What is this plant that started growing in one of my pots? SE Michigan

Identified ✔
What is this plant that started growing in one of my pots? SE Michigan

Posted Jul 3, 2023, 6:38 PM UTC

18
OlDirtyPIumber•

Looks to be an Oak to me

6
opicanoOP•

Yeah it looks to be an oak, thanks !

2
interstellarboii•

Looks to be either a red or black oak seedling. If the buds are light brown and fuzzy it’s a black. If they’re reddish/brown and smooth then it’s a red.

3

What makes you think it’s one of these two?

In SE Michigan, we also have the following species in the red oak group: pin oak, Shumards oak, northern pin oak, and Scarlett oak.

What characteristics excluded these?

2
interstellarboii•

Fair question! I did my MS in forest ecology in Ann Arbor and have become familiar with tree species abundances and distributions across the lower peninsula. Scarlet and Shumards are rare in SE Michigan, the odds that this one is that is quite slim. But you bring up a good point, this could be Pin or even Northern pin. I know that Black and Red are extremely abundant and highly present around neighborhoods and therefore that’s why I suggested those two.

2

May I utilize your knowledge on the topic? I’ve had some issues getting solid answers on the red oak grouping in the area. (I once posted a picture of a “red oak” tree on the treeid subreddit, and was given 5 different answers, without any reasoning).

What are the definitive difference, excluding growing conditions, between northern red oak, Shumards oak, Scarlett oak, northern pin oak, and pin oak?

From what I have heard, leaf variations seem too high to really help, and buds can often vary within a species. Acorn sizes seem to help, but there is often overlap. Any knowledge you can share would be great.

Thanks!

2
opicanoOP•

Yep after looking oak up it looks to be one! Thanks for the extra info about the two types! I think they were smooth but I would have to check again

1
WoodSteelStone•

If it started growing in one of your pots take a look around to see if there is an oak nearby. Chances are a squirrel has picked up an acorn close by and buried it in your pot. If you can find an oak close by it could well be the parent plant and then you'll know what you've got. There are ~600 species of oak worldwide and about 90 are found in North America.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1