Ideas for actresses to play the mane six (humans)

What actresses should play the mane six if there were a MLP:FiM live-action movie?

I'm sure this is flame-fodder, but here are my suggestions:
Applejack: Gina Torres
Fluttershy: Jewel Staite
Pinkie Pie: ?
Rainbow Dash: ?
Rarity: Morena Baccarin
Twilight Sparkle: Natalie Portman

Rationale:
Natalie Portman could play both the "leader" role, but also a convincing "nerd".
Gina Torres, based on her role as Zoe in Firefly, could pull off a hardy, strong, honest character.
Jewel Staite: Not sure she could be as timid as FS, but it seems a decent fit.
Morena Baccarin basically already played a Rarity as the companion.

Better suggestions are the entire point of this post, so please, suggest away!

Posted Dec 21, 2012, 3:16 AM UTC · edited

16
Start_WarsVinyl Scratch•

We need to work Emma Watson into that list somehow.

3
GodofZelda•

I could definitely see Emma Watson playing Twilight Sparkle. But, I could never see Natalie Portman playing her.

3
CodyL211•

If it wasn't for all of her issues she has had, I believe Lindsay Lohan would make a good Rainbow Dash? I think she has the voice for it and could work the personality very well.

Edit: Also, Lisa Kudro for Pinkie Pie. She is the actress who played Phoebe Buffay in 'Friends".

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

yea, she'd do a great job as Philomena.

wait..

3
MikeStern25•

I suggest Zooey Deschanel as Twilight, change Jewel to Pinkie and since we're getting the cast together Summer Glau as Fluttershy. Then we could have Nathan Fillion play.... Spike?.... eh... I don't know.

1
[deleted]•

Ashleigh Ball and Andrea Libman should do Rainbow Dash and Pinkie Pie. Yes I mean live action and no I am not kidding. Anyone else would be a crime.

Agree with the OP for the most part except Natalie Portman for Twilight Sparkle. Not a good match. Choosing a relatively unknown actor may be a good choice here.

1