[M] 19 broke up with boyfriend

Hey guys, I need some advice...or maybe just counsel. I broke up with my boyfriend last night. He was great. Loving, kind, funny, cute. I feel like he was everything someone would ask for in a relationship. We never fought or anything. But at the same time for some reason I just didn't feel as strongly about him as he felt for me. I just wasn't feeling it. And I feel so terrible because he did absolutely nothing wrong. Nothing at all. He was so great. So I don't know why I was feeling this way but I was. And now I feel so bad whenever I think about it. I know he liked me so much. It just sucks.

TLDR: Broke up with boyfriend. Relationship was great, but just wasn't feeling it. Feel terrible about it.

Anyone go through anything similar? How can it be so good but at the same time I just wasn't feeling it?