Make it make sense...pleaae

I ordered something off of Amazon a few months back and opened a card through chase. It gave me a pretty decent discount on that purchase and let me keep that amount for at least another 30 days. I shifted the money I would have spent from my checking to my savings and paid the first bill 100%.

Next few times I ordered from Amazon I used the card, thinking I was using my bank account. Racked up a bill and since I opted for ebills (those got sent to spam) didn't realize I had a past due balance....

Skip to a few days ago, realize I have a balance, paid it in full and now my credit goes down 121 points for "decreased credit utilization"

It didn't negatively impact my credit when i was late (by much +/- one or two points) but paying in full messes it up!?.

I know in the long run it will correct itself but to me that's just stupid!? Shouldn't I be rewarded for NOT being in debt to someone?

Thank you for letting me rant.

Posted Jul 17, 2023, 7:52 AM UTC

113
Shmup-em-up•

Late payments have major effects on your score, such as 121 point drop. It doesn’t just lower it by one or two points.

1
VideoComprehensive99OP•

Okay, so even though credit karma listed the reason as "decreased utilization" It was most likely the late balance.

1
Shmup-em-up•

It absolutely was the late payment.

Payment history is the largest chunk of your score at 35%. You will lose some points for high utilization, but since utilization has no memory, it will bounce right back after paying it off.

There is a slight penalty if you have a 0% utilization, but it is nowhere near 121 point penalty.

1
VideoComprehensive99OP•

Thanks for helping me out! I'm nowhere near needing my credit for some large purchase I just have a goal of getting excellent credit and it frustrates me when I get a ding like that!

Oh well, I'll take the L and go on from here! Lol

1
Shmup-em-up•

It may be worth it to send in a goodwill letter asking for them to remove the late payment. Worst that could happen is they say no.

1
madskilzz3•

Okay, so even though credit karma listed the reason as "decreased utilization" It was most likely the late balance.

Ignore VantageScore from the likes of Credit Karma/Wise/Sesame, as it’s irrelevant. Majority of lenders (~90%) lean towards and uses FICO scores for their lending decisions.

Track FICO using- Experian (free version), myFICO (free version, Equifax), and Discover (TransUnion) if you’re a cardholder.

1
VideoComprehensive99OP•

Awesome I do have Experian on my phone as well. Normally, I try to check my score every 90 days and I put it in my phone calendar what credit karma says (Transunion and Equifax) and then Experian.

Lmao I mark TU&E as green and Experian as Purple in my phone.

I try not to check more than every 90 days because I heard that can hurt your score

1
lestermagneto:gs::usa::c1::ct::nvy:•

I try not to check more than every 90 days because I heard that can hurt your score

You can check it every 5 minutes on Experian or MyFico.com(free account) etc and it won't hurt your scores at all, as those are the results of soft pulls, not hard pulls.

1
BrutalBodyShotsKnowledgeable•

That's one of the biggest credit myths going. Checking your own reports/scores will NEVER hurt them.

1
BrutalBodyShotsKnowledgeable•

Credit Karma doesn't list reasons for SCORE changes. No CMS does. You are looking at the "see what's changed" which like any CMS alert system is only telling you about changes to your report. It's common for people to think that this means it's the reason their score changed, but it doesn't have to be.

1

DO NOT USE CK, it's a marketing site that provides a Vantage score. Open no fee accounts at Experian and Equifax, myFICO.

1
VideoComprehensive99OP•

Thanks! :)

1