How do you come out to a loved one when there's no real "reveal"?

So I'm home right now for the first time in a year (late christmas, because retail) and I've wanted to tell my sister about myself for about 6 months, pretty much since I told my Wife and found out she still loved me.

The trouble is, I don't really know what to tell her, or why I even need to. I'm currently feeling like I'm dual gender, and have no plans to socially or hormonally transition. My only real impetus for coming out is to let her know who I really am, to let her know that there's another side of me that has always been, well, muzzled.

It's not like anything changes afterward, though. I don't have the straightforward "Hi, so I'm going by female pronouns, and these are my boobs, and I may steal some of your dresses and hairspray" story to tell. All I have is, "there's a female side of me. Her name is Hailey. She likes nail polish and skinny jeans. She doesn't really get to go outside."

I just keep feeling like there's nothing to tell, because there's nothing that really impacts my family's lives. There's no misgendering going on, because I'm still being me. It just seems really dumb to risk the potentially life changing awkwardness for no real payoff.

But I really want her acceptance. She's one of my very best friends and I love her to death.

TL;DR - Why is it a good idea to tell my (loving) family about Hailey if they're likely never going to meet her?

Posted Jan 7, 2013, 9:13 AM UTC

1011
iyzie•

We all want the same thing when we come out, we want people to care about us and to love us. Pronouns and name changes provide a convenient excuse, but to me they are just an afterthought that has little to do with what I'm really trying to achieve when I come out to someone close. "Do they accept me?" is just a euphemism for "do they care?" - I learned this because when someone accepts me without caring ("that's great, I'll call you by this name and pronouns, anything else?" as they throw up a wall of emotional distance) I just end up feeling worse than I did before coming out. The solution is to be honest with ourselves about what we want with coming out, and I think love and caring are the real answers.

Whether someone cares doesn't really depend on the details of what you say; chances are, unless they have an appreciable fraction of the knowledge that you do about gender issues, they won't understand the words that come out of your mouth. Their reaction will be emotional, and based about how they feel about you - if they care, they will want to ask questions and understand more, if they don't they'll want a quick checklist of "what does this mean for me?"

Aside from wanting love, another good reason to come out is in case you want to be yourself around someone. I had an experience like this in which I finally got together with a close friend who I had not see in a year, and I was very excited and filled with warm feelings, and he gave me an unexpected gift that meant a lot to me. I burst out with "That's so sweet!", letting down my guard on the fake man-mode through which he had always known me. The things is, I hadn't come out to him yet, and before I said it my masculine conditioning kicked in and said "you can't say that", so I had to consciously override it. As a practical matter, little things like that add up to a good reason to come out to people.

4
Tu-ValOP•

This is all so very true. I want to tell her, not because I want to tell her who I am, she already knows that. I want to tell her because I want her to know why I am the person that I am.

Thank you.

1
neotecha•

Once again, I can relate.

When I first started questioning my gender, I felt like I wanted to tell everyone, especially when I was feeling particularly stressed. One time, I was being grilled by my boss and I just wanted to shout back at him "Shut up! I'm dealing with gender issues and it's more important than this crap!"

I've found that because I have no plans to transition, I really don't see the point in coming out to anyone else. It feels as though there is no point...

2
Tu-ValOP•

Ha! That would have been a priceless reaction.

1
neotecha•

He is pretty misogynistic and closed minded, so I know I would not be able to come out to him at all. Anything outside his paradigm takes way too much effort to explain.

1
Kiranw•

I'm going through this myself. About two weeks ago my brother (28) and his wife came to visit us for the holidays, and one of the nights we were drinking with my sister (25) and her boyfriend and I sort of blurted out I was feeling almost depressed having to keep something (bigender/transgender feelings) to myself. Long story short, I ended up talking to my brother later that night about it while we were both still kind of drunk (since he wanted me to feel like I could talk to him about anything) and I ended up telling him in addition to bursting into tears on his shoulder. He was completely surprised but was still supportive despite not understanding it at all. He ended up telling me some of his deep secrets, and eventually the conversation evolved onto other topics. So much pressure was lifted that night as I could finally be open about it with someone (other than my girlfriend).

After that night, since I felt so much better about it, I ended up telling my sister that I wanted to talk to her about it eventually. It wasn't until yesterday that I sort of had a minor breakdown and I asked to talk to her. I chickened out and then told her I wasn't quite ready to talk to her. I'm sure she kinda knows what might be going on, but she told me she's available to talk whenever I'm ready lol I don't know why I'm nervous to talk to her when she's one of the most open minded people I know (more so than my brother) and on multiple occasions has stood up for LGBT rights and people. It's just harder to be honest without alcohol I guess lol. Eventually I will get around to it.

In my opinion, its better to be open and honest even if there is no real "reveal" or future change. Sometimes it just helps to share the burden with other people and have someone to talk to when you're feeling down. Admittedly, my family is quite open and we share a lot of information with each other, so I don't know if this is the case for everyone.

2
Tu-ValOP•

Yeah, my brother is a completely different story. I'm pretty sure that's going to be an anger reveal.

Without going into too much detail, i'm from a small town that is predominantly white, blue collar, vanilla. There tends to be a fair amount of ignorant racism, homophobia and transphobia, though it really is based on ignorance more than hate. Many gays just leave rather than come out here, likely because it's just easier.

So my loving, caring, protective older brother just so happens to be transphobic. I truly believe that it comes from just not knowing what the rest of the world is like, and that, once he knows, he'll possibly become my biggest ally. But until then, I deal with "that shirt looks queer" and "that guys a tranny." Thus, my big reveal to him will likely be in anger, and will probably consist of me yelling at him about being a transphobic asshat that cuts me down every time he calls someone a faggot, then storming out while his jaw sits on the floor. Then cooling down and accepting his apology and questions.

I think.

1
abbadus•

My older brothers are all the same way. I am closest with my oldest brother, and he knows that I have some deviant tendencies, but has no clue about Abby, has no clue that I've been getting dressed up since I was 8, and will probably never be able to understand it. He just thinks I am a dude who is into some strange stuff...

1
Zamyou•

I think the most important thing for them is to know you are not going to do something that will change your relationship. Also, when she feels you can tell your innermost secrets, i think she starts to trust you more and you feel happier. Win, win!

1
Tu-ValOP•

See that's the funny thing. She trusts me implicitly already. I'm already her fashion advice. My extremely fashionable sister sends me pictures of shirts she's about to buy and asks how they would look. We're incredibly close already, only in this unspoken sort of way. We don't sit down and have deep conversations.

Ugh.

Pretty sure I'll end up talking to her tomorrow night before we go home.

1
neotecha•

I'm interested in hearing how this goes for you!

1