Left company, 401k automatically rolled over into a Traditional IRA - will this affect backdoor Roth in the future?

Retirement

I have about $7k in a Traditional IRA with Vanguard.

Earlier this year I left a company where I had about $100k in a 401k. That money automatically rolled over into a Traditional IRA with another investment management firm.

If I want to do a backdoor Roth in the future, how will this affect my ability to contribute?

Posted Sep 6, 2023, 12:11 PM UTC

110
Lewhoo​•

I believe so yes. You’ll be subject to the pro rata rule. I’m in a similar situation and struggling myself to understand it so I can backdoor properly.

Some companies all for “reverse rollovers” of your tIRA into your new 401k plan so maybe that would be of help? Otherwise, I think you’re subject to pro rata.

1
NewChameleon​•

the easiest way I've found to understand pro-rata is you must ensure your tIRA is $0

if your tIRA has no money then you're safe from pro-rata rule

1
Lewhoo​•

Thanks but that doesn’t help OP or I at all since we both have funds in our tIRA.

1
NewChameleon​•

then empty it

1
Lewhoo​•

One doesn’t just empty a tIRA without tax implications and penalties.

If you don’t bother to comprehend the question please don’t comment.

1
bulldg4life​•

You’ll be subject to pro rata rule when doing the conversion step. It will most likely make it not financially sound to perform the steps.

Did you move to a new job that also has a 401k? Do they allow reverse rollovers where you can move the $107k to the new company 401k?

1
SmashBustersOP​•

No, I am now a contractor at a company with no 401k.

If I eventually move to a company with a 401k will a reverse rollover be a potential option?

1
usefully_useless​•

If I eventually move to a company with a 401k will a reverse rollover be a potential option?

Yes.

1
NewChameleon​•

pro-rata rule says you will have tax bills if you do not empty your tIRA (well, legally speaking it's end-of-year, so Dec 31 but same point)

so essentially you have 3 options:

  1. tIRA -> rIRA and eat a huge tax bill, this will empty your tIRA but I highly do not recommend this

  2. tIRA -> t401k, not all company's 401k plan allows this

  3. do not do backdoor Roth

1
Lewhoo​•

Thanks but that doesn’t help OP or I at all since we both have funds in our tIRA.

1