Will I improve my odds of obtaining a favorable outcome by hiring an equally qualified Attorney with the same gender and/or race as my assigned judge?

Recent research on baseball umpires showed that players with races that matched the umpire received slightly more favorable calls (source: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1318858 - which makes a strong case for robotic umpiring).

Has any similar research been done on if attorneys are more likely to receive favorable outcomes when their gender/race matches the judge?

If this is the case, how much more likely would I be to receive a favorable early outcome (e.g. granted summary judgments, granted initial motions to dismiss) by making that selection?

Posted Sep 9, 2023, 10:56 AM UTC

12
Fluxcapacitar•

It would be pretty impossible to quantify that considering how many different areas of law there are and how much cases deal without the court system.

If you are black, there are plenty of studies about how the criminal system hits you harder. Civilly? Not sure it makes a difference. Chances are your judge is a white male and statistically so will your attorney.

1
ZealousidealHeron4•

If this is true, how much more likely would I be to receive a favorable early outcome (e.g. granted summary judgments, granted initial motions to dismiss) by making that selection?

I would note that the abstract to the paper you linked would indicate that were the exact same phenomenon observed, this wouldn't happen:

This effect only exists where there is little scrutiny of umpires' behavior - in ballparks without computerized systems monitoring umpires' calls, at poorly attended games, and when the called pitch cannot determine the outcome of the at-bat.

1