[Program Review] 1 Year of 5/3/1 and No Rest Days
TLDR: Former high school athlete gets fat in college, gets sick of being fat, starts rock climbing, starts lifting for "balance", and gets jacked.
Training History
- 3 sport athlete (Nordic skiing, Lacrosse, Karate)
- Become sedentary in college
- Graduate (2017) and pick up rock climbing for some exercise
- Pandemic hits, progress resets kinda, keep climbing ~2 times per month
- Start of 2022 I (male) weigh 260lbs at 5'9" for all time high
- Get serious and climb A LOT
- Want more activity but finger tendons can't take more days
- Start lifting because climbing gym has good equipment
Why 5/3/1?
I had never trained with barbells before wanted to start and lots of the recommendations from others and the description in the wiki made 531 seem to be a good choice for someone whose main focus was another sport (rock climbing in my case).
As I was reading it, I seemed to vibe with the simplicity ESPECIALLY with the flexibility of the accessories because I didn't want to feel "locked" into doing some exercises as a beginner (I dunno why I thought but whatever).
Results
I am a male 28 year old and I am 5'9".
Strength results
Not to brag but I think I crushed it. Out of this year I only missed 2 weeks of lifting due to trips but I did run 52 weeks of 5/3/1 templates.
Starting training max -> current TM
- Squat: 185lbs -> 370lbs
- Bench: 125lbs -> 200lbs
- Deadlift: 180lbs -> 385lbs
- Strict Press: 90lbs -> 145lbs
Weight loss (and slight gain) results
Night before first lifting ~200lbs
My primary goal at the time of starting was just to lose more weight. I wanted to hit 160lbs because losing 100lbs sounded neat. But I thought adding some muscle along the way would help my look better at the end. Pretty quickly I fell in love with lifting weights and changed my goals around to trying to do everything, including getting a lot stronger.
Training
TLDR 2: I'll talk a bit about the 5/3/1 program here including the templates I ran and the rules I broke.
So from the results section, the savvy reader will see that my squat and deadlift training maxes increased A LOT. Way more than a year of 531 would have as written. To find my initial training maxes I just went in one day and did all 4 lifts until I did a set of ~5 reps that felt like a 5rm, calculated the e1rm off that, and set the training max to 90% of that. Turns out I sandbagged the ABSOLUTE FUCK out of my squat and deadlift and after I figured out my technique (~1-2 months in) I was hitting like 20+ reps on my 1+ sets and just was not enjoying doing that many friggin reps.
To rectify this I just doubled the rate of progression on squat and deadlift until the AMRAP sets seemed to fall into a more acceptable range. So 20lbs increase every cycle rather than 10lbs. This is the most egregious foul I committed with 5/3/1 and (nearly) everything else was done as written.
Over the course of the whole year I dropped my training maxes back twice on all lifts whenever they got a little too tough and grindy.
Beginner 5/3/1 (ran for 9 cycles, 6 months)
So I say I ran stuff as written but I made a big edit here. I added a 4th day of Press/Deadlift to the template because I figured I would benefit from the extra touches each week and it would be fine. In hindsight, this is kinda dumb because with this change I'm basically doing 5/3/1 FSL at 2x the barbell volume which is a lot. I think I got away with it because I was a HUGE beginner and the extra touches did benefit me but someone getting into this with more lifting history probably shouldn't do this.
Each week I would do the first AMRAP of the week fairly hard but on the 2nd day of that lift I would try to get 2 more reps than the previous day. No real reason for this choice but at the time I wasn't tracking my PRs SUPER closely but I think it did a good job of pushing me closer to failure than I might have otherwise gone.
I did no deloads on this template because I didn't feel I needed them I just full sent it. Once I learned I could do pistol squats though, I oversent it and ended up with a tendinopathy in my left quad caused by overuse (from my Orthopedic visit).
That was the end of 5/3/1 for beginners and I purchased 5/3/1 Forever at this point.
Injury rehab
I did my first deload after the tendon thing and couldn't squat for roughly 3 weeks. I could deadlift fine and press. This was in January of 2023 and actually around the time u/mythicalstrength torn his hamstring and replaced squats with good mornings. So I thought, "Fuck it, I'll do that too". So for this deload and change I did replaced all squats with good mornings and kept it going.
5/3/1 Full Body Boring But Big (4 Leader Cycles with anchors in between 2 leaders)
From the beginner template I found that I really enjoyed doing two compound movements each work out; just seemed to jive with me. BBB is a template I had seen recommended a lot for people moving on from the beginner so I thought I would too and Forever had a Full body version in it.
This is another largeish edit I made; when doing 5s PRO with a full body template I have added two down sets to make it a weird pyramid 5x5 because I felt dumb on setting up and doing 3 sets each day. So week 1 would go 65%-75%-85%-75%-65% all with 5 reps. Just seemed like a sneaky way to add more volume so I did it. Rulebreaker.
Jim no longer recommends this full body version and I definitely get why. As written, the intensity on the 5x10s just feels too low to be as effective as regular BBB seems it would be by doing them post AMRAP set.
On the second leader cycle I increased the BBB intensity each week going 50% week 1, 60% week 2, and 70% week 3 and that seemed a lot better (and way fucking hard in week 3) to keeping the sets hard and effective. If I run this again I think I'll do 60-65-70 but I would suggest people play with it if they choose to go with FBBBB.
5/3/1 Widowmakers (1 Anchor)
This was really fucking hard. I was toying with running Super Squats around the time and decided I'd do a pseudo trial run by doing 20 rep sets with this template and it was rough.
I caused myself to hyperventilate in my car while driving to W3 squat day by trying to visualize my way through 20 reps of 250lbs. I crushed the set but fuck me that drive was spooky.
Main problem I encountered was my strict press WOULD not do 20 reps or even 15. This was maybe a symptom of a TM that was too high or maybe im just bad. To do something I replaced the 1x20 with 2 AMRAP sets with 30-45 seconds rest in-between, which also sucked so mission accomplished I think.
Simplest Strength Template SST (1 anchor)
I really liked this as an anchor. It was MUCH harder than anticipated but the blend of BBB and SSL for the supplemental work after the AMRAP set was really hard. So I felt it was very effective. Will run again.
Full Body, 4 Days (4 leaders, 1 Anchor)
This is my current template I am on and I selected it because I wanted the higher intensity of SSL rather than what I was doing with FBBBB. SSL is way harder than I really thought it was gonna be and the 50-100 reps of accessories instead of FBBBB's 25-50 was kicking my ass.
After the first cycle of this I finally abandoned my desire to keep losing weight/maintaining and actually finally started eating how I should've been.
I think this template is super effective for me but that may just be a bias from getting stronger due to gaining 10-15lbs on it and getting (unsurprisingly) way stronger.
Accessories
I had no set plan on a given day for what accessories to do. I would simply go in, begin lifting, and then make calls on what accessories to do.
I did superset an accessory with every working compound set.
In no particular order the 5 accessories I think I did the most of for each were
PUSH
- Dumbell Press (all sorts)
- Push ups
- Tricep cable pushdown
- 6 ways
- Single arm landmine press
PULL
- Neutral Grip pull ups
- single arm dumbbell row
- meadows rows
- Hammer Curls
- Drag curls
Single Leg/Core
- Single Leg RDLs
- Kettlebell swings
- Cossack squats
- Tibia Raises
- Hanging leg raises
NON-LIFTING TRAINING
5/3/1 as written says to do conditioning on your non-lifting days but doesn't really say a TON about what you should be doing EXACTLY. So I just assume that the rest of the stuff I do is sufficient to satisfy Wendler's conditioning criteria.
And I do a lot of shit. u/gzcl made his posts about training with no rest days and it really resonated with me. So I abandoned my foolish ideas that I needed a rest day each week and just built up to doing more and more.
In about October of 2022 I signed back up for Karate and began going again and totally felt at home again. I've been competing again and doing some teaching and coaching of kids which has all been really good for me.
All told, my current activities of the week include:
- 4 days of lifting (all in the morning, 50-90 minutes each)
- 3-4 climbing sessions (45-90 minutes each)
- 2 Yoga sessions (90 minutes each)
- 6-7 Karate sessions (45 minutes each)
- I attempt to jog 2x per week (30-40 minutes each)
Abandoning the idea of NEEDING rest was extremely freeing. I just kept adding activity as I wanted to and felt that I could recover from. And my overall capacity has just grown and grown. I feel like I'm up for anything at any time and I'm just the MOST FIT I've ever been in my entire life and I'm loving it.
I encourage everyone to try adding more physical activity to their week even if it's just walking or some sort of light sport. It changed a ton for me.
And if you have a gym membership that includes free yoga classes and you aren't taking advantage of that you need to change that.
Diet and Nutrition
Initially, I just cut my calories to <2000 per day at the start of 2022 and the rate of loss shows how rough that was. At the time I just wanted to not be fat anymore. I also quit drinking at the start of 2022 and have remained sober to this day (and hopefully forever).
Throughout this program I was weighing in daily and tracking (almost) all of my calories. My TDEE fluctuated a bit but stuck around ~3200-3400 calories. I ate ~170g of protein per day and had no other macro targets. I was eating ~2400-2800 calories per day during the flat period from the graph above. And when I went to "bulk" I stopped tracking except to make sure I was hitting protein.
Primary staples of my diet were:
- eggs
- chicken
- greek yogurt
- whey products (pwder, protein bars)
- cheese
- whole grain bread
- bell peppers and onions
I dunno, I tried to eat like an adult as best I could and I think it has worked out.
CONCLUSION & CLOSING THOUGHTS
Turns out if you've never lifted a barbell before and you run a decent program you get way stronger. Crazy.
The last ~18 months of my life have been a whirlwind and I honestly don't think I'd ever have thought I could be as fit (and sober) as I am now. I feel like a completely new person and that is thanks (in part) to finding a good program for me and the surrounding fitness communities I have found and participated in.
The wiki has been absolutely invaluable to me and I just want to thank the folks of r/weightroom and r/Fitness who have contributed to it. And to the general users of both who have been helpful and engaging along the way. The posts and the comments and the logs and the questions have given me good insights as I've gone on this journey.
So thanks.
If anyone has any questions about this post or 5/3/1 in general I'd be more than happy to answer them, this post kinda ran away from me on length.
Posted Jul 16, 2023, 6:15 PM UTC
Awesome stuff mate, terrific progress. I really like the annotated weight graph.
Definitely +1 the yoga twice/week. I don't know if it has directly helped my lifts (maybe squat because of improved hip mobility) but its so good just for feeling good in your own body.
I also subscribe to the 'no rest days' approach and love it, but did you ever find that your other sessions impacted recovery? I know climbing is fantastic for the forearms and traps but fk I couldn't imagine doing deadlifts the morning after a climbing sesh!
Anyways good on ya, fantastic post.
Karate sometimes involves some REALLY gnarly slow kick workouts where you basically stand there one leg while slowly extending it out and back multiple times. Squats and those workouts did NOT mix.
My main issues have been when W3 of a 531 lines up with other activities getting intense. Other weeks it'll be fine but I'll be fucked up when those collide.
Usually when it gets BAD I let accessories auto regulate and do much lighter weight or less intense exercises to compensate.