How do you rule Cold / Fire Resistance applying to Environmental Temperatures?

Advice

Maybe I completely missed it in the rules, but how should Cold and Fire resistance apply to Environmental Temperatures, such as when exploring an arctic wasteland or a volcanic chamber? I assume it would apply somehow (Imagine a dragon's frost breath hurts you less but a cold wind still hurts you normally) but how would it apply?

The thought I've had so far is that each point of damage resistance you have makes those temperatures feel 5 degrees more comfortable for you. I.e You have cold resistance 4, you get to -10 degrees F weather before suffering the effects of Severe Cold, instead of 12 degrees F.

Anyone have any alternative thoughts, or any advice given in the rules that I've overlooked?

Thanks!

Posted Jul 23, 2023, 5:51 PM UTC

11
AutoModeratorMOD•

This post is labelled with the Advice flair, which means extra special attention is called to the Be Kind and Respectful rule. If this is a newcomer to the game, remember to be welcoming and kind. If this is someone with more experience but looking for advice on how to run their game, do your best to offer advice on what they are seeking.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
Astareal38•

Take a look at the heritage that have environmental effects built into their descriptions.

Take wintertouched heritage for humans as an example.

"You gain cold resistance equal to half your level (minimum 1), and you treat environmental cold effects as if they were one step less extreme (incredible cold becomes extreme, extreme cold becomes severe, and so on)."

1
CapisbobOP•

Now were talking! This is a great place to look. Thanks!

1
Jenos•

This table indicates the relative levels of damage that the various temperatures apply. Having resistance would mean you ignore the damage - for example, having like 5 fire resistance is probably enough to completely ignore minor fire damage from heat.

However, there are no hard numbers as to how much damage minor or moderate means. So you'll have to gut check what levels of resistance you feel is appropriate.

Resistance alone won't help with the fatigue issue, however. Fire resistance doesn't, for example, mean you sweat less in the desert.

1
CapisbobOP•

I hadnt even considered the resistance's effect on the ongoing damage. Thats a good point.

To your last point, SHOULDNT resistance to fire mean you sweat less in the desert? Isnt it shielding you from the heat? I know it doesnt RAW. Im just thinking it should. No?

1
Jenos•

No. As an example, firefighters wearing heat resistance clothing still sweat and fatigued.

The fatigue is a holistic abstraction of all the elements of trekking in that temperature, not just the damage.

Also I edited my original post with the link to the tables with the damage if you missed it.

1
CapisbobOP•

Sure, but firefighters are wearing heavier gear, and are still experiencing warmer temperatures than are comfortable.

But if a creature's resistance is due to their natural defenses, they are actually comfortable in hotter climates. My pet bearded dragon as a kid, for instance, would seek out sunbathing under the heat lamp, and would get sick if left in colder rooms. Meanwhile, the heatlamp was uncomfortable for my hand, and if I lay under one, I would sweat. Likewise, Im far more likely to get hypothermia in arctic climates, while polar bears can go swimming in them with no risk. Would you say the lizard has fire resistance, and the polar bear has cold resistance?

1
Jenos•

But if a creature's resistance is due to their natural defenses

But at that point, you've now deviated from fire resistance to a general acclimation to the climate.

Wearing a ring of fire resistance isn't the same as having a lizard biology suited for heat, which is why you don't get the benefit.

That's why features like winter touched heritage give both cold resistance and a reduction in environmental severity. That heritage comprises both the ability to handle the environment and the resistance.

But they are separate features

1
56Bagels•

The tangible effects of extreme temperature are detailed here.

It increases your susceptibility to fatigue and also deals minor to moderate damage over long lengths of time. Fire and Cold resistance would block the damage portion up to a point, but it would not prevent the fatigue.

The fatigue is represented over the course of minutes or hours, not simply moments of damage like touching an open flame. You can put on sunscreen, a hat, and light colored clothing on a 110 degree day outside, but you'll become dehydrated and exhausted if you spend literally hours in the sunshine. An oven mitt will not help you here.

On the other hand, Endure Elements is a level 2 spell, 12 gp for a scroll that lasts one person an entire day on three spell lists. Your change would make this spell useless.

1
OsSeeker•

Wearing oven mitts will keep you from getting burned when touching hot things, but it won’t protect you from dehydration. Environmental heat isn’t the same thing as fire damage imo, and I wouldn’t let fire resistance by itself negate hot environment penalties.

1
CapisbobOP•

Heat is heat. Fire damage is intense heat in a short burst. If your skin is naturally resilient to heat, allowing you to shrug off intense heat in a short burst, that means the skin doesnt transfer heat as quickly as normal skin, or it circulates heat better, etc.

Your example works in the case of an oven mitt, because the mitt doesnt cover the whole body. Another example of your point would be a shield which provides fire resistance while equipped.

But in the case of a whole suit, or a magical aura, your entire body is being protected from the heat, not just protecting from heat in one place or from one direction. It also matters if the protection circulates your own heat.

Consider a white dragon, which is immune to cold damage. Where do they live? The arctic. Why? Well, cold temperatures, both environmental AND direct contact dont bother them. Meanwhile, being weak against fire, you traditionally never find one in the desert. And if you did, theyd have made their own lair into an ice fortress. In their case, their immunity and weakness is implied to be the result of their biology (magical or natural), and therefore its reasonable to assume that one is at least connected with the other.

So while I'd agree that its probably not safe to make a blanket statement, its also not reasonable to say one NEVER equals the other. Its probably most reasonable to leave it up to GM discretion in the moment. No?

1