This has bothered me for years. Literally unplayable.

Posted Jul 7, 2023, 12:48 AM UTC

Posted Jul 7, 2023, 12:48 AM UTC
I'm confused. What's unplayable?
Everything is in chronical order except for the expansion chapters, they are in reversed order.
LWS Episodes/Quarterly updates are in descending order, while Expansion acts are in ascending order. In the screenshot you have:
Hah! Okay that is annoying
I’ve never noticed this, that is indeed weirdly inconsistent. Thanks for irritating me as well
Thanks for irritating me as well
I knew I'd get some posts like this. You're welcome. :)
My entire evening is ruined now
Yeah I'm so used to it, I don't even think about it. If I knew it at one point, it was a long time ago.
Boy you must love the fact that the story achievements are (mostly) ordered top-recent to bottom-old, while the "Return to" achievements are top-old to bottom-recent!
That doesn't bother me since they're different sections.
Though it does annoy me that The Origins of Madness category didn't get moved to the Story Journal section like other returning LWS1 categories.
I am returned player after 6+ years away, so I decided to start a new character and play through the story, while I am trying to keep track of my progress I do notice the same thing and it bothering me every time and I thought it was just me, now know other people feel the same way as I do, and thinking of people getting annoyed for the same reason is bother me more.
Sorry! The one guy who could still understand the UI panel code left a few years ago so they can't do anything about this.
Windows control panel, but it's GW2
I wish they deleted the Story Journal category and just moved each act/episode into a new category named after every expansion/season (the ones for expansions already exist anyway).
I don't want to spend minutes scrolling down just to reach the Collections section. No thanks.
For the same reason I don't want to spend my time scrolling manually between Tyria and Cantha every time.
Collections should be inside General or Core anyway, there's no reason why they should have their own category.
I say leave it like this:
Also, give the menu an option to hide 100% completed sections and categories.
I don't know about logical or good looking, but I feel like this is the most convenient order actually. The latest release is always at the top, and if a single release has more than one chapter/act, they're in the order you will be playing them.
It makes sense if you're done with each release before the next one arrives.
What’s worse is that EoD acts are labeled in Roman numerals while PoF and HoT acts are in Arabic numerals
Where's the issue?
Just gonna copy/paste another comment of mine in this thread:
LWS Episodes/Quarterly updates are in descending order, while Expansion acts are in ascending order. In the screenshot you have:
Just so you know, it used to be in the correct order once (Act 4, Act 3, Act 2, Act 1, so that everything is in chronologically descending order), but then they changed it in one of the patches. Yeah, I don't know why either. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Changing it to put the newer stuff at the top seems fair enough, but they ought to at least get it right for everything instead of the expansion chapters being backwards.
Again, it WAS right for a long time. Oldest stuff on the bottom, newest stuff on the top, expansions acts in backwards order, so that if you go from the bottom up - it's all in chronological order. But THEN they specifically rearranged expansion acts to be in numerical order for some reason.
It's happened fairly recently, I think, in 2022 perhaps.
Oh, no, definitely not.
It has been out of order for YEARS. Well before EoD launched. Before IBS started, even.
Originally, ArenaNet had it oldest first -> newest last. This changed sometime post-HoT because people complained about having to scroll down for the latest release.
TBH, I'm not sure the expansions were ever "last act on top".
They were. Look no further than the wiki: August 2020
In September of 2020 the wiki switched displaying the list of achievement from being hardcoded into the page to being a template that collects ordering from each achievement category wiki page, so the search needs to be continued there. There Kvothe swapped the order of, for example, PoF categories around on March 26 of 2022:
https://wiki.guildwars2.com/index.php?title=Path_of_Fire:_Act_1&diff=2477809&oldid=2212619
https://wiki.guildwars2.com/index.php?title=Path_of_Fire:_Act_3&diff=2477808&oldid=2334696
... I swear I remember it having the oldest stuff at the top (starting with Gates of Maguuma), but now I'm having trouble finding a source or even update notes for the change ...
You are correct, during Season 2 and HoT, and some of S3, the oldest stuff was at the top beginning with Gates of Maguuma.
It was changed because people complained of having to scroll to the latest release. I am pretty sure it was mid-Season 3 that this change happened.
I'm moderately certain it used to be like that in the very beginning, when the story journal section was first added. Then, when it grew too big, they decided to swap the order so that the newest stuff in on top and thus more easily accessible. Then, recently-ish, they swapped the order of expansion acts so that they're in numerical order.
Probably broke it the same time they broke the quest list so that fractal dailies no long display properly. All you see is 4 of the same fractal instead of one of each of the daily. Whomever broke it never bothered to go back and fix it.
Changing the ordering of categories was definitely a deliberate choice.
Technically they are still in chronological order of release, just not story order.