r/mtg•
flaveraid

Strategies to beat Gishath, Sun's Avatar EDH deck?

My buddy put together a tribal dinosaur deck with [[Gishath, Sun's Avatar]] as the Commander.

So far I've found a couple decks to try and counter it.

  1. Land destruction with [[Numot, The Devastator]]

  2. Counters/Voltron? with [[Skullbriar, the Walking Grave]]

I'm curious how others play against heavy creature/dinosaur EDH decks. He seems to be going for maximum salt, so I'd like to return the flavor.

Posted Aug 26, 2023, 8:24 PM UTC

110
MTGCardFetcher•

Gishath, Sun's Avatar - (G) (SF) (txt)
Numot, The Devastator - (G) (SF) (txt)
Skullbriar, the Walking Grave - (G) (SF) (txt)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
SHEISTYRICEY•

Have you tried killing his commander

1
flaveraidOP•

I have some spot removal and sweeps available, but my current deck is on the casual side.

1
lessthan_pi•

Always run more removal and sweepers!

1
SHEISTYRICEY•

Ok well you asked how to counter Gishath, you have to remove Gishath

1
theunholycanoli•

Do you have a deck list for his deck? I am curious what kinda maximum salts he’s got

1
flaveraidOP•

I don't have a list. Galta, both Etalis, Zacama, Ancient Imperiosaur, Tyrranax, etc.

1
Emerald_Knight2814•

As a Gishath player myself, any sort of highly interactive control strategy completely bricks me, Sweepers especially. Gishath is a kill on sight commander, and any Gishath player should be aware of that and be playing as aggressively as possible. In your case, you need to prevent them from casting and/or attacking with Gishath as much as possible. Being 8 mana removing Gishath once is such a huge blow to our tempo, the more you can do it the faster we brick and struggle to come back from it.

1
flaveraidOP•

I figured the land destruction option is pretty Stax. I've never used the archetype before, and from what I've read it's peak salt.

1
Emerald_Knight2814•

Technically no, effectively yes if that makes sense. Stax is technically "stacking" a bunch of limiting effects on Permanents like [[Winter Orb]] and [[Dranith Magistrate]] that straight up prevent players from playing the game. Effectively Land destruction does this, but technically since Land Destruction "Ponza" strategies are usually Spells as opposed to Permanents it isn't technically Stax.

1
MTGCardFetcher•

Winter Orb - (G) (SF) (txt)
Dranith Magistrate - (G) (SF) (txt)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
jstropes•

I dunno as a creature-focused deck like Gishath is really, as you say, "going for maximum salt". Can you explain what the deck is specifically doing that makes you think this is the case? The strategies you're suggesting to combat the deck, like MLD, seem much more salt-inducing than I can imagine any Gishath deck being.

Any Instant speed interaction will cripple the deck as well as any fog effects since Gishath won't be able to pull the dinos out and won't deal any damage...

1
flaveraidOP•

Salt is subjective to me. I don't want to get stomped by a board full of dinosaurs.

Yes, MLD seems over the top. This is why I'm also looking at options like Skullbriar. I appreciate your input.

1