Semi-annual moderator feedback and Q&A Megathread

Megathread

Hello all. As mentioned before here, we have started doing a moderator feedback form. We shall not bore you with the details so here are a few points:

  1. This mega-thread will be open for a month and this collection will be in the Subreddit sidebar for easy access.
  2. Moderators will answer your questions in the thread. Please read the queries other users have and see if your questions have already been asked before asking them again.
  3. There is a feedback forum that is going to be open all the time so after this megathread closes, you can use Google Forms for the same purpose.
  4. The questions we gather from Google Forms will also be added to the mega thread and answered.
  5. After every 6 months, you can provide us with feedback on the positive changes you felt after your suggestions were provided and we worked on it from our side. A new Q&A mega thread and feedback form will be made for it.
  6. Please note that this is a safe space to vent out all you want but the Subreddit rules still apply.

The link to the Google feedback forum can be found here:

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScw8Dd6IhcRXkze0AOMA-poapENJSpYmmOZrIJpbwJdXzIOaA/viewform?usp=sf_link

So, tell us r/Nepal, how we can work together for the betterment of this subreddit? Write down any questions, queries, suggestions, or complaints down below.

Posted Jun 20, 2023, 4:45 AM UTC

625
Rayssassin•

My non-offensive, non-flair, non-relationship, non-NSFW post was silently muted yesterday and no particular reason was provided. Was that censorship or too real for this sub? In case you want to pretend which post, it was "Us Nepalese: We don't need much".

10
kp--MOD :snoo_hug::table_flip:•

Hi there. Reddit's spam filters tend to look for common patterns in posts. I went to check it out, but it looks to be fine right now.

In the future, so that mod team intervenes, please modmail us with the link to your post, so one of us can directly look into it. We'll do our best to accomodate it asap.

1
Crippled_Guest124•

Inclusion of separate tag for controversial debate-type questions concerning all topics?

3
kp-- :snoo_hug::table_flip:•

TLDR: How controversial are we talking about here? The answer is always "It depends".

Any controversial topic within reason is and will always be protected by mods under freedom of speech.


Having debates over political ideologies, differing stance on news, and dissidence is one thing, starting a say (disclaimer!!!) strictly for example, a debate about exiling/excluding/lynching all Christians/LGBTIQ+ folks/<insert any marginalized group/identity here> from Nepal in the interests of conservatism isn't, that's just plain hate speech. So is the likes of discussions based on pure dogwhistling.

r/Nepal is currently standing, and continues to stand on principles of inclusivity.

Any controversial topic within reason is and will always be protected by mods under freedom of speech. Just ask yourself how someone would feel if being on the receiving end of the debate, and if the answer is "not very good", then perhaps keeping it to yourself would be the rational approach.

Remember, freedom of speech, but not freedom from consequences. If your intention is to hurt someone with something that is your intrinsic birthright, then the right now begets duties of reparation/disciplining. It's simply cowardly to use your right to trample on someone else's rights to their own peace, then running behind the curtains of "freedom of speech". Also, say if someone's being hurt by someone else's freedom of speech: Them using their freedom of speech in retaliation only weaponizes the right into something it was never meant to be.

It's like saying let 2 drunkards fight, because it's their right to. It's not. It's a sadistic request to be a spectator to 2 parties destroying each other in a process that just benefits no one in the end. A wrongdoing can't be righted with another wrongdoing.

So please keep that in mind(you, and anyone else who wishes to place a rebuttal using the "freedom of speech" argument. It's just not permissible.

1
kp--MOD :snoo_hug::table_flip:•

It's allowed as-is under discussions(they're even closely moderated). If not, you can include [Serious] tag in the title, as that summons every one of us to the post.

Like all things, the answer's "it depends". How "controversial" are we talking about here?

1
reddi7erनेपाली :flag:•

ok so as you wish u/kp-- i m here on your invitation (?) from https://www.reddit.com/r/Nepal/comments/14k7nxb/comment/jptio6h/?context=3

you have threatened me to ban. but honestly that doesn't matter to me, i have long lost any interest to post here either, so i won't miss a thing. go ahead if that serves your purpose of power flexing. and how come you don't get by now that dissatisfaction on the way moderation goes here is not only problem of mine but also many other users'?

> your sole purpose in life right now seems to be antagonizing modding team

how petty of you to judge someone's life - do you even have a point bro? can you show me if over half my comments are antagonizing modteam? or on a 2nd thought if you believed you did right modding then why scared of antagonizing? antagonizing is your term not mine. i am not a rebel or anything, just nothing.

> showboating that you got banned unfairly on some other subs, and circlejerk among them that "yeah mod team bad".

try it - i won't do that ever. no point talking about shits.

> bare minimum of reasonable house rules.

that is the where all the problem is. who defines rules? reasonable to whom? who belongs to the house? who has the say? like the whole point of "this thing is ok and that thing is not" according to mod is so flawed. also ambiguous rules may be reasoned about in ways someone sees fit - again another flaw. this a place where we despise direct monarchical rule.

> This was you like a week back when sulu posted a news link. How bitter do you have to be to continue to act this serious on a forum meant to be chill, and have fun at?

are you gonna accept with a big smile if i do post same kinda news every day? and for that simple tongue in cheek commentary because someone else asked. i think you are determined to find my fallacies to ban me right then and there. if mods are users first then why do you feel entitled in that mods must not be said a thing. is there Lèse-majesté here?

> You realize what this creates? Unnecessary drama

raise your bar bro or you may find everything a drama.

> Go on downvote me all you want

hehe how some downvotes go below -1? know that someone else might be there too. so dont blame me yar i am not your enemy in any way, shape or form.

--

btw i won't be replying further on this- remove if you wish to but know that you invited me here from a locked thread.

3
kp--MOD :snoo_hug::table_flip:•

btw i won't be replying further on this

Cowardice at best, smug at worst.

you have threatened me to ban.

You can choose to feel threatened if you want to - the intent was to let you know your modlog's not speaking in your favor. In an objective analysis of your account's standing, any other person would chalk you up differently. I believe in benefits of doubt, which is why you still haven't been touched by me. If all you contribute on any random thread is "hey mods don't remove this post I like it", then I have nothing more to say here, in my eyes you contribute even less than a lurker(a lurker at least reports/interacts with the voting system - you just create unnecessary noise). Pay heed to this sentiment, it stems out of respect from one community member to another. I'm not here as kp-- the person, that doesn't matter, you don't matter nearly as much as you think you matter in my eyes. What matters, is your actions, I can never judge you based on intends, and I never will. That's a slippery slope. Having said that, ALL that matters to me, is your modlog, and how long it is. Keep in mind, there are several folks here in front page right now, that have less than 10 actions combined in half a decade. What does that tell about those people? They understand what "reasonable" means.

Having said that, principles, without them we'd all be down in the gutters, clawing at each other. Flexing my "power" on you to ban you would simply make you a martyr - and prove me wrong at what I do - it's not something I stand for. I'll only ban you once you make continuous violation of rules - to the point I personally believe you're more a liability than an asset to the sub, which you're accruing little by little.

So choose to feel threatened if you want, esp rich coming when you go "Oh fuck all JUST BAN ME ALREADY". It's a deep seated frustration I don't understand, nor claim to, all I know is that makes you bitter as a person, and I'll comply if you continue skirting rules. That's the long and short of it.

Obv it's upto a mod's discretion, someone else might have a different threshold to mine. Just because you oppose me, doesn't make me think any less of you, it's when you try and intrude, deliberately make the mockery of rules(which I'm coming to next), then stand there being "come at me brah, ban me, do it" - like some wannabe rebel(that's exactly how you're acting, despite vehemently denying it).

Like bruh I moderate reddit on my free time, I don't have the baggage space to deal with someone that takes time away from me doing my job. All this argument leads to, is being bitter, and nothing else.

that is the where all the problem is. who defines rules? reasonable to whom? who belongs to the house? who has the say?

Reddit says so. And you agreed to it when you signed up: Maybe read about it here

Abide by community rules. Post authentic content into communities where you have a personal interest, and do not cheat or engage in content manipulation (including spamming, vote manipulation, ban evasion, or subscriber fraud) or otherwise interfere with or disrupt Reddit communities.

It's given us vested power, granted it aligns with the interest the community has, to establish REASONABLE expectations out of a subreddit. Like with r/Nepal, you have an implicit understanding, that relationship posts don't make it to the FP. That wasn't decided by the moderation team, it was decided by the community voice. If you wish to be part of that voice, to influence the change, you need to follow the process. Standing apart and refusing to do so only makes you look bad, and rings of gross entitlement(a word you're very fond of). That's the whole reason behind the community survey, as well as this megathread. It's the whole reason why we're trying to have a discourse here.

A good mod, and a good jannie, have one thing is common, you don't interact with them diretly. Neither do you feel their presence when you're in a place they work at: They do it behind the scenes. You don't go "oi, yo thau safa garr!". Curb that entitlement, despite us serving you, doesn't mean we work on your whims. We answer to the community, and you chose to stand apart, and thrust your principles against the subreddit's. You use the report system to let us know, it shows up like red herring in our radars. That's the system in works. Trying to be above it, and then painting us as villains, isn't that a bit hypocritical from you? Isn't that you blatantly denying rules because you're a wild spirit and thrust your beliefs on a platform that runs like a well-oiled machine even without your presence in it? You reek of utter entitlement right now.

You wouldn't go to a club on sandals. Do you think the laws will protect you for getting thrown off by the club for going there on flipflops? You think you'd be entitled to questioning the club's decisions?

We mods, we uphold rules, sometimes nearly not enough - all the spam in the FP stands testament to it, sometimes in a hair trigger way, I agree - we're in the works to fix that from our end. What is NOT okay, is questioning us by going beyond the system. Use the outlets that are afforded to you PRECISELY for this issue, and do not sour anyone else's experience. You may not see it that way, trying to act as an evangelist, but often enough, people find that off-putting, and then do not bother engaging. Thus the removal of all meta opinions.

You come into Reddit, you expect it to go like any other social media, and try thrusting your beliefs into a system that prolly existed before you discovered social media. Then, you make a mockery out of all of it, despite agreeing to it implicitly when you signed up to use it. How do I make you understand, that you're the one that's being unreasonable right now?

No, good sir, you don't get it AT ALL. I'm under you. I'm the servant here, trying to do a thankless job to try and make your experience within r/Nepal a net positive. I do the things I do in r/Nepal, because I love it to bits.

So, with all due respect, let me do my job. I'm answerable to the community, and I shall be, always. If you have qualms, state it here, I'll work on it. If not, we're done here. All you had to do, was just state your opinion on the thread freely, without resorting to bring in a meta discussion - it was completely unwarranted, and you achieved nothing for it. Had you edited it out, it'd have been reinstated. Instead, you chose to stand hostile, and bring it here, whilst given ample chances for a reconciliation.

1
GWENTLEHUMAN•

Why do we need to sign in to fill the form?

2
boldclaimthatनेपाली :flag:•

That's Google's policy. You can't fill up the form without signing in. Your email won't be shared with the form creators though.

1
GWENTLEHUMAN•

I'm pretty sure you can set up the form to not require sign in. I've filled out dozens of forms in incognito mode without signing in.

3
kp--MOD :snoo_hug::table_flip:•

I've filled out dozens of forms in incognito mode without signing in.

That's exactly what it's for. So a person can't just run a bot 24/7 on a piece of code any script kiddie can assemble solely through ChatGPT, then proceed to spam tf outta the form.

1
GWENTLEHUMAN•

Okay, I got it when the other mod replied. There's no need to insinuate anything bro.

Also, a couple of your questions are pretty stupid. Ethnicity choice between Aryan, Tibeto-Burman and Mongolian?? And political ideology choice between conservative and libertarian? Are you guys smoking crack or something?

1
PyroquaMOD:paw: •

So, we did that for the Moderator application form and got a lot of insincere, duplicate, and troll responses. That is why sign-in is required for this one. But, as mentioned, it will not be shared and will still be anonymous.

1
GenVenomNepali ho ni•

Haina yo relationship wala post haru chai thursday ko lai matra kina limited? I understand that those "kun hotel ma seggs garna jam guys" posts are annoying but limiting and entire (and i think a rather popular topic among teens here) topic to a single day / thread makes no sense?

2
kp--MOD :snoo_hug::table_flip:•

Hi, we're deliberating it moving forward.

We urge you to take the survey, it covers all the commonly brought up issues + many more, and you can actively change the course of how r/Nepal takes care of itself moving forward.

Link: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScw8Dd6IhcRXkze0AOMA-poapENJSpYmmOZrIJpbwJdXzIOaA/viewform?usp=sf_link

1
motorboatingAfishDozerConnoisseur•

Hello geh mods,

For questions like:

In the past 3 months, how frequently have you encountered harmful or rule breaking content in r/Nepal?

or,

In the past 3 months, how frequently have you been in the receiving end of toxicity, name calling, discrimination based on your identity/gender/political alignment/beliefs?

shouldn't there also be an option for None? The minimum is just a few times, which I fell over-inflates the result provided sufficient sample size.

I have tried to answer as honestly as I can but unless i can choose the correct answer for me, i don't think i can proceed further.

ofc yall are in no shape or form obligated to change the answers based on my sole complaint, but just putting my thoughts out there.

2
kp--MOD :snoo_hug::table_flip:•

shouldn't there also be an option for None? The minimum is just a few times, which I fell over-inflates the result provided sufficient sample size.

66.8%. That was what the average number for "it's targeted harassment at me or someone else"/Rule 4 violations/other harassment header reports that we managed receiving in the past few months.

Chances are, most if not all currently active people in front page on r/Nepal have faced someone being a jerk to them AT LEAST one time in the last 3 months.

ofc yall are in no shape or form obligated to change the answers based on my sole complaint, but just putting my thoughts out there.

We would, but putting our heads under the sand(ignoring that r/Nepal isn't toxic in general) really doesn't make much sense. I tell you, I count my blessings and consider the day a miracle if I don't have to discipline someone for being extremely, extremely disruptive to someone else just because they don't agree with just simple viewpoints. Chances are, their move should have ended at "Lets agree to disagree", yet those folks just simply drag the other guy's mother, call them names, fulminate in the most alarming way possible. Very likely, a majority of those things never make it to your feed. We want to make sure the experiences you have in r/Nepal, is at least, a "Net positive".

I have tried to answer as honestly as I can but unless i can choose the correct answer for me, i don't think i can proceed further.

If that's the case, pick the lowest among the 3. I know it skews the results, but the fact is that its a given at this point.

I'll give you my word that we'll be improving and adding "none/Skip" options for all future iterations of moderation survey.

2
motorboatingAfishDozerConnoisseur•

I hope you guys do some nice data analytics on this survey and pump out some nice numbers and charts.

1
NamXina•

Optional questions. Gender, identity or pronoun, ethnicity, caste, family background, age, location, profession, religion, political ideology?

1
PyroquaMOD :unbothered:•

Are these questions for the Moderators? gif

2

oh you still active nice

1
kp--MOD :snoo_hug::table_flip:•

They help us know our community. If the sample is big enough, we'll publish it as a report. Thus the optional pages to get to know you.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Samaya-Chakra•

I have sent the docs with relevant information.

Hopefully, you guys take the suggestions.

And please, make the results transparent, later on.

1
SlowBag5दुद :DDC:•

Get a life mod. Go and do actual work in real life (if you don't) and contribute to your family. Nobody's going to answer your stupid questionnaires.

1†
miliwiz•

when i post mero post tw post bhako dekhauxa and auto-mod stiicks its forum comment also but my posy isnt seen in the subreddit am i restricted or what? i can comment tho

1
kp--MOD :snoo_hug::table_flip:•

Hi, has been addressed. Like one of my brethren stated, essentially it was because of u/reddit's crowd control filter.

2
Playful-Ad6177•

No this has not been addressed. My posts still get removed automatically.

1
kp--MOD :snoo_hug::table_flip:•

[Blame u/reddit.](https://i.imgur.com/VhpaQ8K.png). Hami haat dhoyera paxhadi lagya chainam.

You'll need to reach out to reddit support to know why exactly you're getting hit on by the spam filter. In the meanwhile, modmail us so we have a manual review.

Sorry, it's out of our hands.

1
Playful-Ad6177•

modmailed. This doesn't happen to me in other subreddits though. Only r/Nepal. Can you disable any spam filters that you've turned on for this subreddit that other subs don't use? I feel that's what is causing this.

1
pailkedv•

Can we have something against people who try to belittle others by using the तँ, भाई, etc.? It used to be customary in Nepali culture to use तपाईँ and others to have a good and meaningful discussion. It used to prevent people from being angry and encourage people to actually discuss on the actual substance.

1
kp--MOD :snoo_hug::table_flip:•

Hi there. Like I mentioned there, we dunno what the background of a member's raising is, perhaps they were around listening to all grownups addressing each other as "tah". If that's the case, it's needless elitism on our end to enforce a specific way to address someone.

On that case, the person you reported has been given the benefit of doubt, that they made it in good faith, perhaps humorously. Tones can't be read on texts, after all. However, we take condescending remarks seriously, so we'll be in the lookout for that user's activities going forward.

Regarding the addressing, I'm sorry, but that's a tall ask for a diverse body of forum users that might have utterly stark raising. Some folks use "tah" just as friendly as someone going "tapai", whilst there are instances of sarcastic folks that use "hajur" to subtly deride those that they stand opposing.

1
pailkedv•

Thanks for the response and I do agree it might be elitist to force others to use उच्च आदर -- so I accept that currently no rules would be implemented. I still think that people should refrain from using भाइ or तँ to address someone especially as it is normally used to belittle others as far as my experience goes.

I will list out the instances where non-respectful (उच्च आदर) pronouns are used in belittling way, just for the sake of making my point, but not to ask you to change your mind.

  1. Anyone from Terai who looks clearly Madhesi is addressed with तिमी, even by small children. Some even use तँ.
  2. People use भाई to appear domineering towards others. This especially prevalent among friends, but they get a pass because they are friends. But, it is also used among two strangers when one stranger wants to dominate over others.
  3. When people become angry, they start using तँ.
1
sarcastic_gooner•

Can we not find a way to ban members whose sole contribution to the sub is spreading hate and misinformation?

1
kp--MOD :snoo_hug::table_flip:•

We try giving everyone the benefit of doubt, always. However, once their mod logs get big enough for us to go "Yeah this guy's a lost cause", we usually do ban them. It should take a lot of evidence to make a resolve to ban someone, because if you start breathing down their necks, well, it won't be a very pleasant thing to do. Needless gatekeeping.

Regardless, continue reporting these people, along with adding remarks about them in detail, it'll bring them on our radars immediately.

1
sarcastic_gooner•

Fairs. I'm gonna send a username in pm. Please check his comments. Bro's Def a lost cause imo.

1
Khairo_ganda•

You have kids asking about SEE and being depressed they didn't get into st xaviers.

Running a free for all SEX thread pinned at the top for horny freaks while there are actual children posting and running riot. Isn't it all too much?

Or you think they get real education from those threads?

1

Is there any architecture college inside Kathmandu valley to study in affordable budget😭

1
Think_Travel5752•

Am glad i found this community with helpful people

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1