Why so much retail in China?

问题 | General Question (Serious)

Are Chinese people still doing a lot of retail shopping in China? I'm seeing new malls that look almost exactly what American malls were like back in the early 90s. Why would you need two retail stores selling DJI drones within a mile of each other? Is it really worth dedicating a huge chunk of space and an employee to selling hot water kettles? Are people actually buying things, or they just filling space? I see food and drink stores doing pretty well, but other retail looking pretty empty of buying customers.

Another question is why are there so many fucking bank branches everywhere? The only time I've been into a bank branch in America in the last 10 years was to get a mortgage, trying to figure out why there needs to be one on every other corner here, especially with no one using cash anymore. I work for a bank, and branches seem to be about as relevant as ATMs these days. What are people here using them here for?

Posted Jul 24, 2023, 9:02 AM UTC

11
AutoModeratorMOD•

Posts flaired as "Serious" are for people seeking responses that are made in good faith and will be moderated more heavily than other threads. Off-topic and deliberately unhelpful responses will be removed and the user permanently banned. One such example would be commenting "don't go to china", or "go to taiwan", in response to questions related to studying in China or relocating to China.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
PimpingBunny69•

there is no better stuff to build. you will also notices alot of pharmacies

1
BingHongChaIsrael•

Because there is still demand for it.

There are many like my wife, who will buy 30 articles of clothing online and will return 29 of them, consuming literally every free moment they have.

There are others who would rather drive the 5 minutes to Zara to decide that they dont want anything

1

Drive 5 minutes, spend 15 minutes looking for a parking space, then park back at your place, and walk the 4 minutes to the mall? Did you marry my mum?

1
Janbiya•

Population density in the cities is a lot higher than it usually is in America. That means that retail businesses need to have a lot of capacity within a relatively small area to accommodate those customers. A good point of comparison is downtown San Francisco, where there are neighborhoods with a Starbucks on literally every block -- that's about one Starbucks every 100-200 meters. And there are two Starbucks on some of those blocks.

Is there too much retail in China? Probably. Almost certainly, in fact. Quite a lot of malls have shut down over the last few years, and many more are struggling to rent out all their storefronts. But most shopping centers are doing OK and are unlikely to disappear or be abandoned any time soon.

There's a lot of money to be made from a very successful mall, so investors are willing to take some risk.

1
onlysubbedhereOP•

Thanks for your reply! What are you using bank branches for? I asked my wife's cousin and she said to check balances, don't people just do that online? Now that people are paying for things digitally, is direct deposit common for salaries?

1
warehouse341•

Wire transfers, investments, identification verification, secure token upgrades, typical banking stuff (that would be deposits, withdrawals, etc.).

1
onlysubbedhereOP•

Thanks, that makes some sense if those services are unavailable or restricted online.

1
BitLox•

Also, old folks like to use banks in person.

1
thecleaner78•

My in-laws still use paper books for transactions. Fil doesn’t even have a bank card

1

There is no public data on it buts it's telling how first tiers have a dozen busy malls, countless underperforming ones and don't get me started about these super localized dingie ones nobody ever goes too. And this is in first tiers go to lower tiers and it's way, way worse.

But even the successful ones there is little clarity other than TKH which is publicly traders by Swire, and the numbers are abysmal compared to western counter parts. Keep in mind TKH is top league and it does financially shit.

I reckon it's also calculated in as those very developers are each and everyone junk rated.

So why the exist, I reckon like a ton of development, it's done to blow it up, get rich and eventually it crumbles, who cares.

1
Kelaifu•

Banking is still very much done over the counter, online banking isn't nearly as popular as the west. Retail still baffles me though, streets where literally every shop either sells tea or baijiu.

1
Ainex25•

Developers will often include large retail spaces in their plans in order to get government approval for their residential developments. The local official can then book the retail locations as a large increase in tax base based on projected earnings before they’re even occupied. Then that official moves on in a few years before the retail space is seen to remain vacant/half-occupied and never generates the expected revenue.

1
onlysubbedhereOP•

This makes more sense to me than the large population argument. I see a larger amount of higher end retail but not a larger amount of shoppers.

1

Chinese actually see these malls as more advance than the US. In China, there are social media posts of how US malls are dead looking while China keeps building malls.

The reality is the US is in the next phase of capitalism which has major consequences but also a lot of benefits.

But yeah, most Chinese dont see it as "we're behind" but they see it as "we're ahead." This is true for every developing country in the world. They never had that before and clearly find it a luxury.

Another thing is Serpentza on YouTube has explained (I might get banned for mentioning his name lol), most Chinese are in big cities, most of China doesn't have sprawling neighbourhoods with houses everywhere like in NA/Europe thus the malls server as a much more practical place too so while it doesn't make sense in the West as much anymore, it makes a lot more sense there due to the big city, having stores all in one spot, away from the rain and snow.

1
BakGikHung•

How long have you lived in Asia ? people live inside shopping malls.

1
onlysubbedhereOP•

I haven't lived in China for 11 years, but retail has been dying in the United States for the last 15 or so years, so I thought maybe there would be a similar trend in China.

Funny thing is even in dying malls I see more people with shopping bags then I see here. But my limited observations don't mean shit.

1
rm-rd•

Chinese customers will often like to shop for things in places with similar stores, so they can shop around and compare. If there's one shop selling DJI drones, they'll wonder if it's a rip-off, but if there's two they can pick one. So you can get malls with a lot of consumer tech, or a lot of fashion, or whatever the big category is.

1
onlysubbedhereOP•

At least in my experience these are more traditional Chinese markets with booths. I'm more referring to newer mall style stores, so like the DJI is a company store like the Mi store, not just a reseller.

I don't know if these malls have become ubiquitous in all of China, or if I'm just visiting higher end areas.

1
Starrylands•

Why are there convenience stores within a minute's walk, often times less, of each other in every major city in East Asia?

The West =/= East Asia.

1
onlysubbedhereOP•

I actually see customers buying stuff at convenience stores though.

1

I don't know about now but people used to buy stuff in the stores too. They wouldn't exist if they were never profitable. It's possible that these days business is down though.

How long have you lived in China for? It's not something you already noticed 10 years ago, right?

1
Starrylands•

And people buy things at malls, too...

Mall culture is very much alive in East Asia. I'm from Taiwan, and Sogo, for example, is always packed.

1
AlecHutson•

At least where I am in central Shanghai, malls are where you go to eat. A discount store or a Uniqlo might have a few shoppers, but at the large malls near me (Mei Luo Cheng in xujiahui, IAPM at Shanxi Road) the retail spots that are not ultra high or ultra low end have been turning into restaurants. Everyone under 50 orders just everything online.

1
kappakai•

Mei Luo Cheng, is that the electronics mall in XJH? That used to be SLAMMED back in the day in the mid 00s. And it was booth after booth selling all kinds of electronics, computers, cameras, cables, etc. I imagine online has taken a lot of that business since then tho.

1
AlecHutson•

Yeah, it's almost entirely restaurants / cafes / food stalls now. Some of those vendors have moved over to another electronics mall nearby. And you're right, JD.com et all have scooped a lot of that business.

1
Dundertrumpen•

Another point I'd like to make is that modern shopping malls are basically public spaces where people meet, eat, watch a movie, take their kids for ice-skating, or playing in the arcade hall. It's great because they're warm open spaces in the winter, and air-conditioned open spaces in the summer. Even if they're loud and crowded, they're still generally a lot more comfortable than being outdoors in 40 degrees (celsius).

1
onlysubbedhereOP•

This is a great point, we've been traveling in Hong Kong and southern China and it's been hotter than hell. Getting into climate controlled malls have been a godsend. I've seen a lot of people eating at restaurants and kids playing in play areas (holy shit there are a lot of claw machines everywhere).

I'm from Minnesota where were cold a good number of months of the year, and unsurprisingly we were the first state to open an indoor mall. Lots of malls at home at trying to convert into more restaurant and experience based venues, but a lot of them still end up feeling pretty empty and an outdated concept.

1
Mister_Green2021•

It's a bubble. Are you seeing empty malls there like empty malls in the States?

1
onlysubbedhereOP•

Seeing lots of people in restaurants and supermarkets in the malls, but not a lot of people doing retail shopping. I thought maybe chinese brands were using retail stores to increase brand awareness, but I don't know if that's the case.

1
LunaSolarMilkway•

If you walk into the malls, most of them was absent.

1
Bill_In_1918•

There is nothing else to do in China. Going to a mall/shop is like the main form of entertainment

1
doclkk•
  1. Retail shops are because people want to experience the store with the product.
  2. There are many bank functions you have to do in person. Getting a loan. Paying back a loan. Transferring a house deed. Getting Forex.
1
Crovasio•

These stores make more money online and through exports, but likely they need to show physical spaces as part of governmental regulations. Their rent may also be partially subsidized by the income that the food courts, restaurants, liquor stores, spas, indoor playgrounds, and karaoke booths in the mall make.

1
VaporWaveShine•

Lots of restaurants and movie theaters in malls they have ice rinks and tutoring schools and pets stores. The malls are still a destination to go. American malls failed to incorporate other attractions

1
North-Shop5284•

In my experience a big mall would open up. Filled with new stores and restaurants for like 6 months to a year. Then the inevitable decline would follow. Rinse and repeat with a new location.

A lot of people hang out at the mall though because there are restaurants, cafes, and usually a grocery store. All the other shopping kind of sucks though Imo.

1
stealthzeus•

Financial Engineering. There are people who bought up these store fronts in bulk and lure investors with 10-15% Annualized ROI. Then do it all over again once the store front inevitably crash and burn with the investors not able to collect on the shell companies that operates the store front.

1