r/LOONA•
joalityy

Why do I feel weird buying OEC's new album?

Discussion

Hey there! I'm, obviously, super excited for OEC's comeback, it's been a (long) while!

However, due to everything that happened to LOONA and how Modhaus' treats the promotions for this release & the nfts, I feel really weird buying their album. Does anyone else feel this way? I don't know, I guess I want assurance that there's nothing wrong with buying the album lol. I know this sounds silly, but I can't seem to bring myself to pre-order it haha.

Anyways, let's support their work!

Posted Jul 4, 2023, 12:43 AM UTC

2139
araelr🦉 Kim Loop•

Buy the album. Give the girls who are free money.

54
Sea-Masterpiece-8133https://bit.ly/3nYzhG5•

There's nothing wrong with wanting to buy the album. And there's also nothing wrong with not buying it if you don't feel like it. Albums are expensive, so I would take the time to think about whether I really want to buy them or if it's something I feel compelled to do.

53
joalityyOP•

thanks, i think i will! just wanted other opinions :)

6
Sea-Masterpiece-8133https://bit.ly/3nYzhG5•

Awesome! Just do whatever makes you happy :)

Edit: also I would check the pre-order events, so you might get an extra pc!

3
JoggyFroggy🐸 YeoJin•

The photocards in the album aren't nfts unless you scan them in on the app. So you can absolutely buy them album and never be involved in the nfts, by just not scanning the card. I will be doing this and I highly recommend others do as well

51
joalityyOP•

I see, i read something about this but wasn’t so sure how it worked. Thank you so much :)

5
KewaBruh•

the nfts are good though, you can vote on future events OEC holds, just like tripleS!

1
pika_chuuwuLOOΠΔ 🌙 @pika_chuuves on twitter•

I have the same issues with the promotions and NFTs, but still chose to preorder to show support for what should matter, the music... and to show the girls that Orbits haven't left. I understand feeling conflicted though, especially after learning what happened to all the money we spend on albums under BBC.

50
HawkKing2000LOOΠΔ is 12🌙•

The success of this comeback is going to show the world that the girls from Loona are still a force to be reckoned with and it's going to show BBC what they missed out on. Everyone please buy/stream everything that you conscience (and pocketbook) allow. A big success could also entice the other Loona members to come together again as a group, IMHO... Just don't scan the photocards, and ignore the nfts issue entirely...

In the end, it's all about the music, the videos, the choreo, the fan support and those girls bringing home a BIG PAYCHECK. Anything that makes money for the girls is alright by me.

I wonder if Orbits are still strong enough to drive this song to #1 in countries around the world. I have a feeling that they are...

43
joalityyOP•

True, I really want them to succeed with this comeback! Thank you :)

5
amandapearl2🦋 Go Won•

Just don't scan the photocards, and ignore the nfts issue entirely

This is what I'm doing. I preordered 3 copies but I'm treating the PCs as regular PCs.

5
aidan226•

Omg if I'm not mistaken I remember your username from YouTube since early predebut era. A fellow classic orbit!

2
HawkKing2000LOOΠΔ is 12🌙•

Yep. Been there since the debut of Vivid, mostly commenting on YouTube. Can't believe it's been almost 7 years since Vivid :)

2
aidan226•

Same here! I think you mightve commented on a few of my old videos too iirc. I'm "My Account with No Shame" on YT 😁

2
HawkKing2000LOOΠΔ is 12🌙•

Oh, right. I definitely your YT username, I think from reaction videos. Nice to see loyal Orbits from pre-debut who have stuck it out through all the ups and downs :)

1
jax621•

There’s nothing wrong with buying the album

27
Jasher1125•

It’s your money, and you do with it what you want. I’m convinced that a majority of the NFT critiques don’t even understand what they’re even mad about. It’s pop music.

14
colorlust•

If Modhaus had just never used the word NFT early on and only had called them digital photo cards which immediately, directly pay the girls before their break even date I truly don’t think the discourse would be happening. There’s so much “all nft bad” groupthink and it’s a bit brain melting.

25
FearnotsBunnies•

NME - TripleS has a big NFT element, where fans use them to vote for members and songs. Why did you want to incorporate NFTs into the group?

Jaden - “The NFT itself is not a core value of our system. I started this project to have more participation from fans and more activity. As a voting tool, the NFT has a certain value and transparency because it cannot be manipulated. We could vote via email, text or CD, but we’ve seen many manipulation scandals. With this technology, we have integrity in our votes. TripleS is a girl group with many decisions made by fan vote, not a girl group with NFTs.”

NME - NFTs generally have been quite controversial and there’s been a big backlash from fans when other K-pop agencies have announced plans involving them. How much did you consider that potential negative reaction before you launched?

Jaden - “When we chose NFTs as the voting tool, we knew there would be a possible bad reaction. We are trying to put as much effort in [as possible] so fans don’t see our NFT as being the same as other agencies’. We believe other agencies are treating NFTs as another type of merchandise to sell to fans and that’s the opposite of what we intend.

Jaden - “The reason fans appreciate our ‘objekt’ is because it’s just an ordinary photo card [which becomes an NFT when scanned into the Cosmo app]. So fans buy the photo cards and then have the opportunity to participate in the voting and decision-making. Many K-pop fans are teenagers and don’t even have a credit card so we don’t think they’re going to buy our objekts as assets for investment and that’s not what we intend either. That’s why you can’t find the word NFT on our app or web page.”"

from https://www.nme.com/news/music/jaden-jeong-triples-acid-angel-from-asia-disband-controversy-interview-modhaus-nft-3363178

Yeah he agrees with you.

21
pdantix06🐟 JinSoul•

I’m convinced that a majority of the NFT critiques don’t even understand what they’re even mad about.

you'd be right. people are still parroting the "ethereum bad" lines. no one bothers to do any research into what they're mad about, they just regurgitate whatever large follower twitter account said

-1†
BlackCatCadillac•

100%

1†
indicolite_moon•

This time I hope the girls get paid (they will since they might have got better deals in their new contract) and the success of the album will contribute. So buy it, also it's a big f u to BBC if they succeed.

14
joalityyOP•

true, that’s what’s in the back of my mind 😅 but just trust them and support them right? thank you :)

6
HawkKing2000LOOΠΔ is 12🌙•

The best part of this is going to be the big f u to BBC :)

3
KewaBruh•

the girls get a cut of each NFT MODHAUS sells btw

1
lucxssebx•

so you guys complain about buying objekts (which is modhaus’ main source of income and directly pays the girls a percentage of the sales) and then feel “weird” to support them by buying the albums? bffr… how do you guys expected them to make money? making mvs, producing songs, doing visuals… that costs A LOT OF MONEY

12
UriGoo•

On god some of them are ridiculous! Plus some are bitching about concert prices being $80 saying its too much and that it's ONLY 3 members, like what? If it was 12 members or 1 I would still be there and if they were in the states and had dates on the west coast I would be willing to spend 4 times that ticket price (yes I'm broke bitch for concerts). Some Orbits don't realize how lucky they are to be so close to the tour dates and the fact of how amazing it is that any of this is even happening at all smh.

6†
NewJeansBunnie🐇 HeeJin•

I went to over 20 concerts last year and have been to over 15 this year and still have lots to go.

The most expensive shows in order are:

  1. TWICE
  2. Red Velvet
  3. (G)I-DLE
  4. LOONA
  5. ODD EYE CIRCLE
  6. Charli XCX
  7. Lil Yachty
  8. Carly Rae Jepson
  9. Hot Chip

Notice anything about the first 5? Thats right. They are all KPOP. Because KPOP shows are overpriced. It's just a fact.

We can complain about prices and still go anyway. Not everyone is made of money.

Rina Sawayama did an incredible world tour and tickets were like £40.

£110 for OEC is overpriced.

3
Zeusicideal-Heart🦌 ViVi•

its really stupud too because its about breaking even! 80 a ticket might just be what needs to be earned to break even.

2
manonforever•

I honestly think orbits have insane expectations and that it’s ruining it.

How lucky are we that five of the girls are the same agency? That we get them back as the same unit? That we get to continue the same lore and story? So yeah the promo is rushed and some decisions are debatable - but man we’re getting an OEC comeback 2023 OUTSIDE of BBC like can we for a second think about how lucky we are? I honestly don’t see what it is to feel weird about. It’s just novelty and we’re not sure what to expect - but we know the girls are excited, doing the job they love with people they love, are getting paid this time around (and sold 83k NFT in 12 days??? Which they’re getting a generous cut off? Hellooooooo). I’m considering leaving Twitter because of how annoyed I am at orbits lately honestly. Can we just CELEBRATE for a minute or whatttt

12
amandapearl2🦋 Go Won•

This is such an excellent point. 6 months ago I thought we were done for, so getting anything OEC is amazing, they're what made me a stan and started me on the LOONA journey. Now we know everyone except Yves are only in 3 companies, that has to be relatively easy to manage right? A future OT12 comeback is possible in a way I never hoped for or could even fathom.

1
manonforever•

Exactly!! We went from absolutely nothing to 11/12 signed, a mini album announced and a tour??? Like it’s insane, no one could have expected better outcomes tbh

1
kennethawesome🦌 ViVi•

I usually pre-order/decide after the agency posted the design. This time, it's still all ????. So far I ignored all the First Class Objekt as it's not something I'm interested in. With the new start and the concept seems interesting, I pulled the trigger and ordered the Choerry version.

10
joalityyOP•

same, i think that’s what i’ll do! thanks :)

2
MissyBee37•

I guess I'm curious why you feel weird about it? Like, what part is bothering you? Do you buy other albums?

I'm also bothered by the NFTs but am just choosing to ignore them. I can't control what Modhaus does with its business model and I admire what the team is doing on the creative side. I loved what Jaden did with Loona the first time, and clearly the girls trust him, too, or they wouldn't have gone back to him. As other replies say, you do not have to participate in NFTs. My photocards will go in my binder and never be scanned.

If you want the albums and you want to support the girls, there shouldn't be any reason not to buy it, so if you're looking for reassurance, go for it :) If you don't want it, that's okay, too. There are other ways to support the girls (watch their videos, stream the album, etc.). Don't feel pressured to buy it. Fandoms always want the biggest success possible for our artists, of course, but you don't have to buy anything to be a fan. Whatever you choose, it'll be okay. :)

I personally have already pre-ordered all 3 versions but I can afford that and Odd Eye Circle was my favorite subunit all along, so I've been ready for this for years. No hesitation here.

8
joalityyOP•

I guess it’s just something in the back of my mind making me worried about this, so it’s not that i feel “weird” - because i do buy other albums - it’s just that i’m worried. but i do trust the girls in making the right decision for them, so it doesn’t make any sense, does it? i guess i’ll end up buying it, i do want the album and if it supports them it’s a plus! thank you for your words, it did help :)

4
Zeusicideal-Heart🦌 ViVi•

buy the album so Modhaus has funds to promote/grow.

3
Betchuuta🦌ViVi🐧Chuu🦢Yves🌙LOOΠΔ•

If you're considering ethical consumption deeply, then I don't think kpop albums and nfts in this case are so different. I don't think the girls' pics are really a part of a pyramid scheme, and I don't think the environmental impact of their nfts are that different than the impact kpop albums have. I think they are sold similarly as collectables too. And they're both not worth the money. This seems harsh as one is music and the other is just a photo but do you own a cd player? I don't. Having a physical copy of the art i love is important if the internet were to ever go down or smth but i don't love this album i never heard it before. Tbh I'm not buying it for the music. I'm buying for the photos, and to support them and to have as collectable. Very similar reasons for an nft. Why do I pre-order if I don't really see it as ethical consumption? Well because I want to support the girls, and I want them to know we're still here wanting more music. And I love seeing their albums on my shelf. I do feel like sick about the nefarious ways bbc made them but each album reminds me more of the joy of being an orbit than anything else. And I want more memories. So basically, do what you can afford and what brings you joy. There are many ways to support them.

1
SoWiT🐺 Olivia Hye•

No.

-3