Confusion about what sihr exactly is
So I have a general idea about sihr but there are a few things that still confuse me.
How does one do it? There's no mention of any specifics in the quran or hadith afaik. I just keep on hearing random stuff like "go to an abandoned place, draw this, do that", or "write on a piece of paper, do this/that and burn it" and other completely random things. Seems like anyone can make anything up and call it sihr?
Due to its random nature, how can I tell what's sihr? If I saw some piece of paper with random Arabic words and the word Allah written somewhere on it too or something like that I'd just see it as Bidah or some other innovation. So how can you tell that something is sihr vs someone just being delusional/wrong in the head?
Posted Jun 6, 2023, 8:41 PM UTC
The sciences of sihr are real and can be learned. The things you will find on the internet may be real or may be bastardized versions of it, or they may be anecdotal in a sense that it worked for some in the past.
This science is for all intents and purposes forbidden to learn, unless for academic purposes. There have been scholars who have written about it and tried it out and written about it that it works/is real. We do not need to test this out again as the scholars of Islam have written about it before. I do not believe anyone is warranted to learn about it in an academical way as it is not beneficial.
Since you ask, I think it is safe to say that you are not equipped to be able to academically learn about sihr without endangering yourself.
Know that it is better to stay away from it, it is real, it is forbidden and it will cause destruction to yourself and others around you.
Where did they get it from? How could they determine whether something was a result of their sihr or mere coincidence? This kinda connects to my 2nd question. For example in case of duaa, we know that in the quran and sunnah it is specified how to do them and how they work. I'm not aware of anything like that regarding sihr, could be just people doing random things and claiming that coincidences are a result of their sihr.
They get it from shayaatin, then they write it down/ritualize it and someone else does it. Black magic isn't protected like divine texts so no one knows it's genuine and can be bastardized into something ineffective.
Usually with sehr you get affirmation by djinn or subtle changes in laws of nature. It is a science, one which God has warned us against. Refer to the story of Harut and Marut. Its science, not parlour tricks. Forbidden though.
Unless you are socializing with people in very active black magic circles, people falsely credit bad things happening to black magic. It's often a cultural thing as well. Old people that are superstitious will claim everything is black magic, because of coping mechanisms.
Intriguing, thanks for your insights.