r/Aquariums•
Rahms

PSA for noobs: ammonia/nitrite/nitrate isn't everything! Non-noobs: diagnose my dead fish please? :(

So I finally added fish to a tank that has been cycled for months.

I bought 8 tiny little lemon tetras, introduced them to my tank and was very happy. When I returned home today, 3 are dead. This makes me super mega sad.

I realised I'd only checked the pH like once, ever. The thing is, I can't really tell what it is from my API kit, I've always had trouble matching the colours.... However, I tested tapwater and it came in at a definitely lower colour. So hopefully after this water change (~25%) they'll be OK.

Anyways, the 3 dead ones.... When I bought them, one was a loner, so I thought he would die anyways (he kept landing on the bottom of the tank). I just want to check to see if anyone knows if this looks like a pH-killed-fish, or if I have something else to worry about...

DEAD FISH SORRY :(

**TL;DR Spent months keeping ammonia/nitrite/nitrate fine, fish nuked by alkali water

edit: sorry for poor picture quality, I have a proper DSLR but it needs to charge. Will upload pretty pics when my tank is less hideous (plants look nasty too).

Posted Nov 22, 2012, 6:15 PM UTC

020
LadyFishington•

Unless it was extremely acidic, or extremely alkali it won't be the cause of the dead fish. Use a bright lamp to tell the colour against the white and match it up. We need to know numbers really.

If you have bogwood, or CO2 for the plants it will always be more acidic than the tapwater, not always a bad thing as long as it's pretty constant. If you have lots of rocks they might make it more alkali (depending on the type), again not awful if their not wild caught fish but they've had plenty of time to get used to it.

What readings do you have for ammonia/nitrite/nitrate?

3
RahmsOP•

I'll have to check it later as I'm going out for a few hours.... the ammonia/nitrite/nitrate is 0/0/~10 (nitrate one is so broad, but its defs not darker than the 10ppm orange. This was all pre-change so it should be lower now too.

If you look at the dead ones, one is kinda cloudy, whereas the rest are quite translucent. Not sure if thats what they do after dying or if thats what caused it to die :(

1
RahmsOP•

The pH is between 7 and 7.2 now, which seems reasonable. The remaining 5 fishies seem happy enough.

I'm thinking the filter could possibly have been too strong. I had put sponge over the outlet, but the fish still seemed to be fighting something... maybe the intake was still pretty powerful. I cut a bottle in half and put it over the main body of the filter and now they seem a bit more mobile.

edit: another fish is on the bottom below the filter, breathing heavily. Pretty sure it's gonna die. FUCKS SAKE.

Is there anything that can lead to low oxygen in the water?

1
LadyFishington•

Normally a fish breathing heavily is some kind of ammonia poisoning, ammonia damages their gills and they have trouble breathing. If you think there is a lack of oxygen, get an air pump with an air stone or something similar. What kind of filter do you have/what size tank.

2
RahmsOP•

its a 15 gallon I guess.... I'm english so I'll work in litres! 63.

The filter is a pretty cheap one off amazon: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Aquarium-All-Pond-Solutions-600IF/dp/B002NLO9PG/ref=sr_1_7?s=pet-supplies&ie=UTF8&qid=1353779290&sr=1-7

Sorry for horrible link, not on my own (RES) PC. It's really high filtration for the size of the tank (600L/h for a 60L tank). Tempted to just buy the smaller one for 7 quid and see how it fares.

Another fish died while I was away :( Ammonia is definitely 0 by the way...

Do dying plants release anything nasty? Have one fern leaf thats a bit brown.... I'll also prod the sand with the tweezers, to make sure there's no anaerobic stuff going on. I really am stumped.

1
LadyFishington•

I'm English as well, so litres is fine by me. I have the same filter in my 180l (along with another 800l/h one) and I really like it. The plastic casing is cheap but nothing wrong with the filter. What I don't like is there's no way to turn down the flow so your filter may be a bit strong for them. Are they struggling against it? You can always direct the flow against the glass behind it just to calm it down a bit.

Dying plants will give off ammonia, but not sure about anything else. You could get a snail to eat some dying stuff if you want. Sorry not sure what's happening to your fish. Sometimes they just have a disease that's impossible to diagnose without an autopsy. You could ask where you got them from if they can look into fish deaths for you.

2
Pllatinum•

The sudden changes in any aspect of water conditions can kill or stress them, making them more susceptible to disease.

3
RahmsOP•

I'm just a bit worried if this is going to be a repeated thing :< I'm planning on getting a betta in the next few weeks....

1
Pllatinum•

It's the initial shock that gets them. Extend the introduction process by an hour or so for your fish. Open the bag and slowly put in tank water over a long period of time, while still floating the bag.

3
RahmsOP•

Is that still likely, if another fish has died yesterday? We're getting a few days on from when they were introduced... but it could be secondary stuff now (like their small school stressing them?).

It's really really annoying, because I spent ages lurking here, had the tank for probably 3 months and did everything I could find online :< Ah well. Maybe the fish were quite fragile, since they were really tiny. Hopefully a betta will be OK.... and if so, I'll get a school of (dwarf) rainbowfish or something, so that they're a bit less sensitive.

edit: obviously if they all die, I'm going to do big water changes daily for a few days first. Something must be in there...

1
Pllatinum•

What you could do is take your water to your LFS and get it tested for free. Careful on big water changes, as it could upset the cycle if it isn't solidly established.

2
ensignrolaren•

How did you introduce the fish?

My practices: I acclimatize fish by keeping them in the dark for the car ride home as much as possible (I put the bag in a small insulated lunch carrier), then gently empty their bag into a small bucket on the foor below the tank. I string an airline, with a regulator set to 1-2 drips per second, from the tank to their bucket. I cover the bucket with a towel, again to keep out the light, and leave it alone for several hours. The tank water slowly drips into the bag water in the bucket, slowly acclimatizing the fish to differences in temperature, pH, and other values. I also keep the tank lights off till the next day.

This works as long as the ambient temperature doesn't chill or heat the water dripping into the bucket too much.

I never lose fish to temperature or pH shock anymore.

2
RahmsOP•

This sounds good, but my room is probably around 16 degrees C, while my tank is at 23. I floated the bag for 20 mins, added a pint of water from the tank and gave them another 20 mins, then did it one more time before emptying the bag into my tank. I intended to fish them out with a net instead of putting the shop water in my tank, but they're so small I was afraid of hurting them.

2
ensignrolaren•

I could be wrong but I don't think that's too huge of a difference in ambient to tank temperature. If you'd like to even it out a little, could you consider running a heater, if you have one, before and during the time you're acclimatizing the fish?

You might also try pinning a towel over the airline from the tank to the bucket... just trying to think of alternate ways to insulate the line.

It really is worth it to use this method. I haven't lost a fish to shock since I've been doing this, even delicate rummynose tetras.

2
RahmsOP•

I do actually have an (untested) heater that came with the tank, so I guess I could run that in a bucket, although I'm not sure how I could empty the fish into the bucket straight away, since they don't come with enough water to fill it to an acceptable level?

2
ensignrolaren•

Oh sorry, 2 miscommunications here.

I actually meant a room heater– just so the ambient temperature doesn't change the temperature of the water dripping into the bucket through the airline. Wouldn't want to heat the water the fish are in since there isn't enough and we want them adjusted to the tank temperature anyways.

Also, as far as water goes, I have a standard 5 gallon bucket from Lowe's and although obviously the bag doesn't fill this bucket up very much at all, they're fine. Large or tall fish are a different story I imagine, but they come with more water anyway. I use this method with rummynose tetras, shrimp, and sterbai cories, and they are just fine with just enough water to swim around in. If the water is too shallow, you can tilt the bucket and secure it so that they have a somewhat deeper pool of water. This gives them less horizontal space, though.

Or you could use a 1 gallon bucket.

Whatever bucket you use, I have found that a solid/opaque bucket is best, since it keeps more light out.

2