Psychological evaluation of Livia Soprano

I've started rewatching The Sopranos from the beginning and there's a scene between Dr. Melfi and Tony where she suggests that Livia may have Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) which is now often referred to as Emotionally Unstable Personality Disorder. However, on this latest of rewatches I've noticed that Livia's behaviour doesn't really conform to what I understand to be associated behaviour of BPD but rather of a Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD). Namely, that Livia doesn't seem emotionally unstable but rather defaults into presenting herself as the protagonist of some awful tragedy. Additionally, she seems to become exceptionally vengeful in a way that I believe typifies narcissistic rage whenever she is criticised or denied.

I was wondering if anyone has done a psychological evaluation of Livia Soprano or has more insights into her behaviour than I do.

Posted Jun 10, 2023, 10:51 PM UTC

2319
manofwar26•

Now I don't like that kind of tawk! It upsets me !

52
bobdylansmoustache•

She's a cunt

35
stevie109195•

Psychiatry is a racket for the Jews

35
Random-Cpl•

Go on now, go into the ham, and take the carving knife and stab me, here, here, now, please! It would hurt me less than what you just said!

21
onebag25lbs•

You can be both. A narcissist with BPD.

17
Spider_JewOP•

Yeah but I'm not sure that Livia is both. I think the 2nd hand, off hand diagnosis from Dr Melfi comes as a result of how Tony describes her, as irrational and emotional. Whereas scenes that she's in she's all but screaming "tragedy, tragedy" like some Shakespearian pantomime.

Also if someone were to be diagnosed with multiple personality disorders, they tend to diagnose the more prominent one then say they have traits of the other. Either that or just call it (I think it's called) complex or compound personality disorder.

Obviously, this is from my own readings on the subject but I'm certainly not a medical professional.

6

Mental health professional here, this answer is al dente

11

Thank you for that ....47 years of Livia so lots of real life experience. Im no Dr just tried to learn what happened.
It's sounded correct to me ....its nice to have a professional weigh in .

1
twinkle90505•

Everyone I've known who was diagnosed BPD (directly, not hearing someone else's account) absolutely says things that make themselves appear to be the center of a big sad drama.

7
CellularTelephoner•

While blaming others for their shit, of course. They are capable of feeling A LOT OF EMPATHY though - for themselves.

2
ahsokas_revenge•

Melfi's description of BPD also gets some things fundamentally wrong. It's completely inaccurate to say that people with borderline feel "no compassion, no empathy." She also describes "splitting behavior" as pitting people against each other — that is not at all what splitting means in the context of BPD.

Unfortunately, especially given its premise, the show has some poorly researched writing around mental health and psychiatry, in some cases contributing to longstanding stigmas and misconceptions.

4
YA-definitely-TA•

as someone with BPD, I totally agree with your comment.

I'm 31 and had only seen the 1st season of sopranos when it first came out and I was a kid... I was watching this scene you are talking about just last week and my jaw dropped at Melfi's explanation of BPD AND how she was claiming that is what Tony's mom has/had...

if anything, we with BPD feel TOO MUCH, not too little... not to say that everyone with BPD behaves the same, but still.. it isn't like we lack empathy or sympathy for others..

I was misdiagnosed with bi-polar for years... because funnily enough bpd and bi polar are quite similar in certain aspects .. such as, a person with bi polar disorder will be manic for days/weeks, then depressed for days/weeks and go through this cycle back and forth..... where as someone like myself with bpd goes through this range in just a day or 2. over and over again.. not weeks/months... we are/can be extremely sensitive. I have only recently I the past couple years been able to get a handle on my own emotions and why I feel the way I do etc. how to change these things and improve myself... because even though all feelings are okay, not all behaviors are okay!

all this to say though that someone with bpd has "no compassion, no empathy" makes me very sad, ironically enough.. the way Melfi describes people with BPD makes us sound like psychopathic monsters.

people watch this shit and believe it too unfortunately... it is incorrect and harmful, to say the least. 😪

1
nyczepfan•

As someone with BPD, I absolutely agree with you. if anything, I have too much sympathy/empathy for people and I certainly don’t try to pit people against eachother. splitting is just the swing from “they’re the best” to “they suck”.

1
thePieOMy•

Don't wave your hanky at me.

It's simple she can't accept love. Very debilitating if you think about it but noticeable when the body slows down. Janice is more the prime example of this. Tony also it's prominent in his whole being. He is never satisfied and when he is it's not for long even though he busts his ass all day long but can't pick up his own smoked turkey.

11
Hydrokratom•

NPD & BPD have some similarities. You can get diagnosed with both. John Hinckley was diagnosed with both after he shot Ronald Reagan, along with other disorders.

You ask different professionals and you might get different answers.

6
GotWheaten•

Who me?

5

A. She was a hooar

4
Peter7474•

Well, if it bothers you, maybe you better talk to a psychiatrist...

4

You might try The Psychology of The Sopranos.

Some have called it "The Sopranos Effect"--the quiet that descends just before a new episode of the hit TV series is aired. Stores are deserted, restaurants quiet--and for patients of distinguished psychoanalyst and author Glen Gabbard, desperate calls for help go unreturned. Why, Dr. Gabbard wondered, have the misadventures of a middle-aged thug won the largest audience in HBO history? What is it about the characters and their relationships that draws us in so completely? What can we learn about ourselves from going inside the heads of these outlaws from New Jersey? In The Psychology of the Sopranos Dr. Gabbard draws on his vast professional experience (and his near-obsessive preoccupation with Tony's two "families") to delve into the psychology of the characters, the show's depiction of therapy, and how "The Sopranos" dramatically showcases the psychological ambiguities and conflicts in our own lives. Indeed, part of the show's popularity, he argues, is the spotlight it throws on viewers' psychological issues--from panic attacks and existential angst to codes of honor and moral indiscretions. With his tongue planted only lightly in his cheek, Gabbard poses the questions so many of us have pondered on Monday mornings: Is Tony's therapy working? And how is it possible for him and his "families" to reconcile the mundane and the monstrous? His answers will surprise and delight loyal fans. This book was not prepared, licensed, approved, or endorsed by any entity involved in creating or producing the "Sopranos" television series.Mafia don Tony Soprano, his family, his work "associates," and his therapist, Dr. Jennifer Melfi, have captured the imagination (and the fanatical devotion) of more than 11 million viewers. The show has garnered rave reviews for its writing and acting and has won a loyal following of educated viewers, who appreciate the sharp wit, the Machiavellian plot turns, and the Shakespearean character development of this extraordinarily well-crafted drama. Find the answers in The Psychology of the Sopranos: Is Tony a psychopath--or is he an American everyman putting bread on the table in the best way he knows how? Is Livia a modern-day Medea or a victim caught in mob mentality? Is Carmella an accomplice or an innocent? Who's more corrupt, Tony Soprano or Father Phil? Is Tony doomed to desire women who make him feel as bad as Mom did? Can a man who commits bad acts still teach his children to be good?

3
Spider_JewOP•

I literally didn't know this was a thing. Thank you!

1

Is the fact that it's the greatest show of all time any indictor of the prevelence NpD In society ?? I've read reviews of the show .. "great commentary of end of an era" and that stuff mean nothong to me ....I watch the show for therapy and I was curious to your opinion ?

1
SaintLickALot•

She couldn't trust Tony after he lied. She should have forgiven him but some people just can't forget

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
cthulu998•

I wish the Lord would take me now...

1

It's all a big nothing

GET THE COOKIES

1
imnotaloony•

She's dead to me

1
bongotai•

Livia is as NPD as you can get: her constant obsession for being right, her outright dismissal of other people''s opinions, her manipulative way of relating to every single person that surrounds her, her abusive ways (often using guilt and emotional blackmail ) of relating to her son and other family members, faking medical symptoms and manipulating even experienced medical professionals. In essence, she is manipulative, self-centered, and emotionally cold, unable to empathyze with aynone other than herself.

1

More specifically ...woundnt she be considered the classic .... covert narc? I had Livia for a mother ...47 years before I knew anything . I watch the sopranos for fun when it aired . I didn't know anything.....now I watch it as therapy .....mind blowing

1

Thank you . Dead on . I had Livia as a mother . THAT PORTRAYAL IS WHY THE covert narc is pure evil . .. they are worse than a mignant narc ... Just by a inch .anyone that says livoa isnt 100 percent accurate
..hasn't lived it. ..47 years of lying it ...I lack medical knowledge .....but ive lived it. That's exactly how they are ...controlling to everything aspect of evweythng

The only real question. I have left is are they conscious anymore of what they are evem doing ?? The classic line about Tony's sister just after she killed Riche ... She says the " Janice has been jilted again ....story of her life" ....tony pools at her

1
lightlyskipping•

A year late to this but I’m also rewatching Sops as a 50 year old daughter of a Livia. It’s devastating accepting what me and my sisters have lived with. NPD all the way. You can never do anything right. You only please by suffering. She has no compassion and no reality beyond her own anger, misery and negativity.

1

This quotes are just one I remember . ..if I miss a word or so ...forgive me . 47 years of of a mother like Livia .....and a malignant father .. my sisters escaped.....I sis mot .....the sopranos show has helped me ...just the psychological stuff .. ....

GET THE COOKIES

WHAT MAKES YOU THINK YOUR SO SPECIAL .....

1

What makes you think your so special... . It's all a big nothing . In the end you did alone.....

GET THE COOKIES .....

ALL I CAN SAY IS DAUGHTERS ARE BETTER THAN SONS .....

1