joke and why he's so fucking funny)

5
argonautdice3•

Thanks, I actually didn't get this layer of the joke.

2
somepollo•

I'm 23, and he's makes me laugh harder than anyone on the planet. Dudes wild.

1
arkentest01•

Underwater welding can pay +100k, and I’ve seen Reddit threads where people claim making 250k, however, it’s one of the most dangerous jobs in the world, and not to mention the job sounds gruelling.

32
Classic_Ad_2684•

Decompression chambers don't sound fun

10
Ech0Beastbraindead button masher•

Byford dolphin accident AWARE

5
CareerGaslighterpsychologimetrist•

yes they do. You literally just chill for days while getting paid as they slowly bring the atmosphere back to baseline.

1
Marty_DollarGod Save The King•

I am not an expert, but I think the pay also reflects the fact that many underwater welders have a short shelf life as there is a limit to how many decompressions you can safely do.

4

Also one of the most dangerous jobs in the world.

1
Collypso•

Well done! you pointed out the second part of the first sentence!

3
deleafir•

or start your own business you can be breaking 100k. But if that is what people mean when they say "welders make 6 figures two years out" that is misleading at best.

Yep agreed. But I think this is what they're referring to. They envision everyone starting a trade and then starting their own business.

26
SkoolBoi19•

I’ve spent like 10+ years in the trades; Nation wide commercial construction. The money comes from certifications/licenses for almost every trade; like welders specifically, in Las Vegas (Henderson county I think) that jurisdiction requires a special permit that you can only get from going to that county and passing an in person welding test, that is an expensive welder because there is such an extremely small amount of people that can pass an inspection in that county.

16
ChuckyMed•

It’s all bullshit, there’s a reason why everyone decided to go to college to get a degree because these jobs destroy your body for a garbage wage. The owner of the successful [trade] company makes bank eventually, but majority of folks are not owners making anything remotely close six-figures. I like to equate it to nursing since I am closely acquainted with that field. The job is so hard on your body that I would not do it for 150-200k for more than a few years which is exactly what happens with travel nursing were people work for a few years to make some bank then completely pivot away from it, take a break, or go to an easier job.

14
SkoolBoi19•

It’s not a garbage wage. The money is there, it just takes testing and continuing learning for your entire career. We’re currently spending 60-120 an hour depending on trade and location. Top lvl people that hold licenses or certifications make real money because it’s such a limited pool.

11
ChuckyMed•

How much money is chronic knee and back pain at 35-40 worth for you?

2†
Sariton•

Idk but my friends who do programming have backs shaped like question marks so like maybe it’s a little more complex than if you do a trade you’re gunna hurt at 35.

11
txd024•

Bad take. It's much easier to modify office work to avoid back injuries than it is to do the same with something like welding or plumbing.

6
darkhorse691•

Also obligatory not in US meme but when I was learning my trade we had a huge emphasis on techniques that save your body over time. Kneeling on pads, always work at chest level, wear gloves, don’t wack tools with your hand to crack fasteners etc etc

9
ChuckyMed•

Difficult to maintain those kind habits ALL the time. It takes one bad lift to fuck your back up.

1†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
SkoolBoi19•

I actually feel really good at 37 🤷‍♂️

1
ChuckyMed•

Good for you, I don’t think I have to explain that just because you feel good right now it doesn’t mean you will later on.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
boastertath•

Probably just as much or more than being suicidal or in crippling debt at the same age with the added benefit of being able to tell people to fuck off when being treated unfairly since you're actually needed and not replaceable

0
ChuckyMed•

Ehhh…not sure if trade’s people are telling people to fuck off, they don’t have it THAT good.

2
eohorp•

If anyone has seen payrolls for large construction projects, it's not uncommon to see a bunch of the trades guys getting a higher rate than even the superintendent.

1

Yeah my dad was a welder in the navy and he always says not to get in to welding long term because it will fuck up your eyes even with welding masks on.

Maybe welding masks are better now, but I kinda doubt it.

4
blueboy664•

They work with all the underwater basket weaving grads. This is all a fantasy people trot out to "hurr-durr" college grads.

As somebody who has actually worked the trades, the reason why anyone who is worth a damn gets paid bank is because they are smart enough to either be really good at it or want to work enough that they eventually start their own company.

The successful guys are usually the types that would have succeeded in any industry.

The trades is a weird mix of some of the smartest people I've ever met, but mostly comprised of not-most competent parts of society.

If you can survive the hazing, gate-keeping culture, the work-until-finished mentality, and alcoholics and shitty bosses, you too can make a decent living! And if you are smart enough to start your own company before you destroy your body, you can start making six-figures!

All that said, I am no longer in the trades lol

13
CareerGaslighterpsychologimetrist•

or they are multi-skilled. Being a welder and electrician or an electrician and plumber increases your worth alot.

1
Icegiant-•

My last year working as a Union electrician I took in just under 110k but that is in San Francisco only NYC union made more than us and it was only by a few bucks, it is also work that will fuck up your body way to young.

8
Chrono68Kyle Fan Club since 2010•

Because blue collar overlaps with the same people who fish - they exaggerate the fuck out of things.

Theres only 2* types tradesmen that make 6+ figures:

  1. Guys in a Union in a city that evens out from the raised COL

  2. The guy who owns the company

The thing they never tell trade people who get a 2 year is that you'll never be more than the most experienced field guy. You'll never supervise because they require a bachelor's degree, or if the business is small enough to give you a shot they won't pay 6 figures. And even then that spot will instantly go to the owner's kid once he comes back to work for the business and you'll be a 45 year-old with knee problems being pushed around by a 25 year-old brat.

*theres a 3rd type making 6 figures and that's the workaholic overtime guy who puts in 80 hours a week. But that guy also is paying child support for 2 kids, rides a Harley, and single handedly finances his local bar at the video lottery table so he's a broke mfer anyways.

love you anyways, dad!

8
halffox102•

This stat comes from people that don't actually go into trades and just want to shit on college because they are selling shitty life advice

3
ggericxd•

it’s not real. no trade pays that much. if you own your own business you could hit it in a couple of years but even that would take an ungodly amount of work as well as having a VERY good office person to efficiently dispatch and route your work orders as they come in.

i did a few-year stint as an electrical project manager. i know intimately how much electricians all over the country and breaking $30/hour as a journeyman is top 5-10% easy. most are in the $21-28 range. i should caveat this by stating this is outside of high-labor states and union shops.

3
natotomatoo•

Welders who work a normal 40 hour week don’t make 6 figures often.

It’s generally a FIFO worker who has no friends or family at the camp so they work 60 hour weeks and get paid overtime.

3
Mikanik0927•

I work in the oil field and welders can easily make that plus more here. I should say that is with working 12-14 hours a day.

2†
ng829•

Is that pay rate listed anywhere publicly on the internet?

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
ng829•

​

To calculate the overtime rate, we need to determine the regular rate of pay. Since the average wage is $22 per hour, the regular rate of pay for the welder would be $22 per hour.

The overtime rate would then be 1.5 times the regular rate of pay: 1.5 * $22 = $33 per hour.

Now, let's calculate the overtime earnings per week:

Overtime earnings = (Number of overtime hours) * (Overtime rate)

To make $120,000 in a year, the welder's total earnings would be $120,000. Since the overtime rate is $33 per hour, the number of overtime hours required can be calculated as:

Number of overtime hours = (Total earnings - Regular weekly earnings) / Overtime rate

Number of overtime hours = ($120,000 - $1,200) / $33

Number of overtime hours = $118,800 / $33

Number of overtime hours ≈ 3,600 hours

Since the welder works 40 hours a week, their total working hours in a year would be:

Total working hours = (Number of weeks in a year) * (Regular weekly hours)

Assuming there are 52 weeks in a year, the total working hours would be:

Total working hours = 52 weeks * 40 hours/week = 2,080 hours

However, the welder has to work an additional 3,600 overtime hours to reach the target income of $120,000.

Therefore, the welder would have to work a total of:

Total hours = Regular working hours + Overtime hours

Total hours = 2,080 hours + 3,600 hours

Total hours = 5,680 hours

Thus, the welder would have to work approximately 5,680 hours in a year to make $120,000, which I would agree is crazy overtime.😵‍💫

1
ThinkingOnce•

??????

In the example you calculated the welder makes $120k from overtime alone.

It should be: (120,000 - 52•40•22)/33 = 2250 overtime hours in a year

4

My info is anecdotal but I know some very successful welders, I don't know their exact salaries but slightly over 6 figures wouldn't be a stretch. Couple of guys work on the road, one works locally as a tube welder. Trade school completion to 120k in two years seems inaccurate unless they are putting in some serious travel and OT but after 5 years with a good outfit or a great reputation it's definitely achievable.

2
Opno7DV4EVER•

Just also get your divers license and work on oil rigs. If you live through it you make bank! :D

2
WinterOffensive•

I think it suffers from the burbs. Biggest, most lucrative cities you can probably make that much, but rural idaho, naw. Not unless you're running a business with a handful of employees. Not that it doesn't pay well, it does for it not being a 4 year degree, but it gets embellished for sure.

2
Volks1337•

I have no degree and I make almost as much as a Welder per year in a shitty office job. I bet the real reason why some welders get paid so well is because its ultra specialized work. Like Welders working on Oil Rigs or under water welders.

2
buckymalone21•

My parents were friends with an underwater welder and I was led to believe that they made an assload of money compared to your average welder. Was just a kid though so take that with a grain of salt.

2
Insert_Username321•

Base welders like base anything will earn base salaries that aren't exactly impressive. That said if you get certified to do things like high pressure vessels or other specialty welding (exotic materials, dangerous sites, fine tolerance welding etc) then you can make absolute bank if you operate as a sub contractor ($100/hr+).

2
boastertath•

People are conflating the act of the trade (welding being the example) with being a certified welder. In every trade there is a rough base pay for the act, and the more certifications you obtain make you that much more valuable for the same work, for a fraction of the price of what we consider higher education. Mechanics in a mom and pop shop don't make as much as dealership techs with ASE titles that don't make as much as leads with inspection titles. On top of normal apprenticeships paying you as you learn progressively depending on trade ($25 year 1, $28 year 2, .....$45 year 5.)

2