Where does Jimmy Butler rank all-time?
Bill Simmons did a nice segment on this recently, and I don’t exactly know what the answer is. But, Jimmy seems to have one of the strangest resumés of a clear #1 on two title contenders. Working from the pyramid (as legit a list as any) we have:
80-100: Shawn Kemp, Kevin Johnson, Connie Hawkins, Chris Mullen, etc
60-80: Artis Gilmore, Reggie Miller, Chris Webber, Rodman, etc
40-60: Gary Payton, Clyde Drexler, Dominique, etc
I don’t think he’s ever been as good as the guys in the 40-60 range. But is Jimmy a HOF player? Seems so. Strange stats for a HOF player. But I think he’s a lock now.
Posted Jul 18, 2023, 4:29 PM UTC
If that’s the scale, he’s in the 40-60 range.
He was good enough to be the lead dog on two finals teams, but neither of those teams had a snowball’s chance in hell of actually winning a chip.
It's be a cold day in hell that I'd take Jimmy Butler over prime Chris Webber. If Webber is 60-80 I don't think Jimmy could possibly be any better than 60
Longevity matters
Edit: I made this comment then went to bball reference. Their primes are a similar length. If JB does this for a few more years then my comment stands. As it is right now though, I was wrong. My b.
I agree, Jimmy better continue to play another 3 full seasons to be in this conversation!
Well it's not like Webber flamed out.
He was 2nd team all NBA when he was 30 when the forwards at the time were Duncan, KG, and Dirk.
Webber would have a ring and finals mvp too if the NBA didn't pay off those refs against the Lakers
No shot. You're outright stating that he had more value as the greatest rebounder of all time, Dennis Rodman. He's top 60-75 at best right now.
How is Jimmy not better than Dennis Rodman wtf...if Dennis Rodman was ever the best player on a team they'd be bottom of the league, I don't understand this take at all.
we woulda won in 2020 if bam and goran werent injured
Doubt. That lakers squad was a buzz saw, and AD was playing out of his mind.