Where does Jimmy Butler rank all-time?

Bill Simmons did a nice segment on this recently, and I don’t exactly know what the answer is. But, Jimmy seems to have one of the strangest resumés of a clear #1 on two title contenders. Working from the pyramid (as legit a list as any) we have:

80-100: Shawn Kemp, Kevin Johnson, Connie Hawkins, Chris Mullen, etc

60-80: Artis Gilmore, Reggie Miller, Chris Webber, Rodman, etc

40-60: Gary Payton, Clyde Drexler, Dominique, etc

I don’t think he’s ever been as good as the guys in the 40-60 range. But is Jimmy a HOF player? Seems so. Strange stats for a HOF player. But I think he’s a lock now.

Posted Jul 18, 2023, 4:29 PM UTC

310
Bunny_Whaler•

If that’s the scale, he’s in the 40-60 range.

He was good enough to be the lead dog on two finals teams, but neither of those teams had a snowball’s chance in hell of actually winning a chip.

1
ChrisSwish•

It's be a cold day in hell that I'd take Jimmy Butler over prime Chris Webber. If Webber is 60-80 I don't think Jimmy could possibly be any better than 60

1

Longevity matters

Edit: I made this comment then went to bball reference. Their primes are a similar length. If JB does this for a few more years then my comment stands. As it is right now though, I was wrong. My b.

1
Lets_Go_Blue__Jays•

I agree, Jimmy better continue to play another 3 full seasons to be in this conversation!

1
ChosenDonu•

Well it's not like Webber flamed out.

He was 2nd team all NBA when he was 30 when the forwards at the time were Duncan, KG, and Dirk.

Webber would have a ring and finals mvp too if the NBA didn't pay off those refs against the Lakers

1
whostheme•

No shot. You're outright stating that he had more value as the greatest rebounder of all time, Dennis Rodman. He's top 60-75 at best right now.

1
kit4•

How is Jimmy not better than Dennis Rodman wtf...if Dennis Rodman was ever the best player on a team they'd be bottom of the league, I don't understand this take at all.

1
Skinnecott•

we woulda won in 2020 if bam and goran werent injured

1
Bunny_Whaler•

Doubt. That lakers squad was a buzz saw, and AD was playing out of his mind.

1
Delanorix•

Hes top 50, but closer to 50 than say, 30.

He started from the bottom and worked his way up to an alpha thaylt brought two under talented teams to the Finals.

Bam is a great Robin, and arguably more talented, but Jimmy is the Batman.

Jimmy is so good in the playoffs. Hes like Eli Manning. Bright lights just dont faze him.

I think he could end up Top 30 with another few years of elite play and/or a title with him as the best player.

1
MR___SLAVE•

Hes top 50

No, he's not even top 70. He didn't even make the 75th anniversary team. Maybe he gets a bit of a bump up into it after last season, but he was outside and if he's now in that top 75 he is right on the margin in the 70-75 range.

There is very, very low chance he gets into the top 30. Scottie Pippin is right around 30. Has Jimmy ever been better than Pippin?

1
kriogenia•

Has Jimmy ever been better than Pippin?

He never conquered Isengard but he is probably better at basketball

1
MR___SLAVE•

Ok you win. I will take Jimmy over a hobbit.

1
reelieuglie•

Honestly, Pippin conquered Isengard being carried by Treebeard.

If it wasn't for Treebeard being a top 5 Ent and really running the team, Pippin would be just another hobbit.

1
Delanorix•

Pippin didn't win a title as the best player, so I think that is held against him, probably unfairly.

Pippens game and Jimmy's aren't really that different, especially since Jimmy hurt his wrist and struggles with a 3pt shot.

1
MR___SLAVE•

In fairness, IMO the gap between Jimmy and Bam is very narrow.

1
richochet12•

The 75 team has an old school bias tbf

1
ChelseaDagger14•

Is Bam a great Robin? He’s absolutely not more talented.

He can’t be relied on at all to be a second option to get buckets in the way that Murray, Brown, whichever of Bron/AD you considered better in the bubble. The run in 2022 was just Jimmy and other dudes on offence.

1
ImExtremelyErect•

Bro there's a whole other side of the court. Acting like bam is some bum because he doesn't score at a high clip is silly.

Bam anchors that Miami defense and let's them play all sorts of different schemes thanks to his versatility.

1
hurricanesznsover•

He’s top 100. Top 50 is kind of ridiculous. He’ll likely end up in the 65-75 range when he’s retired.

1
nbadiscussion-ModTeamMOD•

One-line opinions will be removed. Support your opinion with stats, facts, and well-reasoned arguments.

1
whostheme•

Top 60-75ish range I would say. Anything lower than that would be too generous at this current point in time. No way he places above Rodman or Webber.

1
Primetime22•

I have him within the same range but I'd also put him on the higher end. I think he was the best player in the Eastern Conference 3 of the last 4 playoffs, that's a consistency that should matter when you're up against Giannis, Embiid, KD, and Tatum all of these years.

I personally would put him above Webber, not Rodman.

1
nbadiscussion-ModTeamMOD•

One-line opinions will be removed. Support your opinion with stats, facts, and well-reasoned arguments.

1
MSKOnlyScans•

FWIW, Bill Simmons said recently on a podcast that he officially but Jimmy Butler in his Hall of Fame Pyramid. Where exactly in that pyramid I’m not sure, but that’s probably the top 50 or so range.

1
whostheme•

HoF has 400 inductees... Simmons probably didn't mean he's automatically in the top 50. That's a lot of layers in the pyramid.

1
MSKOnlyScans•

His own pyramid is different than the actual HOF.

1
whostheme•

Did he ever elaborate on what his pyramid actually is?

1
MSKOnlyScans•

I think this is the original article which he then expanded upon in his book http://www.espn.com/espn/page2/story?page=simmons/020108

This is somewhat current it looks like https://aminoapps.com/c/nba/page/item/bill-simmons-updated-pyramid/wKgr_EQQspIB7mMlg0jGqBDozEwXqNlbl5V

1
snakejakemonkey•

Finals appearances being such an accomplishment is flawed.

Like Hardens rockets way better than these Heat teams, but they played the KD Warriors in rd2. East always way worse.

Butler gets seen as some playoff warrior and Harden as a choker

1
Exoduss123•

Thats why NBA introduced these participation trophies for Conference Finals MVP to add legacy points to players who didnt achieve shit, now since Lebron era losing in the finals is apparently to be celebrated 😅

1
Valedictorian117•

Hey at least the two Western Conference Finals MVP’s have been well deserved so far. Curry and Jokic both went on to be champions and Finals MVPs the same year they got the WCF MVP trophy.

1
nbadiscussion-ModTeamMOD•

Please keep your comments civil. This is a subreddit for discussion and debate, not aggressive and condescending content.

1
Koduhh_•

Harden is literally a choker tho, his stats get worse in the playoffs

1
nbadiscussion-ModTeamMOD•

One-line opinions will be removed. Support your opinion with stats, facts, and well-reasoned arguments.

1
Neltrix•

Getting past the same roster that got Giannis a ring and these stacked Celtics teams is no easy feat either

1
2023foresthisdrive•

its not an “accomplishment” but should speak to the overall talent/career of the player.

Harden generally gets worse in the playoffs while that’s literally the opposite of the reputation Jimmy has

And you’re acting like the Heat just sleepwalked through an easy conference to get to the finals as if the Bucks and Celtics aren’t in the top 5 teams in the league

1
nbadiscussion-ModTeamMOD•

Don't just say what you think but why you think it. Support your opinion with stats, facts, and/or well-reasoned arguments and it can be reinstated.

1
snakejakemonkey•

Lol why did mods remove the replies to my comment? U guys make this sub unusable

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Gladhands•

Jimmy Butler is the greatest player of all time who isn’t one of the greatest players of all time. He’s very good at most aspects of the game, but isn’t really elite at anything other than having a sense of the moment. He’s probably on the bottom of whatever tier Paul Pierce is on.

1
grantforthree•

Pierce and Jimmy are by no means in the same tier

3
seasoned-veteran•

Guys without rings don't get to be in the same tier as FMVPs.

1
One-Fish2178•

There are plenty of guys without rings who are on the same tier/ahead of FMVPs so this is not true lol…

1
Gladhands•

Not to mention the fact that finals MVP is one of the most arbitrary awards. 11 voters get five minutes to vote. You could quite easily and reasonably give that award to KG.

1
One-Fish2178•

Exactly. Finals MVP used to just be viewed as like a prize after winning, I think that recently its significance has been overstated to “prove” that a player was better or worse than they actually were. There are many examples of questionable FMVPs- ie. Magic Johnson 1980, iggy in 2015. I also think there is an argument AD could’ve won in 2020 over lebron & Tim Duncan could’ve won over tony Parker in 2007, but I’m not particularly “upset” about either of those. Tired of people using awards like this as a claim to someone being greater or worse than someone else bc the truth of the matter is the judges have messed it up multiple times & having a great finals series doesn’t automatically make u better than someone who was a better player than you. Does anyone say Paul Pierce is better than Barkley??? No.

1
ish_baid19000•

You’re right Iguodala and Jojo White are better than Barkley and Malone

1
7059043•

Yeah PP is at the bottom of the next tier up IMO

1
Gladhands•

That’s reasonable as well. The end result being the same: There is essentially a full tier between them

1
ElegantEpitome•

Since when is getting a Finals MVP a prerequisite for being a great player? Since when is a ring a prerequisite to be an all time great? Because they’re not lmao

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
MonomonTheTeacher•

Feels a little strange to say now when he’s one of the big names in the league, but I think he’s more of a folk hero than an all-timer. It’s great and memorable watching him turn it up for the playoffs, but he’s pretty short on career accomplishments.

I guess some of that is a personal ranking philosophy though. Maybe I’m operating like college football and only ranking the top 25ish. At least right now, Butler is probably below any meaningful breakpoint.

1
inezco•

Well to be fair to Jimmy he's already a 6 time All-Star and 5 time All-NBA which is nothing to scoff at. Many players are in the Hall of Fame with less. And 2 Finals appearances no matter how weak the East is is also impressive. Among his peers Giannis and Tatum have one Finals appearance each (of course getting the actual ring counts way more).

1
razr12•

All stars should not count. All nba definitely

1
MonomonTheTeacher•

Absolutely, Butler has had an excellent career. For context though, 117 players have received 6 or more All-Star nods and 81 have received 5 or more All-NBA. That along with his memorable playoff performances makes for an incredible career, but not so exceptional that I think he has an obvious ranking. But to your point, those are real accomplishments and he’s still active so he could make a more compelling case before retirement.

A couple fun comparisons I came across are Joe Dumars and Blake Griffin. All 3 players have very similar career stats and awards, except for playoff success. Dumars is kind of Butler’s what-if for if he had managed to steal championships out from under the Lakers and Nuggets. Griffin and Butler have had fairly similar careers so far, though obviously they will separate more and more as Griffin has a reduced role and never had much playoff success.

1
lexicoterio•

I would throw a name that may fit your bill as a comparison for Jimmy's career: Reggie Miller. I'm not comparing them skill-wise, just purely on their career success. He's had playoff success, multiple-time all-star but someone who just can't get over the superstars of his time.

1
O_J_Shrimpson•

Yeah - Lamarcus Aldridge is another one. Absolutely love him and had an amazing career, But no one’s really tossing him around in all time convos

1
FYININJA•

eh, I think Reggie Miller at least has the honor of at one point holding an all time record (for 3P made). While the value of that has diminished with him being passed up, it's still not insignificant, holding a record upon retiring is a pretty big deal.

1
ILikeAllThings•

I don't think think measures up against Miller yet, in terms of his opponents(Miller has an argument he played constantly against all time greats) and in terms of longevity. Miller played 1389 of 1444 total regular season games, 30 that he missed at 37 or older. 144 playoff games as well. Also, FG add and TS add he crushed the league almost every year and was never close to be a below league average shooter. He's in that circle of shooter like Dirk, Curry, Durant, Jokic, and Allen. Solid defender for me, just not flashy.

1
LavenderAutist•

And truth be told, Jimmy isn't the guy pandering to get awards or play nice to get things. He just wants to win and pushes to do that. Even when it pisses off management or other teammates or things like that. He is even willing to reduce his stats to win. And when the team needs him he'll go all out to do what he can to get the win; even score at will.

So those 6 time all star appearances is even better when you think of him in those terms.

1
hankbaumbach•

Everything you are saying is very Clyde Drexler pre-Houston.

If Jimmy is able to get a chip I think he has just as good a case as Clyde for rankings.

Player A 10x All Star, 1x All NBA 1st Team, 2x All NBA 2nd Team, 2x All NBA 3rd Team, 20.4 ppg, 6.1 trb, 5.6 ast on 47.2/31.8/78.8 splits with PER 21.1 and WS 135.6

Player B 6x NBA All Star, 1x All NBA 2nd Team, 4x All NBA 3rd Team, 5x NBA All Defense 2nd Team, NBA Steals leader (2021), NBA Most Improved (2015), NBA Eastern Conference Finals MVP, 18.2 ppg, 5.3 trb, 4.2 ast 46.7/32.3/84.2 splits with PER 21.6, WS 105.9

Career stats used

1
Jwoods4117•

Jimmy is like Eli Manning if Eli had lost to both of those Pats teams he was supposed to lose to. Borderline HOF regular season stats with these random even greater postseasons and postseason performances.

1
GuidanceLast4605•

This is a great question for revealing "what do you value?" Is it regular season hardware (All-NBA, MVPs, etc.)? Is it regular season success (#1 seeds, etc.)? Is it consistency? Longevity? Numbers? Playoff success?

I have Jimmy way higher than most of the people commenting, because what I value more than anything is being "the guy." Can you get a bucket in the highest leverage, championship situations, when the chips are down? Can you elevate your team in the playoffs? Do you get better in the playoffs?

For me, what Jimmy has done in taking two very undermanned teams to the Finals is way underrated. Think about all the great players who were never really on great teams or on much better teams and never managed it--Wilkins, Harden, Nash, Gervin. Then there are the guys who only made it as a second banana--Kidd, Pippen, Drexler. Even Barkely and Durant were only able to do it with much, much better teams that Jimmy did.

I'm not saying that Jimmy is better than all of these guys, but I watched him go toe-to-toe with Lebron on the biggest stage and not look outclassed. The number of players in NBA history who could do that is very small. He's as tough a motherfucker as you could ask for and for a game or a series or a playoff run, he would be very, very high on my list.

1
vfronda•

All of that analysis is too dependent on a host of other things to go right or wrong.

Is Jimmy a better baller than X player. In most of these comps, no.

1
Trapivist•

Ok so is KD in your top 10?

1
Rezsguy•

This pretty much sums up my thoughts. I’m much less experienced than a lot with the NBA but in any sport/competitive atmosphere I’ve always valued someone being “that guy” more than theoretical skill or talent. Attitude, commitment, and competitive drive is intangibles that get memed to death online nowadays but it is important factors in how valuable someone is to a team winning.

Jimmy Butler clearly loves basketball, his team, his coaches, and wants to win with them. Is he as skilled or has the peak talent like some others in the league or all time greats? No, but he’s far from a bum and has the spirit to elevate people around him given the right environment.

Like someone else mentioned I think he will end up being viewed as a folk hero more than an all timer. Weather that’s fair or not I don’t care. He will be remembered for a long time and honestly being a folk hero is almost cooler than highly ranked.

1
Rezsguy•

This pretty much sums up my thoughts. I’m much less experienced than a lot with the NBA but in any sport/competitive atmosphere I’ve always valued someone being “that guy” more than theoretical skill or talent. Attitude, commitment, and competitive drive is intangibles that get memed to death online nowadays but it is important factors in how valuable someone is to a team winning.

Jimmy Butler clearly loves basketball, his team, his coaches, and wants to win with them. Is he as skilled or has the peak talent like some others in the league or all time greats? No, but he’s far from a bum and has the spirit to elevate people around him given the right environment.

Like someone else mentioned I think he will end up being viewed as a folk hero more than an all timer. Weather that’s fair or not I don’t care. He will be remembered for a long time and honestly being a folk hero is almost cooler than highly ranked.

1
nathanlanza•

I agree here. I think we overvalue actually winning the championship for rankings. Jimmy was the second most dominant player in the playoffs. The #1 is a guy all but locked to be a top 10 all time player. Last year Jimmy was consensus top 2 as well. Again, the one who prevailed (Curry) is a consensus top 10 all time. 2020, same story.

Jimmy is a three time #2-in-the-playoffs-only-to-be-bested-by-all-time-greats. Clearly this means he's not a top 15 guy as he couldn't get by. But then beyond 15 I think that is a pretty damn rare accomplishment.

This is kind of a nit-picky argument. But when you're past the top 15 where the arguments are homeruns you have to get to nit-pickiness.

1
lemination•

IMO Devin Booker looked like the #2 player this playoffs

1
azmanz•

The heat were significantly better with Jimmy off the floor this playoffs (14 points better per 100). That just doesn’t happen with all time greats.

They Heat got this far this year because the role players forgot they were role players. He’s getting way too much credit for this run.

1
n0t_4_thr0w4w4y•

Jimmy Butler ain’t the guy. Didn’t score more than 30 points after game 1 of the ECF. Thats 11 straight playoff games. Only had 4 double doubles in 22 playoff games during this run and didn’t have a single triple double

1
BitchImLilBaby•

He’s closer to 100 than to 50. Doesn’t peak that high as a player compared to a lot of guys above or around him and wasn’t that great his first couple seasons in the league. When he retires he’ll probably be top 60-ish if he puts together one more good run? As of rn there’s no way I’d put him over guys like Wilkins, Melo, Pierce, and I’d even say PG13 has had a better career so far.

1
druzandlogic•

How has he had a worse career than Melo, Wilkins or PG13?? Those guys have never even made a finals appearance. Melo and Wilkins have barely even made a conference finals! Jimmy brings up every team he's played for and just dragged a severely outclassed Miami team to the finals while beating some really quality teams with guys many people would have as better players than him (Giannis & tatum). I value what a guy does in the most intense and challenging moments and Jimmy has always shown up for those moments more so than many of the contemporary superstars. Those were some poor examples to compare him to bc none of those guys outside of Pierce (who needed the arrival of KG and Allen) have ever achieved anything in the postseason. He's maybe not as talented as those guys or have as many accolades but he's forced his mediocre teams into becoming contenders and has never looked like he cant go toe-to-toe with the greats.. the same can't be said about those other dudes despite their superior stats

1
Trapivist•

Paul George never won a ecf lol, how is that

1
stoonn123•

Kinda Reggie Miller I guess. Not the Payton or Drexler level, but better than rodmen

1
LiaM_CS•

He’ll probably be right next to Reggie Miller if he ends his career without a chip

They’ve had pretty similar careers/accomplishments

1
Autistic_Puppy•

Basketball Ball Reference's similarity scores imply that he might end up near Horace Grant, Jerry Lucas, and Larry Nance. So probably around ~60

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
VizualDread•

Top 100-150+, we have to look at the numbers and NBA History, I’m sure he falls around that range. He’s not better than those guys you just listed in all ranges.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
kit4•

I would put him in the 60-80 tier, probably around 65-70. Personally I don't think he should make the HoF unless he wins a ring and FMVP.

1
JacoIII•

His best comp is Reggie Miller, a dude who played very well in the regular season, but was an absolute terror in the playoffs. Reggie also never got any hardware despite playing elite basketball well into the postseason on many occasions. Reggie also made all-star and all-NBA appearances without ever reaching MVP status.

The question is if Butler will have Reggie's longevity, which seems unlikely because off-ball shooting tends to age better than almost any other skillset.

1
domenic821•

Reggie is way higher than Jimmy all-time IMO. For me, a reasonable range for Reggie is 30-45ish, whereas Butler is roughly 60-75.

I don’t weigh accolades as heavy as most, so for me, both of these players are on the higher-end of those ranges. I just try to look at how much a player positively impacted his team’s chance of success regardless of the outcome.

I don’t think Butler is much lower in his all-time ranking than guys like Dame, Chauncey, Walton, etc.

1
richochet12•

How is Butler below Dame? Imo, Jimmy's got a better resume. His playoff success put him over.

1
swordfischh•

Yeah Jimmy’s easily been the superior player the last 10 years, and has the playoff success to prove it. People tend to forget that defence is as important as offence

1
domenic821•

If you’re weighing players’ résumés without contextualizing their situation (teammates, coaching, opponents, etc.), I just see that as a disingenuous argument.

1
carbine23•

Lol butler was literally on an 8th seed team are we forgetting that??

1
latelastnight•

I think if you actually start listing people out, you’d see Reggie being much higher than 30

1
domenic821•

I’ve made a top 75 list when the NBA released their anniversary team, and Reggie was 30 there. I’m really high on him, though I guess I was a bit unfair with his range, because it’s possible to be higher (although you’d have to weigh playoffs really heavily). He’s right around players like Kawhi, Pippen, and AD for me.

1
latelastnight•

See if think of him similarly to Ray Allen talent wise but without the playoff success and I don’t think I’d even have Ray in my top 50

1
tehLrod•

Why is Reggie much higher than Jimmy in your opinion?

1
domenic821•

As great as Jimmy is in the playoffs, Reggie is quite a bit greater. His scoring and efficiency numbers increased dramatically from the regular season; probably more so than any other player in history. He went from a solid 2nd option (ideally) in the RS to a clear-cut 1st option on a championship-caliber offense in the PS (27.2 IA PTS/75 on +9.7 rTS% from 00-02!).

Simply put, I think the value that Reggie adds to his team’s offense is greater than Butler’s cumulative two-way impact, especially in the postseason.

1
thatonezorofan•

I mean, that's cool and all but Reggie still doesn't have the hardware to justify putting him THAT much higher than Jimmy. He's a 5 time all star and 3 time all NBA player. Jimmy's career accolades wise is already better than Reggie's, that coupled with the fact that he has reached the finals TWICE while being the main dude on the team and going through some good competition his career looks way better than Reggie's.

1
mookz23•

Why is Reggie way higher than Jimmy? Here is a comparison. Jimmy has more All-Star game appearances (6 to 5), more All-NBA selections (5 to 3), more All-Defensive team selections (5 to 0), and Finals appearances (2 to 1).

1
Lewlewlewl•

I mean butler has Reggie beat in every single stat/accolade besides longevity and Jimmy is obviously still playing at a high level. Yes the scoring is higher now and what not but “way higher” is just silly.

1

I’m a big chauncy fan and think he’s often underrated but jimmy and dame are decisively better than him. I can’t really speak to Walton never saw him play.

1
j2e21•

Reggie was much better than Butler. Reggie is one of the guys who would have a title if not for Jordan.

1
Lewlewlewl•

Well all the stats and accolades kinda prove you wrong. There’s no universe where Reggie is “much better”.

1
carbine23•

In what way??? 3 point shooting?

1
joe1240132•

Butler's already passed Reggie in ASG and All-NBA teams despite playing a bunch less years and his first couple years being a fringe player. Advanced sttats like Jimmy a lot more too. Honestly I don't think there's much case you can make that they're similar-Jimmy's just a much better player.

1

I think the reggie comparison makes total sense, both dudes will be remembered for specific moments and turning it up in the playoffs. Both dudes will be regarded as above other players with similar stats accolades because of that. Do think Jimmy has a but better and can still further the gap with more playoff runs and all-star, all-nba’s. if Miami gets dame and jimmy can win a finals or even finals MvP that would be a huge legacy boost.

1