Ah, Madame Guillaumette, I see you have chosen death

Screenshot
Ah, Madame Guillaumette, I see you have chosen death

Posted Jul 22, 2023, 1:16 AM UTC

1.3K56
SmocksTOP•

R5: I won a holy war for a neighboring kingdom and inherited all these vassals with guaranteed council rights, which I don't believe should be a thing. In my humble opinion, feudal contracts should reset to the default when they become part of a completely different realm that doesn't share a culture, religion, or dynasty with the previous liege. I'm not required to honor agreements you made with a completely different king.

This moment is to me the most enraging thing that can happen in this game. I'm generally pretty forgiving but if you make yourself my councillor and you are neither a powerful vassal nor the most skilled candidate for any position, I will hunt you and everyone you love down to the ends of the earth and extinguish your bloodline forever.

1
Admiral_Franz_HipperErudite•

Gotta love winning a holy war or kingdom invasion and then having all your good stat councilors replaced by 1 digit stat nobodies. What is even more annoying is that sometimes you can't even modify their contracts to take it off.

1
Taurusbull13Immortal•

I love having the infinite contract changer since I love to get max money with no levies

1
SmocksTOP•

Pluralism is so frustrating. Like I understand what they're going for and why, but I think in the case of inheriting another liege's bad deals it's just stupid. I'm not sure why it feels so off or what the best "fix" would be, but a weak hook or this contract superseding any level of dread and/or difference in military size is probably the most jarring.

I have half a million troops and just conquered the entirety of Africa north of the Sahara in a decade, but your old boss, a "king" with 4 counties and a sum development of 30 between them all promised you could be his steward so you're going to make yourself mine? When I tell you no, and that you're going to jail, you're going to *rebel against my legion with your 350 troops in your county?* Give me a break game. My harem's guards have more military power. Why do I have to stop my world conquest to deal with this entitled jackass with no apparent fear of the certain death he's going to receive like the previous 10 counts that made themselves councilors?

1
never_any_cyan•

I feel like a simple fix would just be like "reset vassal contract to default when you inherit a vassal via pluralist holy war"

1
SmocksTOP•

Yeah. If you are a hereditary heir that inherits the kingdom and one of your dukes explains he's staying on the council because it was a promise to his house from your father, I get it. People would understandably be uneasy about you revoking that and imprisoning that guy.

This isn't like that at all. A completely different realm, with different customs and a different language, just conquered your lands and burned your old liege at the stake in the name of their gods. You should feel terrified by default and lucky go be alive, not prance on in to the imperial court like you own the place.

Worse yet my loyal cousins and nephews who helped me win that war should not call me a tyrant when I imprison this upstart. It's genuinely ridiculous.

1
k1275Chakravarti•

Then why are you wasting your time on pluralism? There is only one correct faith, and it's the one you made up for your maximal benefit. Everyone must either a) accept you are the living God and everything you see belongs to you or b) get bent. Letting them stick to their own field of superstition is counterproductive.

1
SmocksTOP•

There's only 3 options and I don't think Pluralism needs to include honoring all contracts of vassals made with prior lieges or it's wrong. This still happens if you declare war based on hereditary or personal claims too if I'm not mistaken. The religious aspect isn't even the main thing that feels off. It's that a count or duke just told the emperor of the known world who just took over that they are now one of their top four advisors, and won't take no for an answer. How does that scene make sense in your imagination?

1
wang-bang•

Pass the vassal to someone else?

1

What is even more annoying is that sometimes you can't even modify their contracts to take it off.

You can. Just take the tyranny. Anyone that has a problem with it will soon learn the error of their ways. :)

1
RobGrey03•

Not if their contract was already modified within their lifetime you can't.

1

I pretty much always play pluralist and have never run into that for a vassal I just conquered. You sure?

1
miserableSnail•

Intrigue focus and make hook scheme. Then change the contract.

1

Especially when it's a holy war... like most of these vassals are filthy heretics. I'd have burned them at the stake and landed a load of lowborn knights if given the chance.

1
Admiral_Franz_HipperErudite•

I wouldn't have cared much about them if they didn't force their way in to the council, but they did and now they are speedrunning in losing their heads.

1
PianoMindless704•

You conquered a new kingdom and have to rely on local rulers to be able to rule it. Seems legit to me. Conquest often leave the local administration intact, so a conqueror honoring contracts made with the last king seems not that far fatched

1
capitaine_zgeg•

William the Conqueror enters the chat

1
PianoMindless704•

Alexander the Great: Come on, dude, you have worlds left to conquer.

1
Fisher9001•

a conqueror honoring contracts made with the last king seems not that far fatched

What is far fetched is said conqueror not being able to choose not to honor that contract. Feudal contracts were dynastic in nature, with vassals making oaths to their liege and his heirs, not "anyone who replaces them in any capacity".

1
PianoMindless704•

The thing is that the game needs layers of government: If it was just: "My family has been stewards of France for centuries" the conquerer will probably just say: "Ok, do your thing". But you can't just be the steward of the one kingdom, you'll be for the whole realm. Easy solution: forming an empire and having vassal kingdoms (are vice kings a thing? Haven't played in a while tbh, if yes the struggle between them and their vassals is great roleplay potential for the conflict of local elites vs central rule)

1
Fisher9001•

The thing is, players should be able to decide and then face the consequences of such decisions, for example powerful offended vassals.

Taking away choices from players, especially by simply disabling the button, outright ruins immersion.

Guaranteed positions should be revocable at a heavy penalty, not simply impossible at all.

1
Big_Lexapro•

I honestly don't think "local rulers" would include higher nobles that likely just participated in the war against you. The idea that populations desire a degree of "self-rule" is already modeled in the Wrong-Culture and Wrong-Religion maluses, and historically speaking, I believe enforcing collaboration was relatively normal for conquering armies.

1

Another annoying thing is that when you change their contact afterwards, to remove council right. you still can’t fire them!

1
SmocksTOP•

Yeah. To do that you have to forcibly remove them, and if you try to imprison them they will rebel, along with virtually every other new vassal you just defeated mere days ago. You basically have to fight the same war twice.

1

There should be decisions that allows you to either honor the former obligations which gives you a bonus to relations or to distegard which gives a penalty.

1
Gears_Of_NoneOld Monster•

This is one of the most frustrating things in the game for me.

1
Taurusbull13Immortal•

They why i use the extended Council mod so I can just keep empty spots to put them in if needed

1
useless_debian_userDepressed•

keep empty spots to put them in if needed

you don't need a mod for that

jail has plenty of empty spots

undercook, overcook, jail

we have the best council in the world, because of jail

1
samlind3•

i’ve been using this for my recent HRE playthrough but i feel like it makes the game really unbalanced in the player’s favor

1
SvodolaDarkfury•

More like Emira GonnaGetTheGuillotine amirite?

1
MiciusPorciusCraven•

My updoot is yours

1
cyansola•

Guillaumette, meet Guillotine

1
MiciusPorciusCraven•

Best of luck trying to ex out your spymaster. Never works well for me

1
Mr_Plumrich•

Imprison->Execute. If they rebel it's a non-problem. You just beat their liege. They will be no match and you get a valid reason to revoke their titles instead.

Even if you don't want to go the possible tyranny route you can just move them to a different council position and then plot to murder them. Nothing with council rights stops swapping positions.

1
MiciusPorciusCraven•

Sounds like a plan

1
27Artemis•

Yep. Doesn't matter if I'm rp-ing as a just character, if that happens to me ..... goodbye.

1
pervfufu•

JuSt Rp MaN!

But no seriously, if you feel these pathetic excuse for a vassal is not worth blocking a murder scheme, you can swap them to another council position for which they may have a higher score. But if still you deem them not even worthy of licking your boots, you can grant them as a vassal of another vassal of yours and now it's their problem

Or abduct them and chain torture them until the event of breaking their mind fires. Now THAT'S fun RPig

1
SaenOcilis•

You could also try investigating their court for hooks, or kissing them off until they rebel or you’ve found a way to imprison them. Once that’s done you can either kill, banish or revoke their titles.

1
Nica-E-MBrittany better "Bretagne" than Britain!•

kissing them off until they rebel

Now THAT is a way to force someone to rebel! xD

1
Ratmor•

If you are not required to follow the previous arrangements they are not required to follow you as their king. Everything's fair.

1
SmocksTOP•

That's not how wars work.

1
Ratmor•

In this game or irl? Irl all of those vassals wouldn't acknowledge you as their king just because you made the previous king scatter. Most of the vassals usually have ties to current royal dinasty, so they wanna be kings themselves, or want to be independent, and if you're a ruler in the capital it's capital only if other provences consider it one. The war expedites such processes.

1
SmocksTOP•

In both.

I'm not asking for them to accept me I'm asking for the game not to have them walk into the Imperial Palace explaining that they're now one of my four most trusted viziers because of this slip of paper signed by the king I just publicly executed, and my guy throwing up his hands saying what can he do. Bonus points that the newly displaced ex-marshal who was instrumental in the victory to begin with, as well as every one of his lieutenants, friends, and family, is now going to be upset with me as a tyrant when I shred that piece of paper.

If the new vassals don't see me as a just king despite my material power and try to murder me, spy on me, steal from me, kill my advisors and soldiers, assist foreign lords, or otherwise subvert me that's completely understandable. That's not what this is. This is just a silly oversight about vassal contracts when lands change realms.

1
Ratmor•

That's why irl you never invade someone without knowing how are you going to hold the land after conquest. Typical Alexander Macedon situation

1
PyukumukuGuts•

This is the one situation where I'll go completely against my character's traits and even disregard any tyranny incurred from imprisoning someone without cause. I don't care what else is going on, I absolutely refuse to let anyone else pick who gets to be on my council. Fuck you, King of England. Your martial is shit. I'm appointing the landless peasant who lead a revolt against me because his martial amazing.

1
andronicus_14Bohemia•

If it was a holy war against a hostile faith, shouldn’t you have just received the titles, not the vassals? That’s the whole reason by the sword is so useful to me. When I win the holy war, I get their titles and can distribute them however I please. What’s the point of a holy war if you have to keep vassals of a hostile faith?

1
SmocksTOP•

In Fundamentalist and (I think) Righteous faiths you vassalize everyone of the same faith and take the titles of everyone else. With Pluralism you only get the top liege's domain. Pluralism just happens to be unusually common in the starts/areas/characters I play as so I either need to dump the ~6k piety and accept my realm will hate me for a generation or two while we painstakingly convert everyone and everything to get out of it or deal with this. There's still a point, it's a cheap causus belli that's readily available if you're, say, a Muslim in Europe. It's really not so awful to have Catholic vassals either. The only real headache is this, the inherited contracts.

1
Fulbie•

That might've been a friendly-faith vassal under the infidels' yoke so she got to stay.

1
bucarcar•

Had the same problem a week ago when i nabbed Serbia from the Byzantines, ended up with a pissy countess with 7 provinces who paid 0 taxes, 0 levies had Guaranteed everything except Religious Rights, Coin Stamping and Council Position.

That war against the Byzantines was hard, brutal and pissing me off since they kept coming back and i had to restart sieging provinces over and over again.

This b*tch joined a rebel faction against me, like 2 weeks from when she became my vassal and had 32k troops (late game around 15.th century~).

I may have sort of gone a little overboard and hunted down and continuously bullied the next 4 generations of her family before forgetting about them since i had to deal with becoming ellected for Emperor of my OC empire

1
sephstorm•

Yeah thats when I right click slay.

1
Nardo_T_Icarus•

Okay, but what's her intrigue score?

1
UnholyN7Legitimized bastard•

Imprison then execute. You gain a little tyranny, who cares lol

1
_mortacheInbread 🍞•

If its a count, I usually just drop them under a duke and have them deal with it lol

1
whispering3•

They all do the Petition Liege decision, right?

Should be at that time, they come to ask if you will honour their previous contract. You get a yes decision (for whatever bonus that might get you - opinion, grandeur, popular opinion etc.) a no decision (default contract, at cost of opinion) and a no decision BUT in THEIR favour.

1
4skin_GamerCancer•

Heh revokes title

1