New Guinsoos is really bad

Discussion

Differences from Old:

+400 gold cost

+30 ap

+30ad

-0.5 damage per crit chance, now deals magic instead (previous ratio was already a net even, now this is a not beneficial for adcs the crit is actually better)

+12 % AS fully stacked (you lose kraken slayer 12% per item though and you have to charge this) + phantom hit only applies on full stacks

+5% armor pen +6% magic pen per item (way worse than kraken slayer's old passive, basically only worth for kog etc. w/ hybrid dmg)

​

How is this any better? I play mainly onhit ad kennen to masters last season and this feels disgustingly bad. I didn't build guinsoos before and its not any better now - I just dont have a kraken slayer mythic to build so I have to build galeforce which doesnt even give MS anymore. Better off just Bork -> Kraken -> Wits which is what i did before but kraken is worse.

Posted Jun 20, 2023, 3:27 AM UTC

113
The_ChadTC•

It is a ridiculously more powerful item than before and it's not even close.

It dealing magic damage is much more powerful, the mythic passive is orders of magnitude more powerful than a bit of attack speed and the stats are exactly what on hit carries need.

10
butt_collector•

Kraken Slayer is also 400 cheaper, seems like a wash to me.

I don't understand why you don't just build Nashors and accept the hybrid damage on your champ with jacked AP ratios. To be cute?

1†
vanillaturtleOP•

You dumb dumb xDDD. Do you see any onhit nashors kennens in master? it only provides 35 onhit with 50% attack speed. The playstyle is completely different as an adc vs an ap champion. Nashors when bought as a second items gives just 35 onhit magic with 100 ap. You are losing attack speed due to kraken changes that isn't made up with rageblade.

Compared to kraken nashors:

-5 damage on hit ( actually less because ad applies crit) (physical damage is no worse than magic damage at this point in the game)

+20% as

+100 ap

-20% crit

+200 gold

Passive kraken which is worth way more than 100 ap at high AS and high ad alone. u dont know what you are talking about

-5
butt_collector•

I don't see any on-hit Kennens in master period, not sure what your point is. From what I can tell Kraken Slayer has been built on Kennen in like 5 games in master elo across all regions so far this patch. I don't play your champ but you're out here being a bit of a cock for no reason to people taking time out of the day to comment on your rant post.

Nashors when bought as a second items gives just 35 onhit magic with 100 ap. You are losing attack speed due to kraken changes that isn't made up with rageblade.

I wasn't saying replace Kraken with Nashor, I was saying go build Nashor at some point after Rageblade to benefit from the magic pen, but whatever. I don't play your champ but every other on-hit champ is either building kraken nashor rageblade or trinity force and are in a really good place. Kraken Triforce is a really strong two item spike for every champ that can feasibly build them. I'm not saying this is the answer, I'm asking if you've tried it. Your complaint is that Rageblade isn't good enough but hybrid damage is strong. Like really strong. You are literally the only person I have heard complain that new Rageblade is worse but you don't build it and didn't even build it before so you're really just salty that your old build doesn't have a mythic anymore and you don't want to experiment with the two very good on-hit mythic options.

1
vanillaturtleOP•

xDDDDD

you sound extremely unintelligent yet trying to rationalize a losing position.

Wits bork kraken must buys maybe guinsoos then theres no room for nashors unless you are kayle or kog. Nobody builds 5 straight onhit items and expects to win you need defensive. You also gave no reasoning why rageblade is good you just said that everyone thinks its good. It literally cripples your damage with no benefit other than the armor pen and magic pen. Lets say you have 100ad -> 20% crit = 20 ad. 200 ad -> 20% crit = 40 ad. Literally at less than 200 ad you start getting less bang for your buck and it only goes worse from there. Onhit damage without steroids is horrible with guinsoos even midgame and you start getting outscaled the minute you buy the rageblade.

-7
DeputyDomeshot•

xDDDDD

you sound extremely unintelligent

2
TyphoonflameMODBronze Sera Mid main•

Your submission has been removed. Please review our Golden Rule.


If you are still experiencing issues and need to contact the moderators, please send a modmail using this link.

1
TyphoonflameMODBronze Sera Mid main•

Your submission has been removed. Please review our Golden Rule.


If you are still experiencing issues and need to contact the moderators, please send a modmail using this link.

1
GuptaGodDiamond I•

Triforce wits/bork kennen feels okay to me. Same as my tf and Ashe build lol. Adc items are supposed to be worse now, so other lanes that wanna build these items get even less worth. Only buildable crit adc items (for non adcs) is bloodthirster and collector really.

1
WizardXZDYoutubePlatinum III•

idk about the rest of it, maybe rageblade sucks, but magic damage is generally better than physical damage

Caitlyn (random ADC I looked up) has 106.9 armor at level 18, compared to 52.1 MR, so magic damage does effectively 33% more damage against squishies.

1
HellraiserMachina•

This change didn't happen in a vacuum, tons of onhit items as well as ADCs were also changed and you have to use them together with rageblade.

1
TexasMonk•

I can see your point but disagree with your conclusion.

The armor and magic pen, together, are just a wild amount of available pen, particularly with LDR now also increasing magic damage against champs with more max health than you. Previously, the item felt weakest when building for the crit-scaling on-hit because of how strong things like BOTRK are. The changes to the crit items have definitely helped even the playing field of choices there. I do think a big chunk of Guinsoo feeling not as great right now (and it may have just been placebo) is that its interaction with new Kraken Slayer just doesn't work. There's no 3 shot oomph.

Based on the comments I've seen, I do think you're underrating Nashor's in the build. Maybe not specifically for Kennen but a lot of the other on-hit builders, outside of Vayne, have pretty significant attack-based AP ratios that Nashor's scales monstrously since it's practically a second mythic.

1
nil_785•

my problem with this version of Guinsoo is that it does not double empowered autos anymore(not that i could notice), meaning it kinda messed up my AS neeko as far as i know it felt a bit off at the start :/

havent tried it enough this season? maybe? idk

1
WantToBeAloneGuy•

OP is right and I've tested it, it's extremely situation and deals like 5% extra damage to tanks and 10% less damage to squishes at about 5-6 items in, while simply being objectively terrible if you buy it 1st, second or third in your build. It's bearable for champs with built in on-hit, useless on everyone else. Definitely needs a small buff so it can function better as a tank buster.

1
butt_collector•

Have you tried Trinity Force?

-1