"Campaigns have notched slightly lower impression delivery and, consequently, slightly higher CPMs, over the blackout days, ". This is huge! This shows that advertisers are already concerned about long-term reductions in ad traffic from subs going dark indefinitely!
adweek.com/social-marketing/ripples-through-r...Posted Jun 14, 2023, 3:24 PM UTC
And also:
This is why the smaller, niche subreddits need to participate. If advertisers can't target their desired demographics, they'll back out.
Oohh…dear. I think it may be beneficial for others to take a peak into the subs where ad campaigns are discussed and other troubleshooting.
There are a lot of issues with ad-delivery already and many users complain that their campaigns aren’t getting any [practical/useful] reach to begin with; this was in December.
Every new post on that sub was regexed for keywords and closed shortly after going live; but not before other frustrated users commented how they were having the same issue.
The ‘Ads Formula’ training site has been live for about a year now and it’s a fairly ambitious take on what advertisers can expect with running campaigns on this platform; but when we look at actual discussion and impact about those campaigns by smaller ad-buyers it becomes clear that the value for advertisers isn’t derived from putting an ad in front of you hoping for a conversion - but - [as you’d expect] data mining.
Ad-spend is important, of course. But the complaints discussed in the article were problems before sub privatization so it’s more of a continuation of underlying problems than something new as a result of this.
This is part of why I'm keeping my relatively-small city-based sub dark, so that no advertising for services here can be targeted to it.
Are you kidding me? Long view? u/Spez wants his IPO and then he's out with a fat bonus.
Curious why people are targeting spez and not the actual owners of the company
I haven’t seen any evidence spez kept a single share of Reddit when advance media bought it from him in 2006
if he does have some stock package as the ceo it’s minuscule next to the stock owned by the actual investors
spez doesn’t have any voting rights (again, he sold the company he founded in 2006). Andersen Horowitz, Snoop Dogg, and others actually make the decision if the ceo is doing a good job or not. Spezs job is to keep them, not redditors, not Reddit employees, happy
Remember when the public was pressuring the twitter CEO not to sell to musk? There were credible calls from shareholder to sue the ceo if he doesn’t. Because 100% of his job is to make shareholders the most money
Did the investors force him to publicly lie about the developer of Apollo? Did they force him to give arrogant, dismissive quotes to multiple news outlets? Did they force him to send equally dismissive internal memos to employees?
Spez is an ego-driven twat who gets off on the idea of shutting down third party apps. The fact he doesn't even stand to personally benefit from the enshittification of reddit just makes him all the more detestable.
Go check out reddit's corporate history. They sold to Conde Nast and then there were a bunch of other things and then the founders bought it back.
There were cheers when spez came back. That is how bad it was before.
[removed]
You only mod two subs and they are both open.
[removed]
Unpopular opinion but they will simply resort to broader targeting or even 3rd party cookie (which is much less effective these days). We need to disrupt their AMAs and pressure advertisers.
This kind of narrow targeting is the unique benefit that Reddit can provide to advertisers. They lose that advantage when they offer broader targeting. It's possible that would be enough to lose them customers
I’m not certain how “savvy” their analysis backend is, but it’s entirely possible to analyse comments into categories like ad-safe or even break it down to a few key major topics.
There’s a lot of broaden up if they wanted to and people continue to interact with the websites. Also, from what I know , some advertisers don’t care, they just want people of a certain location.
[removed]
They still do it. They even mention it in the article.
Sure, but it's still less effective than otherwise.
Browsers block 3rd party cookies these days
Safari and Firefox do, Chrome does not. I'm not familiar with Edge.
Chrome has a setting to block 3rd party cookies, not sure if it's enabled by default or not. You can also use extensions such as Privacy Badger.
Last para from the article:
So it makes a difference.
That’s just because they haven’t done tweaks to the backend to adjust to the current state of subs matching the ads in the backlog. I would imagine Reddit lost a few high performing ad-safe subs like Aww in the blackout. Won’t be long for them to do adjustments and broadly analyse comments into categories like ad-safe or even break it down to a few key major topics.
Can't they just target people who subscribed to those subreddits in the past, even if they're not on the actual subreddit page?
The reason we need the big subs involved is because with them going dark, people would stop visiting Reddit altogether, so there wouldn't be any option to target people. We need to drive down the number of visitors Reddit gets to a point where it hurts the advertising revenue.
the subreddits would get hijacked long before that happens, come on
By who? Is reddit going to hire staff to moderate subreddits? They aren't profitable as it is. Are they going to run a recruitment campaign for "scab" moderators? That will also not play very well. The moderators are in control here, the only way to make a change is for the moderators to not agree, like what happened with AdviceAnimals
Yes. You’re already getting ads on the homepage based on your location and/or interests.
No I'm not, I use a third-par... oh, right
Android + FireFox + uBlock = I haven't seen an ad on Reddit in ages. That's what needs to be targeted.
Yes. But the context in which ads are displayed is also relevant (and a lot more relevant than one might think).
So just being a subscriber to a particular subreddit vs. actually seeing the ad appear in that subreddit can have a substantial impact on metrics.
That’s why it costs more on YouTube to show an ad in front of a Mr. Beast video vs. just targeting people who subscribe to Mr. Beast but showing the ad on any type of content.
There are two other considerations there as well. First is that it is almost certainly cheaper for everyone to say I want this ad about sports equipment shown in the sports subreddit than it is to say they want it shown to subscribers to that subreddit, simply because that latter is more work. The other is that you have to consider those users that don't have an account, don't log in. You can't as easily track their activity, so if you want to show them relevant ads you put them in subreddits related to their content.
The very next sentence: "Advertisers can still target users according to interests and other contexts when they’re accessing the home page."
I wonder how impactful targeted shutdowns can be, if we can disrupt targeted advertising campaigns.
Someone needs to build an ad tracker for seeing how ads are distributed across Reddit, and then we can target the weak points.
I think this is also an important point/article about why subs should be going private, not just blocking new posts. If you can still visit the sub, you can still see the ads, and if you're still interacting, albeit just by comments on stickied posts, then you're just as valuable to advertisers.
Someone needs to make a full post about this. A lot of the responses I've seen going around in niche subs is "we're small, so it wouldn't make much of a difference"
It ABSOLUTELY will!!!