First in-person TB Storytelling: 1 in 4 outsiders are real

I ran my first game of TB in person tonight (I've storytold online and played in person before). Of the nine players, we had a Spy claiming Recluse, Imp claiming Saint, Librarian claiming to have seen a Drunk and the only real outsider was the Butler.

I'd had the librarian see a drunk between empath and spy. Gave the Imp a bluff of Saint (which they took), and the Spy decided to take the claim of recluse (because they'd been seen by investigator). Of course, I'd built the game around the sole outsider being a butler because no-one would expect me to do that.

Town was convinced of a baron world. Final 3 had the librarian, the Imp-claiming-Saint, and a soldier, and Evil got their demon off the block by getting five votes on the SOLDIER of all people!