r/Music•
Defyin

I have a question

discussion

So I was kind of wondering if anyone has a similar opinion on most music artists as me. Truth is I typically only care for an artist's album releases and barely ever have gone to a live concert recently or listened to live versions of songs. I don't know why I guess I just enjoy listening to the "perfect" versions of songs so I have never really cared much for other less produced ones, even if a lot of times it is technically less skillful to perform do too being able to adjust and splice parts together I guess I just like what sounds the best to me which is almost always the professional recording. I know a lot of people care about live performances though so I was just wondering if there were many other people with a similar opinion or if it was the minority?

Posted May 20, 2023, 4:21 AM UTC

13
bondmemebond_2•

Im of a similar opinion in that I generally don’t listen to live albums because I don’t wanna hear the crowd in the middle of the song or a slightly altered part done in the song when presented live. That being said I do want to go for live performances just to have the experience of being in a concert and having the infectious energy of the crowd.

1

(1st i play music now so its different than the common person)I used to think like this until i saw led zeppelin live msg 1973 vid. The band is better live, they add new guitar parts, new synergies, their stage presence. I like to say people dont care about whats good, they just wanna listen to something they already know. Probably the non performer in us. Once you get rid of that, sheesh GOOD lives are always better. Most bands are not like that though so i understand, why listen to a live version if its not any different other than worse sound quality. Valid opinion in that regard.

1
Heavy-Week5518•

Way back in the early 70s I sometimes didn't think highly of my favorite bands when their live sound or take deviated from the studio cuts. But over the years, I've come to realize that live is an outstanding alternative to that familiar version I loved. I am a rock fan first. On stage these guys get to perform as the song was written without the record companies suit's intervention. You get to hear longer versions & once in a while perhaps something very unique to that particular show. Musicians all get kick out of playing other people's stuff. They can do that at a show. And the fans reap the benefit. Some of my favorite versions of songs are definitely from live recordings. This stuff can be really be dynamic. Jazz & Blues musicians really opened my eyes to that. I learned that these guys have great talent that's not commonly heard on recordings. But on stage, the chance to show out is there. And boy can they bring it! Going to a concert is big fun. What is not so fun anymore is ticket prices for big name artist events.

1