ELI5: The difference, pros, and cons between leasing, financing, and any other options when looking for a new car.

Explained

A similar question was asked about a year ago, but the answers didn't tickle my pickle enough.

I will be looking to get a new car soon, since all of my family's cars are dying. I will be the one to take the hit. Regardless of car make, what are the differences between leasing a car, financing a car, and any other options available to a university student with a limited budget?

Which one would benefit me the most if I were to pay it off consistently? Which would hurt me the least if things go sour and I can't pay it off? Et cetera.

Posted Dec 22, 2012, 4:44 PM UTC

85
Funkytown•

Any way you dice it, if you don't pay cash for a car you are indebting yourself, so remember that above all else.

Leasing is like renting a car. When your rental time is up, you just hand the keys back. There may be fees for excessive wear and tear if you haven't taken care of the car, or if you've put more miles on the car than agreed when you took out the lease. People that lease might only use their car to get to and from work (have predictable miles), can deduct their leasing expense as part of a business, and find it important to have a fancier/newer car than they would otherwise be prepared to afford. Since they never have any equity or ownership in the car, and are only paying to use it, it might be cheaper in terms of monthly payments for the value of the car.

Financing is borrowing money to buy the car. It comes with interest payments on the money you borrow. It's usually all worked out how much you will pay for how long, and at the end you own the car. This is good for people that don't need/want to change their car every few years.

The last option is paying cash.

Owning is most flexible, because the car is yours. You can put in a new stereo and drive it as far as you want and nobody can tell you otherwise. Leasing can be convenient because you don't need to worry about resale value, and some leases might include servicing (because the real owner wants to take care of their car).

Cars on balance are money pits. Whether you lease or finance, you are using someone else's money to use an asset that will depreciate. The smartest thing you can do (for most people) is borrow as little as possible, at the cheapest interest rate as possible. This is very hard to work out with leasing, which probably won't suit your situation anyway.

TL;DR buy a reliable cheap car and borrow as little as possible as cheaply as possible.

8
RobbieHartOP•

I've been waiting all day. Awesome response!

1
WinglessFlutters•

I like Funkytown's explanations! Using money costs money. Every $ you spend is a $ you can't invest, and every dollar that you borrow today, costs you $0.02 (for a 2% interest rate) every year until you pay it off.

Buying New typically gets you a new/reliable car, but the vehicle depreciates immediately after you purchase it. If you try to sell it later, it'll sell for far less. A used car depreciates less than a new car.

Leasing is convenient and simple, but at the end of the lease you don't have a car. Buying New gets you a nice car, but it's expensive and best suited if you plan on keeping the car for a long time. Buying used is cheaper, but risks whether the former owner took good care of the vehicle. Buying used from a deal mitigates some of that.

Estimate how much you'll drive, and both what you'll use the car for/when you'd want to replace the car. If you won't drive a lot, then a cheap car, even if it gets poor gas efficiency and is a used car with higher maintenance costs, makes sense. You'll pay up front costs, yearly costs (Insurance, registration and inspections) and costs per mile (Gasoline, preventative maintenance and repairs).

If you plan on driving a lot and keeping the car, then something efficient quickly becomes important.

If you choose to finance, look at financing from a bank/credit union, then paying 'cash' to the dealer. The Bank interest rates are likely better than what you'd get from a dealer.

I don't know your exact situation, but I would... -Use the Kelley Blue Book (http://www.kbb.com/) to get a general idea of what vehicles cost, and which cars are most valuable to you for the price. -Become somewhat familiar with what cars need to survive, and use that to judge the used vehicles that you see. -Throw aesthetics, style and color out the window. If there's an unpopular car, then it's likely in far better condition and age for the cost, and you should go for it! :D -Go to a credit union to see how much you'd be approved for a loan, if you need it. (Borrow less than you can.)

Then, buy a VW TDI Diesel Beetle that's 1998-2003, and those engines apparently last forever and get ridiculously high efficiency.

2
RobbieHartOP•

Thanks. I'll be sure to keep an eye out for that car. xD

1
galt88•

I can tell you from personal experience (the last 10 years) that buying an older car for cash will save you money in the long run. I drove a 5 speed Saturn, that I paid for in cash when it was 5 years old, for over 7 years. I have been driving a 14 year old Accord 5 speed for the last two that I also paid for with cash. Yes, you will have to replace things as needed, but these costs can be saved for and paid with cash as well. It's awesome to not have a big car payment hanging over your head.

1