Auto subrogation with a 40k diminished value claim, claim limit issue, which all comes first?

I have an expensive vehicle that is pretty rare, custom rebuilt. I purchased it a couple years ago. I had it trailered taking it back to the builder I bought it from to sell it. There was already a buyer, a price agreed on, just a condition contingency. The buyer was sent well over 200 images of the vehicle, paid earnest money, and was planning on closing the contract that day.

Then an asshat rear ended my trailer hard enough to run up on it and damaged the vehicle. I am covering the damage through my insurance, it looks to be about 70k, and I had the vehicle insured properly, so that is not an issue.

What brings me here, is in my state either my insurance company cannot bring a diminished value claim on my behalf, or 1st party is not allowed it. They tell me I need to pursue the claim on my own.

Here is where it gets sticky. The DV looks to be about 40k, but the policy limit for the other driver is 100k. How does the pecking order work for this? Do I get made whole first? Do they average out percentages and I get a percentage?

Posted Aug 30, 2023, 10:45 PM UTC

119
bigbamboo12345•

what state

1
WeeklyOperationOP•

FL.

1
brycasInsurance Agent, Claims Adjuster•

Florida law follows their made whole doctrine but you'll also need to read your policy to see if there's any subrogation clause that allows the insurer to recover first.

1
WeeklyOperationOP•

I have looked through my policy for that, but I am not seeing anything.

1
brycasInsurance Agent, Claims Adjuster•

Then you should be good! 👍 Look up Florida's made whole doctrine for more info. You'll have to present your DV claim to the other insurance company yourself though since your insurance policy will specifically exclude that. And DV claims are a whole different conversation.

1
saieddie17•

Wouldn’t this be split between the trailer owner and the car owner if you’re talking claimant payout?

1
brycasInsurance Agent, Claims Adjuster•

I read the post as the OP owned the vehicle and the trailer.

1
Shotgun_Mosquito🚗🚘 Auto BI & PD - 21 years 🚘🚗•

What state

1
WeeklyOperationOP•

FL.

1
eye_lowball•

If we could sticky this post and be like this is what a decent DV case is...

Not the Teslas, Hondas, Kias, and all those other things.

(Also nor saying OP will get it, bit definitely has a better shot than most posters)

1
Brief-Avocado886•

Ikr! I want updates on how this plays out from the OP.

1
Bacon003•

There was the Ferrari (I assume) guy six months or so ago who had that complex UMPD DV claim spread across two jurisdictions (Indiana and Tennessee IIRC) He got paid.

1
Deekifreeki•

Just have so say this is the first time in this sub I’ve actually seen a legit/can prove it DV claim outside of GA. I was an adjuster for 5 years and ever paid a DV claim

1
WeeklyOperationOP•

Nice, that makes me feel like i have strong legs to stand on.

1
10PercentOfNothin•

Florida has a made whole doctrine meaning that the priority is to make the individual "financially whole" first. The at-fault insurance is going to pay you out-of-pocket expenses as the first priority- deductible, the trailer itself if it wasn't insured etc.

Sounds like you have the rare gem of actual proven diminished value, so assuming the at-fault company approves diminished value, the DV would be paid to you before your insurance gets paid to "make you whole". Unless your own insurance company for some reason contests that order of payout, that is how I would handle it.

1