[LTR] Andúril, Flame of the West

Spoiler

https://i.redd.it/46mdy81zdf4b1.jpg

Andúril, Flame of the West 3

Legendary Artifact- Equipment [mythic]

Equipped creature gets +3/+1.

Whenever equipped creature attacks, create two tapped 1/1 white Spirit creature tokens with flying. If that creature is legendary, instead create two of those tokens that are tapped and attacking.

Equip 2

Given how this thing is costed it'll be pretty hard to avoid comparisons to the swords of X/Y cycle. It really does just feel like the 11th sword TBH.

Unsure how to feel about it. My realist side says that if the swords of X/Y aren't good enough, then this thing is probably going to fall into the same bin. It's powerful, but i'm not sure whether it's better than SoFaF or SoFI, and both of those are fairly rare to see anyway.

But my experimentation side says, this thing seems like it can snowball pretty hard. Really feels like the "army in a can" equipment. Once you connect things seems like they get out of hand really fast. Also worth noting you get the trigger on attack, which is different the swords. If its blocked or swings at a planeswalker you still get value, which isn't true of the Swords cycle.

I can see decks like DnT liking it, but i'm also not an expert on the topic. +3/+1 is no joke and it creating more evasive bodies to pressure is exactly what DnT wants. If DnT ever connects with this thing it feels like point removal is invalid, just too many bodies. I wouldn't be shocked if it found a home here.

In stoneblade its more iffy. The volume of bodies to carry this thing just isn't there like in DnT, and TNN is at an all time low. At the same time though this thing is a lot harder to handle than kaldra/batterskull which can be taken offline by a single point removal spell. Maybe its good enough to bring back TNN in these sorts of decks?

Posted Jun 6, 2023, 5:19 PM UTC · edited

019
Ezili•

"D&T wants this" is a meme. You wouldn't play this in a deck without Stoneblade to find it, and in a Stoneblade deck why would you want to do this specifically? If you can find a Stoneblade tokens-matter deck you still have to justify this over the living weapons which also make tokens. I think you're right the other three mana swords just dominate the desire for something like this. They offer a meta call about colors whereas this is much more bland. This is the fifth best option for equipment after kaldra, batterskull, jitte, the swords, and lion sash.

17
Klutchtastik•

Don't forget Shadowspear! It's better than this too lol.

4
Turn1_GSZ•

This unfortunately falls into the category of “cool, middle power card that doesn’t solve any problems”.

Batterskull is a decent clock that gains a ton of life.

Jitte stops mana dorks with upside

Kaldra is an insane and fast beater with indestructible

Sash is graveyard hate

Torch gets the initiative and powers through it with blink effects

This makes an attacking creature an army in a can. However you have to untap and attack with a dude. If they remove your guy or can ignore the tokens it doesn’t do anything. If SoFaI didn’t make the cut when UR delver was 20% of the meta game this isn’t making the cut now.

6
MiraweaveThat Thalia Girl•

u/xjcloud I think the people need a "card bad" in here.

6
xJCloudD&T Streamer & Sky Noodle expert twitch.tv/xjcloud•

Card bad

12
First_RevengeOPEsper/Jeskai Stoneblade•

I fully embrace the card is probably bad. I mostly keep wanting good equipment to come out lmao.

1
SuperAzn727•

Powerful yeah. More powerful than other options absolutely not.

Cool edh card

4
leonprimroseJeskai Colors•

This is going to be an edh card not legacy. It's cool. Just doesn't stack up to the equipment already being played and doesn't have a good place it would fit. I would never tutor this up over any of the other options.

3
EmperorBamboozler•

This post screams 'tell me you don't play DnT without telling me.'

This card is really bad in that shell. DnT has way better clocks than this and playing it + equipping it on t3 and 4 is going to be objectively worse than playing like a flickerwhisp into stoneforge for kaldra at the same mana. Jitte, Kaldra, the swords, and batterskull are all substantially better than this because they are all more versatile. In DnT you are already denying the opp resources, and using that gap to beat down your opp before they overcome the wastelands, rishadan ports, and Thalias. Adding a 3 cmc card that requires a legendary creature to equip and doesn't either have living weapon or completely hose a deck archetype like jitte and sash do is really bad.

2
First_RevengeOPEsper/Jeskai Stoneblade•

Adding a 3 cmc card that requires a legendary creature to equip and doesn't either have living weapon or completely hose a deck archetype like jitte and sash do is really bad.

Slight correction, it doesn't require a legendary creature to equip. You can equip it to anything, there's just a minor perk that comes if you attach it to a legendary creature.

1
EmperorBamboozler•

It's still the same cost as swords, is objectively less versatile than sash or jitte, and isn't close to the game ender as batterskull or Kaldra.

3
RedTheReckless-667•

Jitte is about the base you want to compare equipment to in legacy and this is no where near jitte level of power.

1
wildwalrusaurPox/Stax•

You don't play SoBaM and this is worse than that.

1

This is barely commander playable. Classic WoTC design to hold back when a card needs some boost to be even playable and then go reckless when the cards that need a sanity check from the start.

1
OzyLellowen•

Turn a creature into Geist of Saint Trash

Jokes aside, I dont think this beats out any currently avalible equipment for decks that play equipment. Not when the competition is [[Batterskull]], [[Kuldra Compleat]], and (most importantly [[Jitte]]

If the equipment doesn't win you the game for being in play for being in play uncontested, then it better be a cheerio or it isn't seeing play.

Edit: after thinking about this card a bit more: I think I agree with your point about an army in a can. The normal issue with equipment is that you have to have a creature in play, and pay to equip to said creature. The best ones are either more than powerful enough to make up for this (SoFI and SoFF), come pre attached (batterskull) or both (kuldra)

Every attack with the sword puts you up at least one creature, so this might be comparable to butterblossom, but with Jitte style "must get to combat" restrictions instead of the life loss.

In that context the card is a bit more interesting, but I still don't see this having a home in any current legacy decks.

1
MTGCardFetcher•

Batterskull - (G) (SF) (txt)
Kuldra Compleat - (G) (SF) (txt)
Jitte - (G) (SF) (txt)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
max431x•

is the card good? What deck would it play? No clue it just seems to not fit competetive play unless there is a nice combo with it :)

1

A "draft" card at most. There are way better EQs out there

1
Splinterfight•

This seems a lot worse than swords of X/Y. No protection and and probably half the payoff amount. Yes it triggers on attack but being able to require this turn after turn isn’t that threatening. Maybe in some kind of weird humility deck? But even then there’s better token producers

1