La Flèche, the fire.

Spoiler

Patrick Tull is reading "The Fortunes of War," to me on audiobook, it's my 3rd or 4th time though the series, and I decided to see if HMS La Flèche was a real ship. As it turns out, it is not, though there were two HMS Fleches, but both were lost under very different circumstances.

While searching I found this subreddit and a couple of threads blaming MacLean's pipe. None of them suggested that the pressed Americans, upon finding out Britain and the US were now at war, started the fire intentionally.

That was my immediate thought the first time through, even if MacLean was careless with his pipe. However careless he might be, he'd managed to survive a long time on the ship, the fire follows the news of war fairly closely, and while we aren't told where it started, there seems to be a decent amount of time to get into the boats.

And while I'm sure O'Brian did want it just a tad ambiguous, (or he would have told us,) and those hints are further back where Captain Yorke mentions having pressed several men out of an American merchantmen. Later, MacLean is careless with his pipe a bit further on, but even so Maturin is asleep when the fire starts, suggesting that it's a time of the night when MacLean most likely would be as well, when the fewest sailors would be on deck, the ideal time to fire the ship of your kidnappers who are also now at war with your country.

O'Brian being such a master of gentle suggestion... I'd almost think that makes it more likely, as it would be like him to put the clues to the real cause just a little further from the event, and another hint to a wrong path closer. (Though of course he never specifically tells us.)

If one were to decided to set fire to a ship and had moral questions about it on starting the fire, they might be answered by the boats being already in the water, the fire being started in some way that allowed himself and most of the hands to escape into those boats, far enough north that they won't freeze, and with a fair chance of rescue or land.

I'd not have started the thread at all if I didn't find no one else with that theory in the other threads.
Did anyone else think this?

Posted Aug 25, 2023, 3:04 AM UTC

113
Loading comments…