r/cybersecurity•
EpicBot

Thoughts about reporting SPA as Broken access control

Business Security Questions & Discussion

I read the rules. Please let me know if there is a better place to have this discussion.
I recently received a pen testing report for an SPA (Single Page Application) with only one major vulnerability reported, with a CVSS of 8.1.
The reported issue is classified as "Broken access control".
In this deficiency, they report that by patching the client-side authentication logic in the SPA or using a proxy and modifying the authentication response from the server.
They then can access pages in the SPA, which are supposed to be behind authentication. They note that none of the API calls returns any data, and they all return status code 401, which will cause the SPA to reload. If they prevent the SPA from reloading on a 401, they can see "empty" pages.
What I mean with empty pages is:
Empty HTML tables with headers but no data in the table.
Blank HTML forms without labels and data.
I think this is a non-issue, as the javascript source file sent to a browser loading the application already contains all these pages and API endpoints in the source code.
No secrets are stored in the javascript source code, and no user data.
Every API call gets checked for Authentication and Authorization. They note in the report they cannot find any deficiencies in the backend authentication.
I believe this doesn't warrant a CVSS of 8.1 or is even "Broken access control".
What do you think?

Posted Sep 5, 2023, 3:45 PM UTC

12
Loading comments…