r/microsoft•
Podspi

WinRT tablet with inking support?

Does anybody know of a good WinRT (or even any) WinRT tablet with inking support? I know there are a few Win 8 tablets with an active digitizer, but they are all expensive x86 models, with all the disadvantages that x86 brings (heavier, actively cooled, lower battery life).

What I am looking for is a WinRT tablet with a wacom or comparable active digitzer for use in an academic setting. Does anybody know if one of those exist? I was hoping the Surface would fit the bill, but for reasons unfathomable to me, they left it out...

Posted Nov 28, 2012, 6:55 PM UTC

1116
toaster1•

Thinkpad Tablet II? It's not RT, it's Intel Atom- but Intel Atom is basically RT's benefits with x86's benefits.

2
PodspiOP•

I was thinking of that. The lack of a proper dock is kind of a bummer, but it does look like the dock/stand allows charging through a small cable.

Do you happen to know if it is passively cooled, though? If it is, then that looks like a winner.

1
Uncled1023•

The Thinkpad Tablet 2 does not have a fan, and the dock is pretty nice, nicer i think then the keyboard/dock other tablets have, with the inclusion of ethernet port and more USB ports. Also, it has a full digitizer and built in pen. I believe it will be 1024 levels, but i'm not certain.

2
PodspiOP•

Hrm, interesting. My impression was you could not fold the tablet up in the dock, and that it might be unsuitable for using it like a netbook (ie, on your lap). Lenovo's own website calls it a 'stand' rather than a dock.

I'm still a little hesitant to pick up an Atom-based machine (I am a victim of the old victim, err user, of an old N270), but I guess they are still more powerful than any ARM-based tablet would be.

1
Uncled1023•

well the dock is a dock. it does not fold though, you are correct. It does have a keyboard dock though as well that you could set on your lap. this one folds flat and you can carry it with your tablet.

I've played with a couple of the new atom based tablets, and they have been powerful. No lagging or hiccups i've noticed.

1
toaster1•

I don't know. On Baconit right now so can't give a link, but The Verge has a good product database, so check there to know more. :)

1
PodspiOP•

There is also the Samsung ATIV.

Pretty sure the s-pen is active (hover support). The keyboard dock on that looks slightly sturdier (you can actually use it as a ultraportable), but no battery...

1
xarismata•

I have an Asus VivoPad RT and pen input works great with any generic capacitive tablet pen. I found one online for under 10 bucks. Not a digitizer, but inking input is supported natively by all touch screens as it is part of windows 8.

1
phazonoverload•

That's not right. Windows RT does not support inking at all. A capacitive stylus acts as if it was touch input.

2
PodspiOP•

Honestly, I think it is difficult for people who have never used an active digitizer to understand why it is so much better than using something like a capacitive stylus. I do think you can do basic 'inking' on capacitive tablets, but there isn't any pressure sensitivity or hover capabilities, obviously.

2
xarismata•

I guess it depends on what is meant by inking. I'm not planning on doing art, so the important part for me is handwriting input and recognition, which Windows 8/RT handles fine.

1
gadgetsan•

i am also looking for that, you might want to wait for the Surface Pro

1
PodspiOP•

Only downside to the Surface Pro is that it is Ivy Bridge based, which is great for a desktop or laptop, but not-so-great for a tablet. Especially because Ivy Bridge does not support connected standby like ARM (and apparently Atom)-based tablets do.

I feel like Microsoft made a huge mistake not making the SurfaceRT ink-enabled.

3
shoan120•

I agree with you completely. I really love the Rt but without inking I don't think I can buy it.

3
PodspiOP•

Another alternative is the Samsung ATIV 500t. It is a bit larger (11.5") and Atom based, but has inking and an (optional) dock.

I actually prefer it to the Surface, but of course the build quality isn't as good (Samsung), and when you open it the first thing you have to do is update the drivers and firmware because out of the box it is a complete disaster.

None of the other inking-based slates have been reasonably priced, imho.

1