r/atheism•
Nutzillaa

Reddit, my friend has recently become interested in spirituality and always describes the Bible as poetry, saying fundamentalists are interpreting it wrong. How can something like the Ten Commandments be considered poetry? It's doctrine.

Reddit, my friend has recently become interested in spirituality and always describes the Bible as poetry, saying fundamentalists are interpreting it wrong. How can something like the Ten Commandments be considered poetry? It's doctrine.

Posted Dec 6, 2012, 4:21 AM UTC

05
itdemon•

Any writing can be considered poetry by someone. That doesn't mean it would make sense to anyone else.

2
NutzillaaOP•

Said friend has become infatuated with eastern spirituality and is constantly regurgitating Alan Watts lectures (although I don't really think he understands what he's saying). He'l say thing like "man, everyone is just confused when it comes to religion. It's all just poetry. They'd understand if they meditated and were able to reach higher levels of consciousness like me." It's this sort of pseudo-mysticism that drives me up the wall. Like, do you think the people who decided which parts would be canonized were stuck on the fence over which verses had the best poetic structure?

2

This is what the Lord of hosts has to say: 'Go, now, attack the Amalekites. Kill men and women, children and infants.' - 1 Samuel 15

So lyrical! It's obvious that "kill" is just a metaphor for "love". Such beautiful poetry.

1
[deleted]•

Clearly you are not a friend.

Edit: I suppose I should clarify.

If the Bible is poetry, let's take a loose definition of God. How about a personification of fundamental communal morality, as evolutionary biologists/psychologists suggest that communal values were central to the development of religion. Disagree? I'd love to hear from you.

I: Thou shalt have no other gods before me. Biologically speaking, this makes absolute sense. Life as it stands is little more than an effort toward genetic superiority. The minute you begin to support outside influence above the values of your family, tribe, or whathaveyou, you've begun to support your genetic competitors. IIRC from my bio classes, when two groups are in competition for the same niche, extinction is guaranteed.

II: Do not worship idols. Within an ecological example, persuit of an absolute ideal is ... futile.

III: Do not take the Lord's name in vain. What does it mean to be vain? What does it mean to claim to be god because of vanity?

IIII: Remember to keept the Sabbath holy. Relax once in a while and be glad to be alive.

V: Honor thy father and thy mother. Self-explanatory.

VI: Thou shalt not kill. Self-explanatory.

VII: Thou shalt not commit adultry. Don't fuck your neighbor's wife unless you plan to fuck up the neighborhood?

VIII: Thou shalt not steal. ...

IX: Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbour. Don't say your neighbor is a pedo 'cause you want to bone his wife, unless you want to fuck up the whole damn neighborhood.

X: Thou shalt not covet. Get over your "keeping up with the Joneses complex."

So which one doesn't make sense?

-5
NutzillaaOP•

Maybe you misread. I'm not saying they don't make sense, they certainly do. I'm just not completely convinced that religious scripture is poetry. I saw someone in this thread write "any writing can be considered poetry by someone. That doesn't mean it would make sense to anyone else." Sure, ok. I get it.

What really chaps my ass is the fact that he think EVERYONE is just looking at religion the wrong way, and he has it all figured out. Oh, those stories that claim to be the word of God and should be followed without question, that's just some clever writing! I dunno, I just think that when these religious texts were being manufactured, the people weren't really thinking of artistic expression so much as they were thinking about creating a kind of social contract/explanation for life.

I dunno, maybe I'm an idiot, just throwing ideas out there.

1