r/DnD•
Slashlight

[3.5] Overhauling the spell system

I like 3.5 a lot, but I have never really liked the spell system. Everything about it seems a bit too artificial. I'd like my players to be able to be a bit more creative when they cast spells. Basically, I want them to create the spells they need/want and not have a list of options to choose from. For a wizard or cleric, the spell list makes a bit more sense, but for a bard, druid, or sorcerer? A pre-defined list of stuff just doesn't do it for me. Each of those classes, to me, is supposed to feel and use magic on a more primal level, especially the sorcerer. So, because of this, I'd like a system that reflects that.

What I've been thinking thus far is something akin to warlock casting. A spellcaster, and this includes all of them, has this basic blob of magic he can chuck at an enemy. Unlike the warlock, it doesn't automatically get more awesome as you level. So, you have this flavorless ball of magic you toss around, similar to a simple weapon attack that a ranger or a fighter might have. The player adds the flavor, depending on the character, so that the ball of stuff might be a searing ball of light, a screaming white skull, or a ball of blue fire. Whatever he wants it to look like that might be RP related. In any case, from class to class, it's the same ball of stuff.

I'd like them to be able to do stuff with this ball. If a sorcerer wants to cast a fireball, he'd expend some resources to make it into a fiery AoE spell. If a cleric wants to toss some healing, he'd expend resources to do so. If a wizard wants to create the illusion of a screaming banshee, he pays the appropriate cost and has it happen. In any case, though, nobody looks at a pre-defined spell on their sheet. They have a variety of effects that they've learned to apply, but no specific spell to fall back on, unless they create it themselves.

Does anyone know of any system that does something similar or, at the very least, some advice on how to create one?

Posted Dec 20, 2012, 3:43 AM UTC

618
[deleted]•

So basically instead of a list of spells they'd learn a list of effects and have a mana pool instead of casting per day?

2
SlashlightOPDM•

Essentially, yeah. Of course there'd still be room for prefab spells, something that an NPC (or PC) wizard would put together, but I'd like to give casters a bit more freedom. Yeah, I know that wizards and the like are ridiculously op at higher levels, but I think that stems from the spell list, not the class itself.

2
[deleted]•

It's like a more versatile version of the psion. May or may not be more broken depending on how you approach the effects and it's limitations. Spontaneous casting is huge.

1
SlashlightOPDM•

It's really the spells themselves that bug me. Apart from, say, Conjuration, Illusion, and Transmutation, the spells really just seem to be 'throw bigger ball of death'. With a few schools of spells, especially Illusion, you need a certain level of creativity to defeat a foe. High level spells are just ludicrously overpowered, too.

2
[deleted]•

Well, the only spells that does 'bigger ball of death' is evocation.

Conjuration, Illusion and transmutation as you've mentioned are generally situational spells or battlefield control type spells.

Necromancy is split between debuffing, damage and summoning/control. Where the damage aspect could be construed as 'balls of death'. but most of the de-buffs don't actually do damage.

Enchantment is almost totally devoid of damage dealing spells (of any sort, HP or ability).

Divination similarly has no damage dealing spells OR any type of classic 'combat wizardry'.

I'd say in terms of flavour, the D&D spellset has some of the best balanced and varied spell list. It's the power and versatility of some of these spells that makes them problematic.

The one problem I foresee with your system is that you either severely limit the spell effects available to casters OR you limit how they can combine them OR you limit it's power.

The first is totally undesirable in most circumstances because it essentially neuters the wizard and turns it into another flavoured warlock.

The second is also undesirable in the sense that the whole point of this new system is so that PCs can come up with innovative and organic ways to create/fashion spells.

The last is probably the most reasonable way to go: reducing the duration, damage/effects and area of spells is probably the best way to nerf a mage without dismantling the feel of magic. Unfortunately, this has to be very carefully controlled as if you do it too much then mages doesn't scale with their counterparts (and you get the bard syndrome, where you have lots of interesting abilities... but all of them are relatively weak and the overall package is underpowered.).

2
grobolom•

The Vancian casting system actually handles this kinda well. Basically, you're giving everyone the equivalent of the Acid Splatter reserve feat for free. Just reflavor spell slots as being the cost you have to pay to convert that attack to a specific spell. Everything else is as normal.

2
SlashlightOPDM•

This is a solution that I hadn't thought of at all. I was thinking of dissecting spells into their various effects and figuring out how to hand those out to the various caster classes as they level, but this...makes things a bit easier.

2
QuillonDM•

You could look at how spell creation at epic levels are handled in the Epic Level Handbook for 3.0, and modify that for lower levels as well. Basically you have seeds for different magical effects, and then the spellcaster can modify these seeds or mix them to create various spells. Your imagination is the only limit really.

2
SlashlightOPDM•

I'll have to look into that. I have a couple of weeks to get the campaign stuff together, so I have some time to refine this shit. I might be on here quite a bit fishing for ideas.

*Edit: Holy shit, this was just about perfect. I think I'll remove the Spellcraft check, replace it with a caster level check, and adjust the mechanics for each class to still give them a sense of belonging. After a change like this, a sorcerer and a psion are practically identical unless you give them unique mechanics.

3
AquorBard•

Ah ha! I know exactly what you need. Look up "Words of Power." In short, it's a set of variant rules for the Pathfinder magic system that lets people create spells on the fly, rather then rellying on "Premade" spells. It's a rather complex subsystem at first glance, but if you look into it, it's rather interesting.

Basicaly, rather then learning "Spells" on levelup/from scrolls, casters learn "Words" witch come in three types: "Target" Words control if the spell is going to be an AOE, a Line, a Cone, Self-only, etc. "Effect" words, are what tell you what a spell does....will the spell deal Acid Damage, heal the target, or make them save vs Blindness? Finally, you have "Meta" words, witch kinda work like Metamagic-feats, but work on a x/per day system, rather then increaceing the level of the spell.

In addtion, you can combine lower level effects into higher level ones, via the use of a high level spell-slot.

Example: I am a Cleric, and all of my allys are taking damage, and had just been the target of a Dispell Magic.. removing my beneficial spells. I could cast Burst Lesser Cure Alignment Shield, witch whould 1. heal everyone in the burst 1d6+1 per level, and give them +2 AC and saves vs an alinement of my choice. This spell would cost me one of my second level spell slots.

You'll also notice that my Lesser Cure only healed 1d6, as opposed to the 1d8 of a Cure Light. This is because magic is given an overall bump-down in power, witch is the price to pay for flexabailty.

Tl:DR: Make "custom spells" on the fly, rather then relying on what amounts to "Premade spells" out of books.

http://paizo.com/pathfinderRPG/prd/ultimateMagic/ultimateMagicWordsOfPower.html Is the original site, but it looks down at the moment.

2
SlashlightOPDM•

That's pretty similar to what I have in mind. I'm glad that there is plenty of other material to pull from. Going into this alone would have sucked.

1
RandomParable•

Now I'm going to mention the fun part. You need to make sure all the other classes are balanced against this :) Personally I would try to set up something like the Tome of Battle maneuvers for classes, but with a bit of flavor for each different class.

1
SlashlightOPDM•

That isn't a bad plan, really. Bake in some of those maneuvers for the martial classes so that they get a few toys, too. It'd probably end up being similar to the bonus feats a fighter gets, but tied directly to a selection of maneuvers from specific schools. That'll come later, though...

2
ElSatanno•

Have you looked into GURPS magic? I played a smidge back in the day and I recall there being a sizable section devoted to building spells.

In my hazy recollection, I think you built spells like a sentence: You have a subject (caster), verb (fly/transmute/etc), object (enemy/area/etc), and adjectives (elements/effects). Then you determine how much energy is required based on complexity of the spell, scale, resistances and other relevant variables.

Obviously this is just barebones, but I thought it a clean approach to a universal spell creation system.

1
SlashlightOPDM•

I'll have to look at that as well. I'll probably be using some sort of patchwork system after looking at all of these other systems. I'll be sure to toss it up here for critique once I'm satisfied that it's ready.

2
Fedykin•

I am running a campaign for a group of friends currently, and as we have gone along I have been toying with a couple homebrew rules. Among them, I was tackling much the same problem with the spell system. I came up with what I call "up-casting", which does sorta function in the same manner as psionic augmenting. Essentially, the caster can take a spell he knows, and by expending a higher spell slot (dependent on the desired effect), he/she can cast the spell with a different effect. I say different because I am trying to keep it rather broad and up to the interpretation of the player. My restrictions are simply that you cannot up-cast a spell to do things like more damage, longer duration, etc...there are already feats for that. They must modify the spell to have another use, that still adheres to the spirit of the spell. It is still all very convoluted, I imagine I will force the player to make some kind of spellcraft check to use a spell in this manner, but I have yet to work out the numbers fully as it has only been utilized once or twice.

Here is an example if my rambling has not been altogether coherent:

My players encountered a herd of wild bison, and the dragon shaman got off an extremely lucky one shot kill (double 20s), leaving them with several hundred pounds of meat that could feed them all for weeks. But they did not have the time to spend to properly preserve the food for the road. So...the sorceress decides she knows Ray of Frost, and chooses to up-cast it to a 2nd level spell slot in order to flash freeze the meat.

The point is really to get them to think outside the box, because there are going to be any number of instances in which a DD style caster is going to find their magic less than useful if they have loaded down their spell list with offensive spells, and there should be a creative outlet for them to expend their magical energy. I dig on your idea as well, seemingly a little more polish is necessary but you are pretty close. It sounds similar to something like Whitewolf's: Mage, where if you can make a check based off your general magical aptitude in a given area in order to create whatever effect you desire (within reason).

1
SlashlightOPDM•

It's a very rough idea at the moment. I still have some time to refine it before the campaign actually begins, but it'll be a photo finish, I think.

2