"Campaigns have notched slightly lower impression delivery and, consequently, slightly higher CPMs, over the blackout days, ". This is huge! This shows that advertisers are already concerned about long-term reductions in ad traffic from subs going dark indefinitely!

adweek.com/social-marketing/ripples-through-r...
adweek.com

Posted Jun 14, 2023, 3:24 PM UTC

2.7K260
Manny-Both-Hanz•

Dabaghi notes this pause will be shorter than more prolonged advertiser boycotts on Twitter and Meta. Still, Reddit has been working on its relationships with advertisers, and any accumulated goodwill could be diminished if the precarious situation continues.

And also:

“By directing ads that would have gone to the blacked-out [moderated] pages to the homepage is kind of defeating the point,” said Liam Johnson, senior account director at Brainlabs, who hadn’t seen that particular note from Reddit. “The ads would then just be shown to the masses and outside of any of the contextually relevant locations that advertisers are trying to achieve with Reddit.”

This is why the smaller, niche subreddits need to participate. If advertisers can't target their desired demographics, they'll back out.

269
--DannyPhantom--•

Oohh…dear. I think it may be beneficial for others to take a peak into the subs where ad campaigns are discussed and other troubleshooting.

There are a lot of issues with ad-delivery already and many users complain that their campaigns aren’t getting any [practical/useful] reach to begin with; this was in December.

Every new post on that sub was regexed for keywords and closed shortly after going live; but not before other frustrated users commented how they were having the same issue.

The ‘Ads Formula’ training site has been live for about a year now and it’s a fairly ambitious take on what advertisers can expect with running campaigns on this platform; but when we look at actual discussion and impact about those campaigns by smaller ad-buyers it becomes clear that the value for advertisers isn’t derived from putting an ad in front of you hoping for a conversion - but - [as you’d expect] data mining.

Ad-spend is important, of course. But the complaints discussed in the article were problems before sub privatization so it’s more of a continuation of underlying problems than something new as a result of this.

77

This is part of why I'm keeping my relatively-small city-based sub dark, so that no advertising for services here can be targeted to it.

59
Basoran•

Are you kidding me? Long view? u/Spez wants his IPO and then he's out with a fat bonus.

35
virtual_adam•

Curious why people are targeting spez and not the actual owners of the company

  • I haven’t seen any evidence spez kept a single share of Reddit when advance media bought it from him in 2006

  • if he does have some stock package as the ceo it’s minuscule next to the stock owned by the actual investors

  • spez doesn’t have any voting rights (again, he sold the company he founded in 2006). Andersen Horowitz, Snoop Dogg, and others actually make the decision if the ceo is doing a good job or not. Spezs job is to keep them, not redditors, not Reddit employees, happy

Remember when the public was pressuring the twitter CEO not to sell to musk? There were credible calls from shareholder to sue the ceo if he doesn’t. Because 100% of his job is to make shareholders the most money

18
rubbery_anus•

Did the investors force him to publicly lie about the developer of Apollo? Did they force him to give arrogant, dismissive quotes to multiple news outlets? Did they force him to send equally dismissive internal memos to employees?

Spez is an ego-driven twat who gets off on the idea of shutting down third party apps. The fact he doesn't even stand to personally benefit from the enshittification of reddit just makes him all the more detestable.

31
DevonAndChris•

Go check out reddit's corporate history. They sold to Conde Nast and then there were a bunch of other things and then the founders bought it back.

There were cheers when spez came back. That is how bad it was before.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
DevonAndChris•

This is part of why I'm keeping my relatively-small city-based sub dark

You only mod two subs and they are both open.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
leo-g•

Unpopular opinion but they will simply resort to broader targeting or even 3rd party cookie (which is much less effective these days). We need to disrupt their AMAs and pressure advertisers.

19
AssassinAragorn•

This kind of narrow targeting is the unique benefit that Reddit can provide to advertisers. They lose that advantage when they offer broader targeting. It's possible that would be enough to lose them customers

34
leo-g•

I’m not certain how “savvy” their analysis backend is, but it’s entirely possible to analyse comments into categories like ad-safe or even break it down to a few key major topics.

There’s a lot of broaden up if they wanted to and people continue to interact with the websites. Also, from what I know , some advertisers don’t care, they just want people of a certain location.

6
[deleted]•

[removed]

3
ryanmerket•

The very next sentence: "Advertisers can still target users according to interests and other contexts when they’re accessing the home page."

They still do it. They even mention it in the article.

1
AssassinAragorn•

Sure, but it's still less effective than otherwise.

2

Browsers block 3rd party cookies these days

17
funkybside•

Safari and Firefox do, Chrome does not. I'm not familiar with Edge.

9
TheAngryGoat•

Chrome has a setting to block 3rd party cookies, not sure if it's enabled by default or not. You can also use extensions such as Privacy Badger.

9
AlexanderDaychilde•

Last para from the article:

“By directing ads that would have gone to the blacked-out [moderated] pages to the homepage is kind of defeating the point,” said Liam Johnson, senior account director at Brainlabs, who hadn’t seen that particular note from Reddit. “The ads would then just be shown to the masses and outside of any of the contextually relevant locations that advertisers are trying to achieve with Reddit.”

So it makes a difference.

15
leo-g•

That’s just because they haven’t done tweaks to the backend to adjust to the current state of subs matching the ads in the backlog. I would imagine Reddit lost a few high performing ad-safe subs like Aww in the blackout. Won’t be long for them to do adjustments and broadly analyse comments into categories like ad-safe or even break it down to a few key major topics.

3
falconfetus8•

Can't they just target people who subscribed to those subreddits in the past, even if they're not on the actual subreddit page?

8
LondonPilot•

The reason we need the big subs involved is because with them going dark, people would stop visiting Reddit altogether, so there wouldn't be any option to target people. We need to drive down the number of visitors Reddit gets to a point where it hurts the advertising revenue.

22
yesitsmework•

the subreddits would get hijacked long before that happens, come on

-1†
JoeCoT•

By who? Is reddit going to hire staff to moderate subreddits? They aren't profitable as it is. Are they going to run a recruitment campaign for "scab" moderators? That will also not play very well. The moderators are in control here, the only way to make a change is for the moderators to not agree, like what happened with AdviceAnimals

16
surreal3561•

Yes. You’re already getting ads on the homepage based on your location and/or interests.

3
orthogonius•

No I'm not, I use a third-par... oh, right

11
TheUncleBob•

Android + FireFox + uBlock = I haven't seen an ad on Reddit in ages. That's what needs to be targeted.

3
PhAnToM444•

Yes. But the context in which ads are displayed is also relevant (and a lot more relevant than one might think).

So just being a subscriber to a particular subreddit vs. actually seeing the ad appear in that subreddit can have a substantial impact on metrics.

That’s why it costs more on YouTube to show an ad in front of a Mr. Beast video vs. just targeting people who subscribe to Mr. Beast but showing the ad on any type of content.

3
hyperman500•

There are two other considerations there as well. First is that it is almost certainly cheaper for everyone to say I want this ad about sports equipment shown in the sports subreddit than it is to say they want it shown to subscribers to that subreddit, simply because that latter is more work. The other is that you have to consider those users that don't have an account, don't log in. You can't as easily track their activity, so if you want to show them relevant ads you put them in subreddits related to their content.

2
ryanmerket•

The very next sentence: "Advertisers can still target users according to interests and other contexts when they’re accessing the home page."

2
EmbarrassedHelp•

I wonder how impactful targeted shutdowns can be, if we can disrupt targeted advertising campaigns.

Someone needs to build an ad tracker for seeing how ads are distributed across Reddit, and then we can target the weak points.

1
m00nh34d•

I think this is also an important point/article about why subs should be going private, not just blocking new posts. If you can still visit the sub, you can still see the ads, and if you're still interacting, albeit just by comments on stickied posts, then you're just as valuable to advertisers.

1
BornVolcano•

Someone needs to make a full post about this. A lot of the responses I've seen going around in niche subs is "we're small, so it wouldn't make much of a difference"

It ABSOLUTELY will!!!

1
AssassinAragorn•

Some really important takeaways:

  • Reddit has had to make good/give free advertising to clients.

  • Clients have delayed planned ad campaigns.

  • There would be consideration to reduce spending if the protest continued for 2 weeks.

  • A large advertising firm, Brainlabs, is quoted as saying general advertisement on Reddit isn't a replacement for nor as valuable as the targeted ads Reddit can otherwise provide.

This is working, but 2 days isn't enough. It's significant enough to raise flags and eyebrows, but it needs to go for longer to be effective. Every single sub is helping, since the smaller subs and niche communities are desirable to advertisers.

It's an irony that using Reddit is the best way to organize against Reddit. I'd recommend checking out Lemmy as well, that's what I used through the blackout to see how things were going. Here's the page for discussing Reddit happenings: https://lemmy.ml/c/reddit

240
tuctrohs•

• There would be consideration to reduce spending if the protest continued for 2 weeks.

That's an important point.

Note that some comments with links to reddit competition are being removed. Will be interesting to see if that happens to yours.

54
Spanktank35•

We should prefer the platform dying over them turning us into products. This is a critical crossroads, if we don't make this stand then reddit will continue to sell out until the platform is dead.

We need to make it crystal clear that they cannot take advantage of their users. Imagine how easy it is for huffman to be convinced to implement changes like this when he sees how much money it would make him. He certainly doesn't think the community could make him pay in the short-term.

Far too many social media platforms have done exactly this, but their communities never banded together when it started happening. And that just guaranteed a slow death of the platform.

35
jalepinocheezit•

That's where I am....I use the official ap, I'm not blind and I'm not a mod...but I'll be goddammed if I'm not going to protest bullshit where I can make a difference for once. All we ever do is get shit all over anymore.

Frankly I'm shocked the whole site isn't dark...except for a choice few that don't understand how to work together for a greater cause (and the ones that really should stay open)

23
AssassinAragorn•

This is the largest protest Reddit has seen. If people just roll over, they know they can make any change, no matter how unpopular.

18
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
yun-harla•

Alternatively, 2 days is enough as a demonstration if the community is willing and able do it again at critical times — like before an IPO. That way, the community retains power on an ongoing basis, and both the current owners and prospective investors will be wary of that.

27
ManofManyTalentz•

This one.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1

Unfortunately the way spez is acting, should the community back down now, he'll do everything he can to make sure they cant rise up again. It's how autocrats work.

1
EnormousCaramel•

A friend of mine work in advertising. They get paid to tell companies where and why they should advertise.

I flat out told them whats going on. They are actively advising clients/companies to hold off on reddit advertising for now.

19
depressionlmfao•

2 protest sister servers on discord (5k members) have agreed to migrate to Kbin and lemmy (with preference for kbin). https://kbin.social/m/RedditMigration (7k members)

mass migration + indefinite blackouts = POWERHOUSE.

18
AssassinAragorn•

I'll keep an eye on this, thanks! May as well keep a foot in the door for both.

6
jalepinocheezit•

Saved thanks

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
jmbluechip•

get a life

1

Anyone else get jank formatting and css on lemmy via mobile browser?

1
AssassinAragorn•

Definitely hit or miss

1
TurdFergusonlol•

I will ask yet again, what really is the point here again?

At this point I really think mods are just trying to stick is to Reddit because Reddit said this would blow over. “We’ll show them!!”

Mods have free access to API for their mod tools and any non commercial uses like accessibility. Expecting Reddit to basically subsidize another company when their own company isn’t profitable is absolutely asinine. Reddit owes nothing to a direct competitor.

-20
pk2317•

Two big problems:

There are many moderation tools/abilities which are not available in the official app, but were built into other apps. So “having free access to the API for mod tools” only works (maybe) on a desktop computer, or maybe a mobile browser. And that assumes the developers of those tools continue to maintain them.

And “non-commercial use” means that someone has to build and maintain a separate app just for accessibility, at their own cost/expense, and they can’t do anything at all to recoup costs. Previously this was just…something that was naturally included in other 3rd party apps, as a standard feature, and not their one and only purpose.

9
CrimsonMorbus•

Are you forgetting the nsfw subs? Even if someone pays for access to API, nsfw content is going to be unable outside the main app

8
Tigress92•

Has anyone delivered any proof yet to the claim that Reddit not profitable? Or is it still all just baseless assumptions?

6
TurdFergusonlol•

They don’t have to provide proof as a private company. But when the IPO drops very soon, they will have to release P&Ls and I can’t imagine they would make a huge swing in either direction in the span of just a few months.

4
Tigress92•

They dont have to provide proof, but then they also dont get to make claims. You can't say something like 'we're not making profit' and then provide no factual proof for that, that's just shady, at best.

9
Dankmemes_-•

I would also like to point out this article isn't wishful thinking from a political news site that would have a corporation going broke within their interests

This is article is from Adweek, a trade magazine. Trade magazines market towards people within in an industry. Adweek, naturally, is a trade magazine for advertisers and marketers. So when they say something will negatively affect the advertisers, they mean it, and their informing the advertisers about it.

224

So what you're saying is that this is basically the most credible source possible for market impact, then?

76
Dankmemes_-•

I am not an expert so I can't confirm it , but I imagine so. If I were an advertiser, I probably wouldn't read a magazine that knows nothing about advertising.

52
MightyPitchfork•

I am an industry professional with over 20 years in digital marketing. Adweek is a reliable source.

It is very US centric, and does focus on other format (mostly more traditional formats like print, broadcast, etc), but if they report what the industry is seeing, then it's what individual advertisers are reporting.

I personally am not currently running any advertising on Reddit, not due to the protest, simply that it's not the right platform for any of my current clients, but something like this protest would have a clear impact on the profitability of any campaign (you won't believe what Musk's actions on Twitter have done for advertising there).

52
tragopanic•

20 decades is a long time.

23
YT-Deliveries•

(you won't believe what Musk's actions on Twitter have done for advertising there).

Do tell.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Aleashed•

So we won the war? Did we do it guys or didn’t we?

-10
dudleydidwrong•

At best we won a skirmish.

6
NatoBoram•

We won 2% of the war.

That's it.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
kinmix•

They are also making a very interesting point that explains why, as leaked memo says, reddit so far didn't see a significant impact on the revenue, and also why this is just a delayed reaction.

Reddit told advertisers that it was redirecting impressions lost from these blacked-out subreddits to the home page

Campaigns have notched slightly lower impression delivery and consequently, slightly higher CPMs, over the days of the blackout, Johnson said.

Basically, reddit decided to automatically move ads from more relevant locations (individual subs) to the less relevant location (homepage), and while doing that they've artificially created a higher demand for ads on the homepage which made those ads more expensive.

Advertisers cannot be happy about it. But it takes time to move the advertising budgets around. Once the weekly reports will come in showing that the ads became more expensive and less engaging, budgets will move and it is then when Reddit Inc will get the revenue hit.

42
neumaticc•

this guy markets.

1
LondonPilot•

If the performance weakness continues for a week or two, the agency would start recommending decreasing spend with Reddit or directing it to other platforms

This is why we need an indefinite black-out!

The moderator boycott is not only affecting auction dynamics but media strategy, as advertisers don’t want to appear tone-deaf during a contentious period for the platform.

Two Wpromote clients canceled two premium, takeover-style campaigns that were supposed to launch this week, and received make-goods for the impressions that had already been delivered, D’Altorio said.

The campaigns will relaunch next week, while other standard campaigns remain unaffected, he said.

D’Altorio asked several clients to reschedule Ask Me Anything activations—where brands chat directly with their customers—as “we shouldn’t muddy the waters with our brand,” he said.

The anonymous media buyer source said one campaign turned off comments on their ads today.

“They didn’t want to become the subject of users’ opinions about Reddit’s decisions,” the buyer said.

Let's make sure it's not viable for these advertising activities to resume, either in a week or any time after that, until the changes the admins are making are reversed!

133
HKayn•

Not only that, for the advertisers to be affected, participating subreddits must be fully private, instead of just restricted.

54
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
PepsiColaMirinda•

The anonymous media buyer source said one campaign turned off comments on their ads today.

“They didn’t want to become the subject of users’ opinions about Reddit’s decisions,” the buyer said.

Now they've just given me this idea, gg.

35
PennyMarbles•

Possibly dumb question, but how can I see which companies are working with Reddit? Is it just in the ads people see? I had premium for a long time (cancled now)so I'm kinda new to ads

12
Alissinarr•

They're sneaky and look like posts on old.reddit.com (if you're lazy with your adblocker like me).

6
PennyMarbles•

Yes, I remember those! My premium still has a few more days left but when it's up I will finally be paying close attention to the ads. That way I'll know exactly what not to buy.

3
Ganacsi•

Just browse as guest, you should see the default view.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
jaggazz•

#keepredditdark

127
TwilightX1•

Seems that posts in this sub get echoed in the media. I think you should take advantage of that. Post a public call for advertisers to stop campaigns. Post a call for regular users not to click ads. If Huffman is only interested in the bottom line then the bottom line should be the target.

107
locke_5•

I'm straight up not buying anything I see advertised on Reddit anymore

58
1-760-706-7425Landed Gentry•

Never have. Never will. 🫡

42
itsnickk•

The person who needs to really take action is the user who has clicked on/bought from ads and planned to continue, but is concerned by the current actions of Reddit’s leadership

You have no leverage in that department, you’re probably bucketed as “ad avoiding user” or something

24
1-760-706-7425Landed Gentry•

You have no leverage in that department, you’re probably bucketed as “ad avoiding user” or something

Oh, I am sure of it. All I can do is keep staying in my lane so they understand conversion in that category is not happening.

11
TheMcG•

i paid for premium to avoid seeing advertising. cancelled that.

10
PM_ME_YOUR_FELINE•

Who's phone number is that? I know it's in the San Diego area, right?

2
farrenkm•

Quick Google, it is -- or was, didn't call it -- a number that will Rickroll you.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
thebluehotel•

You weren’t clicking on “he gets us” ads whenever they were plastered everywhere?

3
Porn_Extra•

Between uBlock Origin and Pi Hole, I've never seen an ad of Reddit.

3
ngwoo•

Make sure you tell the companies that advertise here that.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
giveAShot•

Go one better, run an adblocker and remove all ads. I haven't seen an ad ever, even promoted posts. I even remove all links to Reddit gold, etc..

1
TranZeitgeist•

Post a public call for advertisers to stop campaigns. Post a call for regular users not to click ads.

At some point admin will find reasons to invoke "site interference" and make direct threats and actions.

10
TwilightX1•

Such as? Removing mods' roles and setting all subs to public? Let them do it, and let them hire mods of their own and pay them salary to prevent this place from becoming 4chan. And if they don't give a f*** about this place becoming 4chan then tbh imho the place loses the right to exist. If I wanted 4chan I'd go to the original.

13
TranZeitgeist•

they seem to be moving fast to support subs and mods who want to stay open, with some major subs seeing replacements and removals. r/ ModCertification101 supplies volunteers.

Part of the fear/ reality is Reddit seems to be self healing - r/ news goes down, r/ inthenews is on the front page like nothing happened. Votes and views and subscriber counts are all relative, and admin might see this as a forest fire and a minor change, some users participate in private subs now, old mods and users moved on, jeremyclarkson.png . I don't like reddit.

8
TwilightX1•

I don't think that "fear" is an accurate word. I've also volunteered in various online places and there were some cases where I felt like I was being taken for granted and I just quit. Several months / years later I really hardly have any hard feelings. If the people who caused me to quit can handle things by themselves then I wish them well, but if not then I won't shed any tears even if I see the entire thing falling apart.

If Reddit insists on treating you like crap just don't agree to be part of it, and if it comes down to worst you can leave with your head held up. The new slaves respected people they're recruiting as mods will probably find themselves in a similar situation as you pretty quickly if Reddit doesn't change its attitude.

Also, may I suggest that those who want to keep the community running consider naming a successor, whether a site like Squabbles or a distributed project like Lemmy. Maybe switch the subreddits from private to restricted and pin a link. A lot of people support you, and will follow.

7
squirrelrampage•

Yes, big subreddits with general topics can be easily replaced, but that's where the small communities come in: Communities form around niche subjects and attract users/mods who are value the community above everything else.

These communities and hence their users will be lost forever if their subreddits stay closed, because they won't trust some admin-created replacement subreddit with random mods.

Rebuilding them would take time and effort, something that Spez & Co. with their fixation on getting profitable fast, won't be willing to commit to.

5
TurdFergusonlol•

Dude what is even the point of this?

At this point i really think mods are just trying to stick is to Reddit because Reddit said this would blow over. “We’ll show them!!”

Mods have free access to API for their mod tools and any non commercial uses like accessibility. Expecting Reddit to basically subsidize another company when their own company isn’t profitable is absolutely asinine. Reddit owes nothing to a direct competitor.

-4
DeckardWS•

The number of people who care about this blackout tantrum is so infinitesimally small, it's laughable that these people think they're moving the needle in a significant way.

These people have spent thousands of hours of their lives doing unpaid work for reddit, and reddit is about to fire them from that unpaid job. It would be funny if it weren't so sad.

-4
randoul•

Currently, these protests are impacting a small percentage of Reddit’s more than 100,000 active communities.

A stupid metric to use. There are countless subs with virtually no membership.

61
___HeyGFY___•

I am a mod for four subs. The three I created myself have 2, 8, and 20 members. The one I was added onto is at 198.

36
TranZeitgeist•

At the same time, every subreddit protest is based on how many "hundreds of millions" of "subscribers" mods imagine they represent, disregarding the fact that subscriber count includes bots, dead accounts, etc. Big number better.

7
Nightwing73•

There are also people who may visit the sub who aren’t subscribed to it though, as well as new potential followers who would have found it.

3
brickpicleo•

Well time I nuked my old subs...

2
farrenkm•

But that's how they're swinging. spez said 90% of API users wouldn't be impacted by the changes. I haven't looked, but I'm sure you're going to find that 90% includes the little mod tools and bots and things like that. The 10% are the heavy hitters, like all the regular user apps.

It's a completely disingenous statement.

1
KazanRei•

That certainly seems to contradict what spez said recently. It would be interesting to see some hard data on how much of an effect the blackouts have actually had.

57
LondonPilot•

Spez is going to say what gives him the correct headlines. The advertising agencies are going to say what is going to help make their clients make the right decisions. If advertising agencies are saying to hold off on Reddit campaigns, that's going to hurt spez and Reddit - it hurts them far more than the direct actions of shutting down subs, but it's directly caused by shutting down subs, and this is why those subs need to stay down indefinitely!

60
KoreKhthonia•

I don't work in paid ads or social media marketing, but fwiw, Reddit never really had that great of a reputation among marketers as an ad platform to begin with. This certainly isn't going to help that any.

10

did you seriously expect spez to say the truth?

54
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
gabrielish_matter•

Spez needs to not make anyone panic and keep the ship onboard and straight. That's his job.

Our job is to make him fail his job in the worse way possible if we want to get something

35
LIATG•

it wouldn't necessarily contradict, as most advertisers likely haven't changed their ad budgeting yet in response. spez is probably correct that overall viewership hasn't declined a significant amount over the last two days and therefore ads are still being placed and charged for, but if the ads are less effective companies will spend less on reddit ads in coming days/weeks

13
eaglebtc•

Steve Huffman made that statement prematurely, I think. He had not been given any data about ad campaigns being paused, or curtailed. It is especially notable that ad week is a trusted voice in the advertising business.

5
TerryMathews•

Minor quibble: he didn't say it prematurely, he intentionally put it out before it was provably false. He's not dumb, he knew which way the wind was going to blow. That's why the AMA from hell was scheduled.

7
TheUncleBob•

We already know Spez lies. Don't be surprised.

2
DTFH_•

You know its working when yesterday entirely unprompted news channels were discussing Reddit, it it was truly a drop in the bucket there would be no mainstream news coverage!

41
dude_just_relax•

I think the media knows just as little as we do about the numbers, but the fact it's being discussed works in our favour.

25
hiero_•

every sub opening back up today should go dark again immediately. it's working. 2 days is just an inconvenience though... if you give up now, it was for nothing.

37
twistedLucidity•

I don't disagree, but moderators need to be careful to gauge the opinion of their communities and ensure they can explain why the action is needed. If moderators act directly against their community's wishes, then you will just get r/name2, r/the_real_name, or whatever.

Moderators are not gods, we need our communities to buy into any action. I'm lucky, my community seems to be up for a scrap.

And fundamentally it's our communities who hold ultimate power. Power over the mods, and power over the admins. If the community leaves, Reddit dies. End of.

But where do we go?

Lemmy? Diaspora*? Those're going to need people to build out infra and to pay for it.

Hackernews? Slashdot? Great for us nerds, but what about everyone else? Also, that just kicks the can; private interests and profiteering will rise again.

The thing is, can enough people be convinced that this action matters to take action. I have seen one large sub totally ignore the blackout (and for no reason) and another say that it doesn't affect them (again, for no reason).

I guess I am screaming into the void. Facebook exists. No one cares. Stallman was right.

Again.

37
snuxoll•

Communities also need to understand the value their mods provide. It's easy to say "I'll make a new r/Awww with new mods", it's another thing to actually put in the soul-crushing work of moderating a community for 0 tangible benefit.

Let the outraged lurkers be pissed off and make their real_actual_subredditnamehere's, 80% of them won't survive a week of actual activity without being flooded by garbage.

10
headphase•

Good post.

Mods need to fundamentally think about where the value lies in their community, and then ask "Is Reddit still the best platform to serve this community's needs?"

In some cases, that answer (come July 1st) is "NO!"

In other cases, it's "yes, but we can begin migrating to something better" or "yes, but only for certain functions going forward"

Many communities (which started on Reddit) have been operating across multiple platforms for a while, and this may be the final straw that causes them to pivot away from their subreddit either partially, or entirely.

5
ShowerVagina•

What about time of day based blackouts? Like it goes dark for 8-12 hours nightly. It impacts ads significantly while still being open and usable for some of the day.

3
twistedLucidity•

Could be done. Set-up and automod/cronjob and do that. The world is global, so we'd need to pick TZs, although maybe randomness would cause a bigger impact?

3
ShowerVagina•

I'd say EST or PST. The goal would be to significantly impact traffic while still being accessible for most users. Reddit is US-centric.

3
sje46•

If moderators act directly against their community's wishes, then you will just get r/name2, r/the_real_name, or whatever.

These would get very few subscribers. Essentially meaningless. After all, how would people actually find those new subreddits?

3
Gamerguywon•

From what I have seen, many people are refusing to read text explaining the issue and are complaining with little to no knowledge of what is happening besides "Don't care about the mods or third party apps. My favorite subreddit is closed, the mods did it, so now I hate all the mods."

2

I don't disagree with your overall point but i mean; leaving digg for reddit was once seen as inconceivable and reddit was perceived as trash.

It might take a while, but it'll happen. No king rules forever.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
GhostOfSamurai•

Spez says we aren't having an effect? Since when have we been taking that guy's advice?

Blackout indefinitely! We are making a difference!

23
Wondrous_Fairy•

This is why we're seeing both this place and r/redditalternatives being hit with MASSIVE amounts of shills and astroturfers. They basically recycle the same talking points which is pretty obvious to spot.

And you know shit's bad if Reddit management does this.

Also, it's pretty funny to see how 99% of their posts are just these talking points when you view their profile. It's hilariously transparent.

20

If the screenshots are valid, some of them are chatgpt bots.

3
snarkylittlepuppet•

advertising not community is what spez cares about.

you can bet that with or without a blackout all human mods will be on the chopping block next. he will eventually replace every one of you with an advertiser friendly bot - mark my words.

having been through a couple of startup rodeos now i know how this plays out when vc, ipo and's media all converge on a black cloud story like this.

assume that as unpaid volunteers you're valuable today, but once they go ipo you become a risk that needs to be "mitigated".

blackout won't matter. whether you participated for an hour, a day, indefinitely or not at all... in the eyes of investors you're a risk that needs to go away. now or later unfortunately the mods that keep this site running are as doomed as third party apps.

the only way out is to force his hand and give communities time to regroup with a longer term plan for their community either here or somewhere else.

as we speak i see others standing up your communities on other platforms. imho if you value leading your community yourself you should be the ones proactively doing this until the dust settles.

finally assume he may not stop at removing you as a mod. i predict he'll ban your accounts completely. you're too powerful and dangerous to be left with any voice.

so find an alternative way to communicate with your groups (disvord, lemmy, mastodon etc). if you need help getting started somewhere dm me.

19
GhostOfSamurai•

Forcibly replacing mods has a downside though. It will generate negative PR and entice even more users to question the platform.

17
funkybside•

you can bet that with or without a blackout all human mods will be on the chopping block next. he will eventually replace every one of you with an advertiser friendly bot - mark my words.

Sure, but that will turn the subs to garbage. It's a short term solution only, and will likely cause greater damage in the long term.

12
TheAnonymouseJoker•

Your biggest mistake is thinking admins care about a long term organic community. If you ever used the Reddit app (I did, it is a replica of Instagram UI and UX), it is designed in a way to serve you ads disguised as regular posts, the exact same way Instagram is 2/3rd ads, where there are "ad" ads and influencer reel product ads.

Do not mistake this as just being spez alone, this is the whole board cooking up these ideas together. Spez is just the face everyone is seeing.

4
Yoddlydoddly•

What I don't understand is: why doesn't reddit lean into 3rd party apps wisely? (Making up numbers) say each user on their app generates 1.00 per day. Currently, 3rd party app users generate 0. Wouldn't it be wiser for reddit to simply charge "usual income + x%"?

They would keep users happy and generate more income than they would on their native app.

19
CPSiegen•

The Apollo dev even said the pricing scheme (high as it is) would be feasible but only if they have him a year's time to cycle through his existing year-long subscribers. With only 30 days' notice to switch to the paid API, the dev would be paying tens of thousands of dollars every month out of pocket to cover the difference in cost between his current subscribers and what reddit is charging.

This is all about short-term profit. They don't want to wait an extra year for the IPO and they don't want to go public with expenses like a free API that doesn't serve ads. Faster just to kill the API than to find a compromise.

29
MITJustinFields•

I don't know if they said it if it's ever going to be feasible. I just think they said they could work towards lowering the costs. By the dev's calculation, they are essentially being upcharged 20x

6

With only 30 days' notice to switch to the paid API, the dev would be paying tens of thousands of dollars every month out of pocket to cover the difference in cost between his current subscribers and what reddit is charging.

In other words, he made a bad business decision. It's always a risk to build a business around something you don't have any control over.

1
SpicySummerChild•

A blackout protest will get people more aware about the issue. But does not cause "pain" where it matters.

You know what will work -

  • All moderators need to take a leave of absence. No moderating.
  • Let every subreddit be filled with spam
  • Let advertisers pull out because they don't want their ads next to a potential scam or virus link.
14
SpaghettiSnake•

That seems to me like it would be a good "nuclear option" in the final week. Every mod participating deactivates their bots and scripts and whatever else they have and just steps away. Let the subreddits fall into chaos and be flooded with spam, porn, gore, sketchy links, and shitposts.

Then the users can complain about how unfair the moderators are being for not moderating. But that's the new normal they can deal with after the first.

17
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Peaceful_Warrior_•

Then reddit just allows new moderators to step in.

Good idea!! We can get rid of the shit-mods doing this to everyone and get back to normal.

-10
SpaghettiSnake•

Lol you're so cute. Like a little mouse squeaking and scurrying around, I just wanna pick you up and cuddle you 🤗

12
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
TheAnonymouseJoker•

The fact that you think power hungry opportunists can do the job of thankless moderators with years of forum experience is cute. That cuteness will not last though, when it happens. I kind of want it to happen at this point, just to see the likes of you suffer and realise how valuable we are, and how much we are taken for granted. I am both a mod and a content creator, and the fallout is hilarious to see.

2
Peaceful_Warrior_•

Awesome. You’re on board. Welcome.

At this point I just want you to lose your 3rd party app and hate your Reddit experience, so I get the sentiment.

1
JesperTV•

This is a copy of another comment I made, but it is very relevant.

Problem is not moderating for a certain amount of time makes your subreddit open for r/redditrequest. Going private doesn't have that risk.

Personally, the main sub I mod is one I faught for from a toxic mod (who is now suspended), and I have since worked hard to revive and rebrand it into a more active and safe community. The last thing I would want is for admins to think I don't care about it based on the lack of moderation and hand it over to whatever schmuck puts in a request for it first. Especially since it's an opportunity that alot of hateful (homophobic, racist, pretentious, etc) users have vocally expressed they were waiting for.

Going private indefinitely is one thing, but risking the quality and safety of a subreddit I care deeply for is another. All it does is give Admins the probable cause to kick out moderators who otherwise take great care of their communities.

Edit: someone had replied to this saying they wouldn't because you just have to be active on the site as a whole. I refrained from replying something along the lines of "they could just change the rules". Now I can no longer see said reply but that's exactly what they're doing

9
redhedinsanity•

not moderating for a certain amount of time

That's slightly incorrect. The account of the current mod user just needs to have been active anywhere on reddit in the last 30 days to avoid - not actively moderating, just active at all beyond logging in. source

1
TranZeitgeist•

All moderators need to take a leave of absence. No moderating.

Let every subreddit be filled with spam

The fastest way to give admin a reason to label a sub unmoderated and re-claim it, offering it to whatever r/ModCertification101 trainee want it.

3
monarchmra•

Ya, it has to be quiet quitting.

Just stop moderating. Actively upvote, actively comment, but stop moderating.

It's much much much harder to find the lack of action than negative actions

Maybe check mod queue once a day and remove 1 comment, pick the worse one.

4
Peaceful_Warrior_•

....I'm for it, as long as the mods who protest allow other people to step up and volunteer for the duties they're protesting against.

-1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1

I thought spezzy said blackouts are a nothingburger LOL

12
fork_yuu•

He also said no revenue impact

Let's see what he says after these blackouts hit his bottom line

4
Axros•

There wouldn't have been on the short term anyway. In the short term all this did was generate traffic of people coming here to check out what is going on. However, as interest in the drama dies off, all that's left is a crippled website. What would in fact really hurt is when search engines also stops displaying reddit pages in their search results, though unfortunately a lot of the most informative subreddits refuse to go fully private precisely because they don't want their valuable information to disappear from search engines.

1
Enidra•

seems like dark subs matter after all. who would have thought. keep em all shut

10
bologna_dog•

I worry that a big one-time show of defiance is not going to work. The reality is that, at some point, the subs have to come back. If they don't, others will create new subs to fill in the vacuum.

If mods really want to send a message to reddit's administration, they should do so in a way that those who are driven by corporate profits will be scared of. It should be something that inhibits long-term growth.

The solution is rolling blackouts. Every week, go dark on the one or two days that your subs get the most traffic. It'll be enough of a disruption that people will notice a down-tick in new content, but not enough that it will drive people to a new, competing sub.

Call it the "Moderator Day of Rest" or something. It will be something that the admins notice. Its effects on traffic and clicks will be something that investors and advertisers notice, too.

10
Zr4g0n•

Who's going to moderate those replacements?

5
bologna_dog•

There will always be people willing to moderate subs. And not every mod is on board with the blackouts.

3
klauskervin•

This isn't true at all. No one wants to take over mod for my sub.

3
Peaceful_Warrior_•

I volunteer.

3
DifficultyIll690•

new neckbeards

1†
DifficultyIll690•

Reddit is not going to budge no matter how angry the mods get. They believe (rightfully so imho) that the majority of subs will come back and those that don’t will be replaced or forgotten. This collection of however many reddit mods does not even come close to representing the entirety of the reddit userbase. most of us haven’t even heard of 3rd party reddit until now

4
bologna_dog•

They believe (rightfully so imho) that the majority of subs will come back and those that don’t will be replaced or forgotten.

I agree, the subs would be replaced/forgotten if they were to permanently go dark. That's why I'm proposing rolling blackouts: go dark one or two days per week. This way, the subs are still kept relevant, but at the same time, reddit will still be feeling the effects of a restriction on content.

13
DifficultyIll690•

sounds like that would just be a bunch more work for the mods with no gain and no significant impact on reddit

1
bologna_dog•

How much work does it take to flip a switch to make the sub go private and post a pre-written message explaining the situation? Maybe 10 minutes per week? Considering that the mods wouldn't have to actively moderate any content for those 24-48 hour periods, I'd say that they'd be saving themselves on work.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Peaceful_Warrior_•

I propose removing any mods who do this and forcibly reopening subs that go private.

-3†
TheAnonymouseJoker•

First be a moderator and/or content creator, instead of a raging shitposter on the internet ran by the very people you are shitting on. Oh wait...

3
DifficultyIll690•

if it were significantly impacting reddit they would just remove the ability to private subreddits temporarily, they literally have said they don’t care, no need to take action against a very vocal minority that can easily be replaced

1
chaos750•

The only thing that's going to work is mods quitting. Either go on strike or resign entirely.

Mass user revolt isn't feasible because while the third party app users are disproportionately power users, helping to actually create the communities that drive Reddit, they are a vocal minority, and the majority is already starting to not care and just want their stuff back. Mods, though, they're just as invested but actually possess power, as Reddit relies on their unpaid labor to keep the place livable. Unfortunately, they're also people who like the power they have and don't want to give it up, so it's a tall order. But that's the only thing that's going to do it that I can see.

2
Peaceful_Warrior_•

Other mods will take their place. Every mod is replaceable.

4
chaos750•

If they can find good replacement mods, then yeah. It is their site, after all. But mods are already at the center of a lot of the typical drama here, and an entire class of new mods all learning the ropes at the same time is likely to be a very bumpy transition. Regardless, it's the only thing I see with a chance of causing change.

1
Egmonks•

The current group of mods don’t seem to appreciate that fact. They are replaceable volunteers, not the owners of the site.

-3†
bologna_dog•

They are replaceable volunteers, not the owners of the site.

You mean the site that literally doesn't work without the input of said volunteers?

4
Spanktank35•

... Still, Reddit has been working on its relationships with advertisers, and any accumulated goodwill could be diminished if the precarious situation continues.

Oh no! We wouldn't want that.

For too long social media companies have pulled the rug under users, betraying the values that the communities were built around. ("enshittification"). This would be the first time users have said "no, we would rather this platform die than you turn us into products".

For months reddit had blocked me from commenting on the mobile version of the sitr, trying to force me to use the app (I used the buggy desktop version rather than that pile of crap). After the blackout, I can now use mobile version again... It's working.

9
Piculra•

Personally, I haven't seen a single ad since the start of the blackout, despite still checking this subreddit and a couple of others, and not having any ad blocker.

8
[deleted]•

[removed]

1