[Waybound] Question, who hid Libdon's memory?

Cradle

During the tournament, Lindon tried to show his friends the memory he had of Suriel showing him the strongest in the world. Someone had altered it, however, and it's never mentioned in the books.

Who did that? Was it Emriss? Suriel?

Posted Jul 5, 2023, 7:58 PM UTC

3523
VDrk72•

Suriel herself probably. It was probably one of the abidan stipulations around altering a worlds fate. Suriel was allowed to take Lidnon outside the timestream and show him stuff to motivate him, but she couldn't allow his memories spread that knowledge or let his memories reveal her existence. It was probably a rule that was built around worlds that aren't as connected to the greater multiverse as Cradle, and therefore dont have the same access to the knowledge of the Abidan and the Judges, but also still applies to Cradle.

25
issaaccbb•

I don't think it is quite as grand as that. There are instances where the Abidan reveal themselves and is hinted they have done so before, otherwise the monarchs wouldn't know of them of their "rules"

Likely it was for Lindon's protection as much as anything. Think about that Malice would gain from directly reading those memories?

1
VDrk72•

In the case of the Abidan revealing themselves, it was either in severe circumstances (like the fight with the Mad King in both Fathom and Cradle) or it was a pre-approved action. Suriel was operating entirely out of personal desire when she showed Lindon the Monarchs, so she has to follow more strict conditions. While during something like the Uncrowned Tournament, the Abdian intervention was approved and pushed through the proper channels, so the conditions were probably bypassed for that instance.

As for the protection thing, what would somebody like Malice have to gain from the knowledge? She's already aware of the other Monarchs and the abidan, and it's not like Suriel told Lindon anything secret about their paths or plans. There's just nothing that important that it needed to be blocked.

1
bonly•

She only hid her presence, Ghoststrider's survival, and Sha Miara's ascension. She didn't hide or alter herself.

It was that grand. She was fine letting anyone who could steal Lindon's memories see what she said to him in general but she hid anything that might change the world's fate (probably no Northstrider memories, Sha Miara is hidden, etc).

1
issaaccbb•

IIRC, she spent quite a bit of time changing her appearance such as eyes and hair, so yeah, she really did alter herself

1
Sari-Not-SorryTeam Malice•

She didn't hide or alter herself.

From Wintersteel:

It wasn’t Suriel. She resembled the heavenly messenger in many ways. She wore white, but instead of the smooth, almost liquid armor of the Abidan, she was dressed in a white-and-silver coat, shirt, and long skirt. Her hair was more brown than dark green, and it hung naturally behind her. Her purple eyes made her look like a member of the Akura clan, and she spoke while stretching her neck and wincing. There was a bend to her nose as though she’d broken it at one point.

1
Andrew_42Team Dross•

It never occurred to me it COULD have been anyone but Suriel.

Nobody else knew he had those memories. Not till after he tried sharing them that is.

There's an outside chance Makiel or Eithan could have, but if they could, so could Suriel, and we get no indication either of them had any motivation that Suriel wouldn't have had, and there aren't any moments that look like one of them was doing anything to modify Lindon's memories.

I'd wager it was just some kind of automated memory safeguard Suriel keeps running so nobody can harvest detailed information from dream tablets of encounters with higher level Abidan. To reduce risk of altering fate too highly.

20
bonly•

It could have been one other entity and they are most likely: her presence. That seems the most likely entity to do some working that wouldn't impact Lindon's memories but would block a pseudo-presence.

-1
effortfulcrumload•

Either Suriel or Makiel. He interfered in... Skysworn I think. We know he altered fate so that the Bleeding Phoenix would wake, but he could have done more to prevent Lindon from sharing with "Ozreal's descendant"

6
tndarisTeam Dross•

During this scene Mercy is saying she's never heard of a technique to alter memories for everyone else but not for yourself. Then Eithan mentions something like, "If she were a heavenly messenger I suspect she could do anything."

So I think it was clearly indicating that Suriel masked those memories. She probably let Lindon keep the original memories because it was supposed to be a source of motivation for him.

1
TwiceTestedOP•

I mean, Emriss could have done it? I'm pretty sure she is the only one on cradle that has the knowledge and will to do such a working. But that's my only guess.

Of course Suriel could have done it, but why? Would it really affect things so much?

Could Charity have done it? She's got the dream aura, but it doesn't quite fit her character. She doesn't seem the type to just read ppl's minds and then make changes.

The biggest question is why Will set this up, and did NOTHING with it? Almost as tragic as the disappearance of servant 113 or the loss of the great Mu Enkai.

-45
retief1•

In general, Suriel was very careful to not affect anything. I'm fairly sure that letting lindon keep his memories was already bending the rules. Given who Suriel is, I think it is completely reasonable that she'd try to bend the rules as little as possible, and hiding lindon's memories from anyone else is completely in line with that.

8
bonly•

The Abidan aren't allowed to change the fate of worlds. It goes against all of the rules of the Abidan to have Suriel leave Lindon with those memories (Northstrider's status and Sha Miara's ascension are both fate breaking)and let's be honest, it was probably a retcon that made it where only Lindon could access those memories.

3
TsaVix•

You don't think that was a deliberate and thought-out way to show that while Judges and other high ranking Abidan can affect an individual's fate as long as it does not unduly change the world's fate. This is reiterated numerous times throughout the books and is precisely a reason for Makiel's actions to force the team out of Cradle. The longer they stayed the greater they impacted and stained the iteration.

1
tndarisTeam Dross•

Of course Suriel could have done it, but why? Would it really affect things so much?

Considering Suriel was worried about the runes in her eyes affecting Cradle too much, I'm gonna go with yes. She did it because otherwise it has a chance to interfere with Cradle's Fate too much and she's literally bound by the Eledari Pact to not do that. She might not even have had a choice, letting Lindon keep his memories could easily have been the limit of what the Pact allowed.

The biggest question is why Will set this up, and did NOTHING with it?

You sort of answered your own question, there are tons of other little things in Cradle that are set up and not fully 100% explicitly explained to the reader.

Personally, I don't think any book that meticulously answers every detail 100% makes it a "better" book in any way, especially in fantasy. That sounds like a textbook to me.

Leaving things unknown allows the reader to fill in the gaps however we want. So while you will probably never get any real answers to your questions here, the best answer is feel free to believe whatever you want.

1
Ok_Worker_2940•

The best part of Cradle is that its such an open world and that not every gun needs to be fired. Will could write a story in some other part of Cradle without ever even mentioning Lindon & Co because that's how expansicr and alive the world feels.

1
Arcane_Pozhar•

To clarify my stance upfront, I am sure this was done by Suriel (and felt this way instantly, with no confusion).

I felt like it was a natural continuation of Suriel being cautious to not change fate. So this, to me, was not a setup with no pay off. It was a character of immense power who has the wisdom and foresight to be aware that mind reading and memory sharing techniques exist, and preventively blocking such techniques from revealing things she didn't want revealed.

I agree that the other characters you are mentioning who might have the power generally lack motive. And honestly, if it was done by any of them, that would feel like something which would have been set up more cleanly, and which would have been addressed later.

Suriel just makes sense in-story for the reason I mentioned, and in a meta, good writing sense, for various reasons which I think this thread hammered out pretty well.

1
dmurph123•

I always took it implied it was just a thing with the abidan with either Suriel consciously doing it or her presence automatically doing so to not cause too much divergence from fate.

1
ObnoxiousQuestions•

Everything I came here to say has already been said.

So instead, I'll make up a random crazy fan theory:

Northstrider altered the memory. It was Dross's projection that was faulty, not Lindon's version of it. Dross was made in Northstrider's pocket world that was designed to make an Abidan-style presence. He didn't want to ascend but did want the toys. His personal biases regarding the Abidan are reflected in all byproducts therein. So Dross made her look less magnificent, though Dross himself was unaware of his inaccuracies.

Hmmm.... wasn't there another discrepancy... the little girl Monarch? That's an easy one... they didn't want that word getting out, so they made all of the other monarchs swear an oath not to pass that information along, which, in the nature of other soul oaths we've seen, is more about the spirit of the promise rather than the specific wording, so it also applied to Dross as a sort of derivative of Northstrider.

How'd I do?? ;-)

1
bonly•

On that same note: this is why I think it was Suriel's presence...it's a block that literally works on a pseudo-presence but doesn't block Lindon's memories.

1
bonly•

It's pretty clear it was Suriel and her presence. Lindon knowing Northstrider was alive or Sha Miara was monarch are a bit fate breaking...but not if he can't prove he isn't making it up.

1
TheeGreatPap•

While everyone says it was Suriel. I think it was the Monarchs themselves. They altered reality with the same oath that bound Sha Maria to Underlord level. And we know Monarchs working together can do alot when it comes to shifting reality. Because Suriel had no reason to hide it to begin with. People knowing would be from Lindon and Lindon spoke of her before..and those who knew were those who could truly alter fate by themselves.

Also if it was Suriel I don't think it'd be masked in some shody dream/ memory. Whoever it was would just not remember it at all or if they saw an alternate memory they'd see a cleae convincing one.

1
Kallusim•

Obligatory I'm on mobile and yadda yadda.

For some reason, my first time reading it, I was under the impression it was the 9 cloud court. Especially with the whole Sha Miara/Lialla thing. I had been under the impression they had changed things somehow from there such as the presence speaking vs "suriel" speaking.

This was somehow done as a result of the crowning of Sha Miara directly, where somehow the minds that had been subjected to it filled in their own details in a way that made sense to the individuals.

As far as Mercy's comment about her not knowing of any way that could happen that another commentor mentioned, that could be a further part of it - that basically the magic makes it so that nobody below a certain power level could be aware of it.

In regards to it not affecting Lindon, it could be that he's protected by Suriel (being in close proximity to her marble maybe).

And all of this is adding up to be probably more than what could be done by someone at Monarch level, though it could be a few of them together somehow having done it. Still, probably not the case, and more likely someone like Suriel like a lot of people are suggesting.

-1