Riding a motorcycle from Los Angeles to Patagonia. BMW of Colombia made a hole in my engine and refused to admit it. Help appreciated

https://imgur.com/gallery/41QefD1

I left my 2012 BMW GSA at the shop for service after riding it all the way from Los Angeles to Bogotá, Colombia, spanning seven countries and covering thousands of kilometers.

After leaving BMW of Bogotá, I rode directly to Neiva, Colombia, where I parked the bike overnight. The next morning, I noticed oil on the ground and the entire lower left side of the engine covered in oil.

At that point, I visited a local motorcycle shop to have it inspected, and I was informed that during a valve check, the BMW of Bogotá technician had neglected to use a spacer and had inadvertently screwed the bolt into the engine, resulting in a hole in the casing.

However, the valve service is the only missing item from the final bill; everything else was completed. BMW of Bogotá claims that “no valve check was required as my valves were in good condition.”

Yesterday I was scrolling through my photos and discovered that by pure luck I snapped a picture of my bike on May 31 when I dropped off the Ohlins shock that was serviced in the US. On that day I’ve been told that everything I asked to be serviced was done and that only the shock needs to be put back in. 3 days later I picked the bike up from BMW and was repeatedly told that crash bars were never touched However, when I zoomed into a picture I took, the bolt is clearly unscrewed and ready to be forced into the casing

(Additionally, upon leaving the service center, I heard a loud bang and later discovered that my steering damper had been incorrectly installed, causing it to rub against the fender and break an adjustment knob.)

After communicating with BMW rep over WhatsApp and requesting a video surveillance of the area where my motorcycle was worked on, I’ve been ghosted. The only thing I got from them was a kind of “shit happens, move on” type, but entire trip to Patagonia is at the risk of being finished because of incompetence of BMW of Bogotá. Without the engine, my GS is a bunch of fancy scrap metal sitting in South America

I had to move the bike out of Colombia due to Temporary Import Permit (TIP) expiration and issues with renewing it, hence I rode it to Ecuador where it’s now parked at the MotoHell motorcycle shop in Quito. On the ride there, oil pressure light kept coming on and off with oil level being good. I suspect that a little aluminum piece that was pushed into the engine by the bolt could be affecting an oil pump or causing other issues (perhaps more mechanically gifted readers could comment on it?) Angel, MotoHell’s owner will drain the oil, inspect the motor and cut the filter to try and find a piece of metal that could be there

The question now is what to do with this information and a newly found proof that the crash bars were removed and the long bolt was skewed into the casing. (I wrote emails to BMW motorrad in Germany, US and Colombia. The only one that didn’t respond is Colombian. Two others said that they forwarded my message to BMW of Colombia)

I’m also considering hiring a lawyer after I discovered new photo evidence and know for fact that they broke my motor. Does anyone here know how law works in Colombia and if it’s worth pursuing that route?

PS: Here is the dealer that did the “work” in case anyone knows someone who works there and could help to untangle this mess: Autogermana

https://maps.app.goo.gl/VLfSoUyfHnUdLyDT7?g_st=ic

Also, here is my instagram where I can share and tag bmw with even more photos of the problems that bmw of Colombia caused: IG @andreinotes

https://www.instagram.com/andreinotes/?hl=en

Here are the photos of the damages:

https://imgur.com/gallery/41QefD1

Thank you for reading and offering your ideas on how to deal with this situation!

Posted Jun 14, 2023, 8:49 PM UTC · edited

411
math_debates•

Doesn't fix your issue with them but can a shop just drill and tap the block to fix it so you can get going?

6
psyolusUnited States•

Confused. Are you blaming Ohlins for leaving the bolt hanging out or BMW for punching a hole in your engine? Or both? Is the hole from the crash bar bolt punching in or is it unrelated (is that the bolt that was screwed in without a spacer)?

If the hole preexisted your bike being at the BMW shop, it'd be bizarre for them to not mention it (or you to notice it, honestly). It'd also be weird to not notice it when leaving the shop.

Not to rub salt in a wound, but /always/ look over your bike before and after someone else messes with it.

3
andreinotesOP•

Crash bars were dismounted to check the valves. Mechanic neglected to put a spacer when he put the crash bars back on. That resulted in bolt getting screwed into the engine casing

Bike was washed minutes before I picked it up to hide a leak

Bike was parked overnight after I rode it to nearby town. In the morning there was a puddle of oil on the ground

4
psyolusUnited States•

Reread the post and I think I get it now. You dropped the Ohlins part off at the dealer.

Does sound like they're covering it up. If it was broken when it came in, they should have said something.

3
andreinotesOP•

Yes. I snapped a picture where the bolt is sticking out while dropping off the Ohlins shock

Their claim that the crash bars were never touched crumbled after I zoomed into the picture

3

Really any time you ride you should do a basic once over. Especially if it’s in public parking, someone could have intentionally damaged it sitting as well.

3
tenpencetemperance•

Where did you buy the bike and where do you live? If you aren't US based, none of my advice would be relevant.

2
andreinotesOP•

Bought the bike in the US, live here as well

I rode it from Los Angeles to Bogotá

2
tenpencetemperance•

The when California is the place to be for consumer protection. I'm assuming that BMW Bogata was an authorized service center. Your photographic evidence is very important. And, as in politics, the cover up is worse than the crime.

The when you bought the bike is important to know if there was any warranty coverage. Absent that the trick will be jurisdiction and venue. I would start by writing to BMW here. Describe what happened and ask them to make it right. Tell them you went out of your way to use BMW authorized repair shop. If they won't help, use caala.org to find consumer protection attorneys. Tell them up front about the fact that the damage was done in Bogata. I don't know the answer as to whether that makes a case impossible or not.

As a final resort, sue in small claims court. In CA, lawyers aren't allowed in small claims court. It is a huge hassle for corporations. They frequently default because it costs more than 10 grand to fight in small claims. If a CAALA lawyer won't take your case, she or he may still be able to explain how you sue in small claims. I would sue BMW USA based upon the fact that their representations of service centers all over the globe were my basis for choosing a BMW. Suing the folks in Bogata is not likely to work. Hope some of this helps.

2
andreinotesOP•

Are you are lawyer by trade or just making a suggestion? I don’t see a standing here. BMW of North America and BMW of Colombia are two different entities. Furthermore, bmw operates its network of dealers on franchise basis, hence every dealer is responsible for their own operations.

Based on that, how can you make an argument that BMW of North America is to blame? Perhaps BMW of Motorrad in Germany

1
tenpencetemperance•

I'm a lawyer by trade. Standard disclaimer: this isn't legal advice. We don't have an attorney-client relationship.

The separate entities is problematic, but the question is whether he purchased the motorcycle because of the extensive service network and the promise that that network would be available to service the bike on his trip. That's also the reason that a letter to BMW might get him a good will repair.

In reviewing, I didn't notice that age of the bike. If he bought it secondhand off an individual and not from BMW, your thought is probably correct. It's probably out of reach for an average rider, but I would certainly include BMW of NA and Germany. The fight over dismissal would cost them more than the repair and isn't guaranteed to work out for the foreign entity. I wouldn't advise that to anyone who isn't related to the lawyer (for the reason that it will cost more than the repair to sue). I was, as above, assuming he bought the bike from a BMW dealer, which may not be the case.

1