If there is a WoW2, will it have the same "magic" as early WoW?

When people talk in topics about their favorite gaming experiences and the things they're most nostalgic about, one thing that comes up time and time again is "early WoW". Because of this, and how they talk about it, I've always felt like I missed out on something that would have been amazing had I played it back then, and I always wished I could have gotten in on that. So, assuming Blizzard makes a WoW2, which I imagine they eventually (5 years from now? maybe more?) will, would it have that same magic that early WoW did, assuming that I never played the original? Or was the magic simply age based? I'm 21 now, was the magic of early WoW simply the effect of the people playing it at the time being 14 year olds? Hell, if the sequel does come out in 5 years, I'd be 26, could I possibly still get that "magical experience"? Just curious what you guys think.