CTV Confirms Government(s) employing Internet Trolls, Shills & PR Agents to 'correct misinformation' - YouTube
Posted Jan 9, 2013, 1:07 AM UTC
Posted Jan 9, 2013, 1:07 AM UTC
Hey man, I gotta pay the bills.
[deleted]
that turned out to be bland and uneventful enough that it wasn't even worth going through for more than a few pages
zionistshill is rather butthurt about it
Buttrosa?!
10/10. Well played.
If any actual government shills are reading this: I am willing to sell out completely, please PM me if you're interested in running reddit
I am willing to sell out more than the guy above me, seriously. I'll make it worth your while.
i'll suck yo dick maaaan
This man / woman above me how-ever speaks for themselves though.
"I think he's talking to you." /whisper
Exactly what a shill would say :p
Pfft, I see your r/metacanada and raise you r/Canada.
This is what is called astroturfing. When an entity being paid to represent a side pretends to be a neutral anonymous party to the subject.
It is beneath despicable for the following reasons and more:
if you knew you were talking to a paid government representative your interest in the interaction would depend quite a bit more heavily on the quality of the interaction.
if you knew you were talking to a paid government representative, you might be inclined to question their motivation in how their statements were being formed.
if you knew you were talking to a paid government representative, you would might question the end result of your exchange with them.
It should be a matter of Canadian law that paid government representatives participating on social networks be required to identify themselves as such.
I would also limit their scope to facts only and no interpretation. They would also not be allowed to track your behavior or attempt to track your real identity, unless there's potential harm yada yada yada.
If I knew that there was a person who I could contact on reddit or if they commented on my question with a confirmed account that's very useful.
If they're there correcting me on the government's line then it smacks of "re-education", and if they don't identify themselves it smacks of communist regimes and having the government spy on its citizens for political purposes.
[deleted]
So which NDP staffer are you?
I know being wrong and never admitting it is a frequent speciality of yours, but this takes the cake in a few ways for me.
[deleted]
right back at ya ....
That's why you need to verify the things you hear on chatrooms, comment sections, rebbit threads, etc. There's a lot of misinformation out there not only on the internet, the radio, television. Whether it comes from the government, universities, or activists opposing the government, double check the facts.
Your tax dollars at work!
Bonus: your tax dollars at work posting internet messages that do not state that they are being paid for with your tax dollars/ serve a partisan political purpose.
It is appalling that our money is being wasted this way and moreso that our money is being spent for advancing a political agenda. Make the Cons dig for their own messaging.
EDIT: out, out damn apostrophe
[deleted]
If you're not bothered by taxpayer money being spent on government communications that do not clearly state they are government communications, you've lost your moral compass.
[deleted]
Again, it's tax money being spent on communications that do not clearly state they are being paid for by the GoC. Doesn't matter if the money is being contracted through the PMO. All government comms should state clearly that they are paid for by the GoC. There are huge issues of clarity, openness, honesty and financial responsibility involved.
Obviously the government thinks so.
you are assuming I had morals to begin with.
Nope, it's been pretty clear since the first time I read through a few posts.
I have a moral compass you can buy. Unfortunately all I have in stock right now are Tory moral compasses.
*Your
EDIT:
If you're proposing that the federal government cuts all subsidies to advocacy groups i'm all in.
I would go so far as to call it tax fraud. The cons are using tax dollars to advance their political ideology.
This explains the "as a Canadian" about everything bullshit
AS A CANDIAN SORRY
This explains the extreme conservative bias on r/canada...
How much are they paying you guys?
lol, you think r/canada has a conservative bias? thats hilarious.
Well the comments sure do.
Hardly likely, nearly everyone here is against Harper, and if you went by the general opinion of r/canada, then the NDP would have won last election by a compete landslide.
Are they against Harper, or against blatantly self-interested 'government'
I agree but admittedly all of reddit is like a fucking black hole of racism, sexism and classicist idealistic conservative clusterfuckery
Just what a conservative shill would say.
A link from a year ago, and you've got 7 upvotes for your trouble.
Thanks for confirming the recent influx of conservativism to this subreddit.
You raise a fair point. That link is from a year ago. A lot of things can change in a year.
Ill highlight the fact that reddit itself has grown in popularity over the last year, bringing in new users. They will have there own biases politically.
Maybe r/Canada does have a Conservative lean to it (it doesn't but lets say it does), thats not a bad thing. More viewpoints for different issues is not a bad thing.
Not at all a bad thing, but the behaviour of some of these people downvoting everything they disagree with is not cool.
At first I was so sure this must have been sarcasm.. it makes me sad that there are people with as little awareness as you.
[deleted]
$10 per downvote
You are banned from posting on r/metacanada
is that some kind of racist version of SRS?
I thought SRS was the racist version?
is that some kind of...[significantly less]...racist version of SRS?
FTFY, and yes.
Lol SRS
That explains the 20 posts on r/canada about a meaningless oil sands study, clearly an attempt by the NDP to create controversy about the project.
You got it backwards. Both internet users and Canadians lean fairly prominently towards the left, and yet here on reddit you have plenty of flag waving conservatives in r/canada, and then even places like r/metacanada exist as well.
It is clear to see what the implication is.
I mean it's even obviously what is happening here in these comments with all you people completely ignoring what the actual video is about and misappropriating the concept to fit your narrative.
So, if a place is heavily represented by the left wing, you think because there are a few vocal people who dont fit with that orientation, that they are paid by the govt? that is seriously ridiculous.
1, that's not what i said
2, but using your logic for a moment, how isn't sinsyder-'s comment (or most of the other comments in here) exactly as ridiculous?
Anyway, it only makes sense to astro turf when you need to. Therefore, if there are any paid shills around here, a place that would naturally lean heavily to the left, in all likelihood they would be conservatives.
To be clear though, i don't outright buy the idea at all. The shill-ing that goes on around here is most likely done by simple hobbyists i would think.
I just think its incredibly insulting for a lot of people(not you) in canada to call someone a shill just because their opinion doesnt closely align with the reddit hivemind in some way. Ive been called a shill for opposing sides of the same issue before, pretty hilarious.
R/metacanada is about 1.6% the size of r/Canada and the demographics in a recent survey suggest only 39% of that 1.6% identify as CPC voters. There are hardly plenty of conservatives in this community. The difference of opinion just stands our more.
only 39% ... identify as CPC voters.
kinda like the last electiona, ha ha
Paid shills the likes of which CTV is reporting on, would have no reason to answer such polls honestly or self identify as conservatives, it would likely lose them their cushy jobs surfing FB and Reddit all day for pay.
Canadians lean fairly prominently towards the left
Not really.. If they did we'd have had an NDP government for the past 30 years. At best you could maybe say centre-left. But even that may be a stretch.
I think you need to get out of the echochamber a little more often.
The nation was built on incredibly progressive values and has maintained a constant highly-socialized liberalism since our creation.
Canadian conservatism is to the right of an inherently left-leaning nation. It might not be apparent watching Sun News, but our history is very clearly a progressive one.
There is no "inherent" left or right. The consensus of opinion determines the center, and left and right are always relative to it.
Nobody watches Sun News.
it's always cute when people describe liberal views, which are almost always such that they want to revert back to the 1800's way of thinking are labelled progressive.
ride bikes instead of driving cars, because the population is small enough to live in a very tight area
eat organic food that use old less efficient chemicals and methods
accept drug use to control the masses
etc etc etc
No that just means organized crime hasn't made an agreement with the ndp yet like they have with the other political parties.
Pretty sure that if the conservatives have enough supporters to get a majority government that there would be enough similarly minded people to be a visible minority in an internet forum.
I don't agree. Canada leans to the right, we are not as liberal as we like to think we are.
Well, we are as liberal as our constitution, charter, culture and society say we are.
I am getting downvoted because the truth hurts.
And the wrongness, don't forget the wrongness.
I don't deny that there are shills around, but I'm sure most them do it for free.
That defeats the point of being a shill.
Yeah, I'm getting ripped off here.
yea zionistshill has been working for free for years now
If I am going to do it you better believe I am going to get paid
It's always comedy gold watching these dolts get their asses handed to them as soon as talking points meet cold, hard facts. They may be wading into social media, but they have no clue whatsoever about how to navigate it. The whole Vic Teows fiasco just served to illustrate how inept they are when it comes to the Internet in general.
no shit
The government should have to disclose the screen-names of their propaganda agents.
Uploaded on 9 Mar 2011
thanks for keeping it current
I'm sure they have stopped by now.
Now I know that every single person that opposes the seal hunt on the internet is a paid internet agent. Thanks!
Well that explains the subreddit that dares not speak its name.
Hahah this is all a joke and there's no way any of that is true, we are all just normal people with opinions and that's the bottom line.
Yep, good ole CTV National News, always with the jokes that involve contacting experts for live interviews...
[deleted]
Harper + sock puppet --> "Harppet"
r/metacanada has been saying this to everyone that will listen. Wake up, people!
No kidding.. it's not like we've kept it a secret. We openly admit we are shills and receive shill cheques for our efforts. It's pretty simple people.
Not a bad way to make a living either.
r/metacanada is pro-Harper wtf are u talking about!?
Actually, its more "anti ridiculous stuff in r/canada" which tends to be anti harper in general(but not always)
[deleted]
it is right now. And frankly, r/canada seems to be going the same way, Spence is extremely mockable now.
Funny cause anytime I go there they are calling natives lazy, leftists "faggots" and anyone who actually gives a damn about Canada and wants a better future for their friends and family just get the "lulz".
Its a bunch of high schoolers with no idea about the world, laughing at people who want things to be better, even for their dumb asses.
I think you will find that on any of the circlejerk/meta subreddits. ike all the posts about ridiculous stuff from r/atheism that get posted to r/circlejerk, doesnt mean everyone in there is fundamentalist and anti atheist, if anything its the opposite.
Au contraire, I think you'd find the average age of an r/metacanada user to be much higher than that of an r/canada user.
[deleted]
You just described Post-Election r/Canada.
Upvoted because you could be more wrong.
You sir, deserve 9000 karma for your bravery!
[deleted]
funny how 9 times out of 10 on reddit (in r/canada in particular), it's the person on the "left" calling you a faggot. Weird.
[deleted]
Of course it is. Read the threads, you'll see people talking about receiving shill cheques and what not. It's not even a secret.
Not really. The posters of r/metacanada are mostly just people sick of the shit that happens here in r/canada and post about how ridiculous some of the comments are.
[deleted]
You are banned from posting in r/metacanada