r/AskReddit•
jbor613

Just saw the Red Dawn remake, and absolutely loved it. When have you seen a movie despite terrible reviews and been surprised?

Granted, it was exactly what most of the reviews said: it had terrible acting, it was predictable, and it was nothing like the original. But damn it, it was fun! I knew exactly who was going to die and almost exactly WHEN they were going to die. The dialog was cheesy. And it almost felt like an insult to the original (which I love, though I do consider it a semi-subpar movie in places). But it still, somehow, manages to get a 7/10 in my book.

Posted Nov 24, 2012, 12:55 AM UTC

07
[deleted]•

Waterworld

3
jbor613OP•

YES! And Postman. Both are in my top 30.

...maybe I just have bad taste?

3
[deleted]•

Yup and Yup and Yup and Yup.

2
jvonnd•

Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter. It didn't get horrible reviews, but I loved it and thought it deserved much better.

3
JonAudette•

If you "loved" a 7/10, then it'll be a weak 4 in my book. Definitely skipping it.

1
jbor613OP•

My rating system:

... 7. Love 8. Would marry 9. Would cheat on 8 with little to no regrets. 10. Would have sex with, even if 10 resisted. Would probably make 8 and 9 watch.

3
SadlyIamJustaHead•

Same. I don't understand how people use all of their rating system. On netflix a 3 is a good movie, 4 a must see, 5 reserved for frickin amazing movies.

2