Chris Matthews' Economic Claims Are Wrong

Episode Discussion

He kept hammering on with this simplistic model of an economy where the only driver of inflation is how much money is printed. If economics was that simple, we would stop studying at Economics 101 and the Fed could be run by one person who just crunches the numbers about how much money should be created each year. This isn't reality. Economics is far more complicated than that and I think he knows that and I'm disappointed that he wasn't pressed on that.

Posted Aug 17, 2023, 5:15 PM UTC

136
flyingthedonutSaagar in 🚧🚦🏍 & Krystal in 📈📉📊•

Wtf are you talking about he wasn't pressed on that? Krystal tried getting into but the dude wouldn't shut his trap for more than 1.3 seconds. You must of not watched the entire interview because Krystal tried on more than one occasion, but he just wasn't having it. Watch and pay attention than make your complain post.

1
bagehisOP•

She argued with him, but the argument wasn't on his use of a simplistic economic model. She did not press him to defend that. She argued that there was a report that showed corporations. The problem is that she was talking about future spending and he was arguing that more spending always caused inflation. So her arguments weren't directed at his statement. Possibly because she didn't want to return the favor and question his intelligence.

1
flyingthedonutSaagar in 🚧🚦🏍 & Krystal in 📈📉📊•

So you are complaining that she didn't rebuttal in the exact manor that you wanted her to? Ok buddy

1
bagehisOP•

She argued for more spending in the future. He said spending equals inflation. She said corporate greed was the cause of most of the inflation last year, but I think the correct argument should have been monetary policy isn't that simplistic and he should know better than to make such a simplistic claim.

She didn't address his argument. Her counter could be true as well as his argument. The problem is that his argument is known to be incorrect. His argument was the economic equivalent of "an apple a day keeps the doctor away" in response to a discussion about a cancer diagnosis. It was extremely dumb and he should have been laughed at for making such a dumb comment like it was a legitimate argument.

1
NefariousNaz•

She responded saying that she doesn't agree with his statement. I don't think it matters that she didn't say "it's not that simple".

1
mojogogo124•

Chris was a terrible interview. Guy couldn't stop talking over Krystal and Sagar. That was brutal to listen to.

1
bagehisOP•

Definitely. And he would let Saagar wrap up the interview. He's clearly a bit starved for that spotlight.

1
statecv•

Chris Matthews never stops talking and he's what, 80 years old? So no way he changes his ways now.

1
Based_Monarchy•

#Free Top G

1
workaholic828•

I remember when I was a boy milk only cost 2 cents per gallon

1
tarc0917•

Why MSNBC hasn't cut Chrissy loose yet us baffling. He is a relic of an ancient day.

They might as well hire Begala and Carville back.

1
Bredditchickens•

He hasn’t been with MSNBC for years. 🤡

1
LasBarricadas•

Three years to be exact

1
tarc0917•

He returned a few years ago as a guest and political analyst.

Think before speaking next time.

1
Bredditchickens•

Guess you watch a lot more MSNBC than I do. But I wouldn’t consider that “thinking”

1
Square_Donnie12•

Inflation is absolutely driven by money supply growth lol

1
bagehisOP•

Inflation CAN be driven by monetary supply growth. Monetary supply changes CAN impact the velocity of money, which OFTEN leads to inflation.

1
Square_Donnie12•

No. It does.

1

I am sure your favorite politician has told you that, but I have yet to see an economist come to that same conclusion. I would cite you papers of well respected economist, but you would not read them, or be able to grasp the concepts contained in them.

1
Square_Donnie12•

Let me guess…you think it’s corporate greed 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

1

If we were a closed system sure, but the fact the dollar is the reserve currency of choice limits that. If that where the case explain current inflation in places that use another currency. It is a very elementary way to look at while ignoring a plethora of other factors.

1
Projectrage•

It Chris’s argument is true, why is it that giving money to the military cause inflation???

Very convenient.

1
vinegar-pisser•

It does

1
eico3•

But that’s literally the definition of inflation - where the inflation shows up in the markets is a different discussion

1
bagehisOP•

It's the definition of inflation in econ 101. Economics quickly shifts to velocity of money and increasingly complex models as you go deeper into the field of study.

Just a quick example of why adding more currency into circulation does not cause inflation, more often than not, is because it doesn't necessarily get spent. If you look at the balance sheets of large corporations, at times, the actual cash on hand can get ridiculously high. That money is in circulation, but it is not impacting prices because it is not being used to buy goods.

In a similar fashion, when household savings go up, the velocity of money goes down, so the inflation rate goes down unless additional currency enters circulation. Of course, there are many many different factors that counteract additional currency in circulation, such as supply and demand, so it is simply not accurate to say more money in circulation means inflation.

1
eico3•

Ie: where inflation shows up in the market is a different discussion.

1
bagehisOP•

No. That isn't a question of where it shows up. The government can dump a mountain of currency into the market and if it doesn't get spent on products in the economy, there is no information impact. The velocity of the money matters. The amount of money only matters if it impacts the velocity of money.

1
eico3•

Seems to me like you’re having that different discussion about when and where inflation shows up that I was alluding to.

1
yokingato•

Why are you acting like people and corporations are just gonna sit on money instead of immediately invest/spend it like we saw after covid relief.

You're advocating Paul Krugman's theory which has clearly failed as we saw in 2021 until now. Yes corporations price gauging is a major problem too, but thinking you can just drop trillions of dollars into the economy and it won't affect things is just silly tbh.

1

He’s a politics/history guy who gets visibly angry when economics comes up and stonewalls like a toddler bc he knows he lacks the wherewithal to defend his orthodoxy against people who do know what they’re talking about on the subject. If you’re not a math guy that’s fine but go ahead and stop screaming at math guys over economics bc “NO I TOOK MACRO ECONOMICS THAT’S EVERYTHING

1
Teddie-Bonkers•

I'm glad people are starting to wake up to the fact Chris Matthews isn't very smart. Yelling and being an asshole aren't indicators of intelligence.

1
floydtaylor•

no they aren't.

he wasn't just saying money printed. he's also talking about expenditure. he specifically states the infrastructure bill is inflationary (which it is in the short term) even though he he thinks it will be good in the long term

krystal was saying companies keeping prices up. that's true ....BUT..... they can only do that when govs and fed reserve have flushed the economy with cash. she is saying companies are the cause of inflation when in fact they are a symptom

1
Cpt_phudge_off•

Inflation is a monetary phenomena. Too much money chasing too few goods. It's by definition a function of printing too much money.

You can't remove dollars from circulation in that equation. The government taxing it and spending money is among the least efficient uses of money in the economy.

It's pretty wild how politically oriented this sub is without even even taking an ECON101 class.

1
yokingato•

The government taxing it and spending money is among the least efficient uses of money in the economy.

Why?

1
Bredditchickens•

Krystal is always with this conspiracy theory about coordinated price hikes.

1