I think Moana might've been the last Disney movie made that had a soul
Posted Jun 26, 2023, 6:36 PM UTC
Posted Jun 26, 2023, 6:36 PM UTC
I liked Encanto more than Moana.
This, Moana is okay, I give it a 7/10, but Encanto truly speaks to me and is the first movie to make me cry every single time I see it. Fuck when they hug and Do Ogruitas plays it’s absolutely breathtaking
I guess that's fair. I don't get why people like Encanto at all, but clearly many people did. To me it's one of the most incompetently written Disney films I have ever seen.
You're gonna have to back up that claim. You can't go around making wild hot takes without evidence perpared.
Lol, I thought we were having a friendly discussion about liking/not liking cartoons. I didn't know we were debating darwinism xD
If you want my opinion on Encanto, I wrote a longer explanation for my thoughts on the movie further down in the thread.
I don't mean to seem hostile, I'm just very blunt. I suppose I could have softened the language a bit.
While Casita coming back at the end was rather cliche, the magic was born from familial love, so I dont see why it can't bring it back. Your other criticisms are very strange, because the focus on the other characters is to establish the different ways that Abuela's attempts at keeping the family together has hurt each person individually. It's not just Mirabel who feels alienated. Bruno hid away because he feared what Abuela would do if she knew about the Mirabel prophecy, Luisa has attached her self-worth to how useful she is, and Isabela is forced into the suffocating role of playing "perfect".
The idea that nothing changed is a bizarre statement to make because the family is closer than they've ever been at the end. Abuela learned the error of her ways, Mirabel feels welcome for the first time since she was denied any powers, Bruno was welcomed back, Isabela is no longer restrained by the need to be perfect and can express her true feelings, and I don't remember what happened with Luisa so I can't comment on that part. Not much happened with the rest of the family, but they didnt get much attention in the narrative anyway. They were still well-written enough to be believable people despite their limited roles.
The film is about family, not just one person and her conflict with her grandmother. It might be a meme in this community, but themes are extremely important to stories. They're one of the core pillars alongside plot and character.
I also take issue with your dismissive use of "cartoons", as it sounds like you're saying animation is of lesser value than live-action.
I don't know if all of this sounds like an attack on you, but I'm only targeting your bad arguments, and everyone has bad takes every now and then.
Encanto
I guess some people liked they one. I gotta admit that I found that one extremely incompetently written.
What about the movie Soul?
Tbf that was Pixar but yeah that movie is good tho
I can't speak for that one since I never saw it. I do, however tend to separate Disney films from Pixar films.
Raya and the last dragon had potential. If only it would stop repeating the same lesson over and over for each act in the movie. It made it repetitive.
Even if one doesn’t like Encanto I don’t see any argument against it being a movie with a soul that was made with artistic merit
Encanto is a frustrating one because it has everything going for it. Amazing visuals, great music and energy, an interesting setup and then everything falls the fuck apart in the execution. I think that's why it was so difficult for someone like me to even connect with that movie because what should have been the heart and soul of the film (main girl's relationship with grandma) was shoved into a corner for 80% of the movie to make space for characters who served absolutely zero purpose to the core plot and then you get the last ten-ish minutes for main girl and grandma to rush through their emotional arks and finish the film with zero consequences, zero growth, zero lessons learned because everything returns to status quo by the end. Nothing lost, nothing gained. It was a deeply frustrating watch for me because there's no excuse for the execution of the story and pacing to be this amateur. It genuinely felt like an extended first episode to a Disney Channel show that somehow was given a massive budget to make it look good. I still have no idea why so many people love this film. My only conclusion is that after nearly two decades of shit, people will jump for joy when they get something mediocre.
Well I think a lot of people connected with the family and to say the girl has no arc just ain’t true. If you don’t like it fair enough but she clearly becomes more comfortable with herself and her powers as the story goes on
I didn't day she didn't go through an ark. I said that the ark was rushed and that there were zero consequences at the end of the day. Because there weren't. It seemed like they were setting up the idea of the family being forced to live without their powers and they even made an entire song about the family members realizing that they still had their abilities in a non-magical form and that they could still get the best out of it even though they were no longer magic. They were about to rebuild their house with their own hands and that was all such a beautiful message that made me go: Wauw. That's a really nice and comforting message.
And then they immediately get their powers back and the house builds itself and the girl still has no powers (which is fine) and everybody's internal conflicts are magically solved without having them earned at all (how the hell is the aunt suddenly okay with Bruno? Oh, right, because there's only five minutes left and we forgot to write in that confrontation, but we need to have them be friends again so weeee, now they are friends. Just don't think about it, lawl).
It completely invalidated the ending I thought they were setting up and the grandmother and the main girl's conflict was so rushed too because they barely spent time on it in order to make space for characters who didn't matter. Encanto is a shaggy dog story. It was too many ideas crammed into too short a runtime and it sacrificed the heart of the story for all these funny concepts that weren't relevant to anything.
I think they should have had balls and kept the ending where the family becomes normies, rebuilds their home and find peace in the new way to live. That way the main girl could have truly shined as she could step up as a guide and mentor for her family as they transitioned from one way of living to another that she knows everything about.
That would have been way more of a hard hitting ending than the main girl feeling more comfortable with herself. I mean, come on. Demand more from the movies they make for our kids.
Encanto is a shaggy dog story that could have been great but instead it's just a bunch of wasted potential and over stuffed ideas tied together with shitty pacing and a cowardly ending.
I don’t think your proposed ending hits harder tbh. It could have absolutely worked but would all depend on execution.
Something I noticed about the latest WDAS movies. They seemed to have move away from the “Twist Villain” trope, but now they have moved on to not really having villains at all.
And this seemed to have started with Moana.
I think a corrupted Goddess can be considered a villain. If anything, she’s the last twist villain except she’s a reverse twist villain. A villain who actually is good
I think you are correct there
And their gonna rape it with a live action remake less than ten years later
[deleted]
Nope: Coco
That's fair. Some people really liked that one and it's definitely not the worst film to come out of the studio, but I gotta admit that I forgot it shortly after watching it. It's a general problem I have had with any movie coming out of the disney studios the past 15 to 20 years. I'm aware that isn't true for everybody, but Disney movies are not the events they used to be and they are rarely talked about years later. They are there, have their moment in the sun, if even that, and then they go away again and every movie is basically a re-skin of the former. The Coco-type of Disney movie is the only story that's being told the past 7 to 10 years. It's just the same over and over and over again. But I agree that Coco is one of the least offensive ones out of the bunch. It's at least worth seeing. I cannot for the life of me see why I should watch Turning Red or Elemental etc. There's no reason to watch them and most people have already forgotten that they exist.
I highly doubt that 10 years from now, people will make cool fanart of most of the disney movies coming out these days.
Coco (2017) is fantastic on so many levels, though it’s only partly Disney.
I guess. It didn't do anything for me tbh. It wasn't bad, of course, but it was an in one ear, out the other experience for me. To be fair, so is Moana. I barely remember that film except for that one scene. All their films since the 2000s have been generic drivel in my opinion.
When I think about animated movies over the past 20 years that left an impact, then maybe a few Pixar films had a few moments where they did something, but the rest of the time I'd give it to DreamWorks for making something that's worth remembering.
At the end of the day, it's all just opinions, but the quality of the stories Disney have told for the past 20 years have been falling off a cliff. Movies like coco are pretty much the only story that has been told by the Disney studio over the past few years: a big family with a big culture having big cultural expectations for the main character who is different but is afraid to disappoint. It's every single Disney movie now. Bonus points if the films are supposedly based on the writer or director's own childhood experiences, and yet somehow it's just a re-skin of the Disney film that came before it. With every iteration of the same movie it becomes more generic, more forgettable. Right now we have that Elemental film that's a story about a big family with big expectations but the main character is different an afraid to disappoint. How original. Never seen that plot before. Did the screenwriter watch Coco too and think "I can do that"?
Disney movies have become so generic and uninteresting that the only way people will notice or care about them is if Disney can drum up outrage on social media. And that mostly happens with the live action remakes. All the new animated movies are not a priority for the studio. They seem like afterthoughts and they are often just shoved onto Disney+ with no fanfare or anything. And if they get to see the big screen, you will most likely not hear about them because the marketing budget was used on special toilet paper for the CEO.
I agree with your sentiment. Pixar used to provide quite original stories or at least an innovative take on the old ones, but now it’s mostly reassemble the same parts of ‘sure success’, sprinkle with some distorted modern values and put in a new, shiny package. People get sick of that.
It really sucks. It's also getting progressively harder to tell what is a Disney film and what is Pixar. They have lost their voices and now they just make the same type of whatever-movies.
Onward (2020) is one of my favorites