Tom Curry to find out suspension fate for Argentina red card on Tuesday
oxfordmail.co.uk/sport/national/23779841.tom-...Posted Sep 10, 2023, 2:39 PM UTC
Posted Sep 10, 2023, 2:39 PM UTC
He really shouldn't get a ban for that. I hope there is a way to mitigate out of it
I think the way the England legal team would argue it is that Curry is stationary and braced for the tackle and most of the force in the head clash comes from the jumping players momentum.
Why ?
Because what the hell was he supposed to do in that situation? Banning him seems insane for essentially an accidental collision
They’re trying to protect players. The whole point of the ban is to stop players from putting themselves in these sort of positions that put vulnerable players at risk.
Curry wasn’t trying to catch the ball, he was trying to hammer the Pumas player as soon as he landed. He got his timing wrong, and was too uptight in the tackle. It wasn’t intentional or malicious but it was reckless and poor technique.
What was he supposed to do in that situation? The guy jumped into him, he was almost stationary. Have you ever tried to stop running and then done so in a crouching (bent at the hips) position?
Look, I get what they are trying to do, but sometimes collisions happen. We cannot control every single thing.
All I'm saying is he doesn't deserve a ban, that's all. It's not that controversial.
Even though I agree that Curry was unlucky more than malicious, the answer from World Rugby is “don’t have your head there”. He was too upright as the player landed. Had he lowered his body and their heads still clashed, he would get some mitigation.
It's not always possible to plan for something like that. It's a split second situation. Next time you go for a run, try to slow down by bending your hips and crouching forward
Why should he not get a ban? It’s a clearly illegal tackle under the laws.
Because he was basically jumped into. So he was supposed to anticipate that, crouch down etc while at the same time trying to slow down? It's impossible sometimes. He doesn't deserve a ban
He leaves him alone until he can make a legal tackle. Under the laws it’s the tacklers responsibility to make a safe tackle.
The guy jumped into him. Even if he tried to hold back he can't teleport to another place
I don't expect it will be a long ban. 1 or 2 matches at most. It wasn't malicious.
Mandatory mid range for head contact is 3 matches.
Mitigated with tackles school to 2 weeks
Yep 👍
This is the exact ban he’ll get.
3 week's, halved for no record, minus 1 week for good conduct.
He's getting a week.
Unless the committee goes mad again for (2/3rds have form)
No. It's 6 weeks mandatory mid range halved to 3 for no record.
Then minus one week, so 2 weeks.
Frankly I'd suspend Englands tackle coach right now - clearly not doing their job right
No. 6 weeks with the maximum 50% discount to 3 in the hearing. The third week can be replaced with tackle school so effectively 2 weeks.
Bullshit red. Yellow at the most, this doesn't even feel earned as someone who hates England.
You know you don’t have to say you hate us every time you mention us.
But it's how we get off.
That's a bit sad for you but there's medication for that.
Is it England you hate or just English people? England is a beautiful country
Yes.
Hmm. I thought so.
Like most Anglophobes, he just believes what his parents tell him with no personal life experience to back it up.
Yeah it goes without saying everyone hates England! 😂
No need to pretend simply because you're worried about Kriel.
Surely the English KC just needs to point to the Chilean YC today and point out that Curry's was no different.
It was different however
In what way?
IMO both were rugby collisions and shouldn't even have been YCs.
Tom curry going forward towards the Argentina player, head content initially, and upright tackling
The Chile player was going backwards away from the player, and got pulled in, and initially it was a Japan shoulder to Chile chest contact before the head contact
Tom Curry's tackle was a lot more dominant than the Chile collision
Ok well we can just show the South African tackle on Dempsey then. And that 1 isn’t even a yellow. The rules and refs have no consistency whatsoever
2 aussies on the panel = red card rescinded.
Hopefully the panel just apologises and no ban follows.
This is a bit rough, I think a red was harsh. Technically, I get it, still harsh.
I think both teams should have received a team red for the worst game of the opening round. Fairs fair.
Yet kriel will get nothing
[removed]
He’ll be cited.
Highly doubt it. Considering his red card in the JRLO semi that should mean he’s out for the tournament if he is so they won’t do anything.
What has that got to do with him not being cited? Are you implying corruption or something else?
Just compare the controversy Farrells tackle garnered. This is easier to ignore as you don’t have the same fake indignation. World Rugby is reactionary to the loudest noises. Not corruption just incompetence, linked to avoiding controversy. Under a scenario where they were competent we wouldn’t even be having a conversation about sanctioning.
It wasn't malicious. Move on.
Will be reduced to 2 weeks
I think there should be a round up of all decisions made this weekend and a review taken of what happens will all incidents rather than individual panels for each thing. So comparing the curry one with the Chile Japan one and seeing if they are comparable enough and issue the same sanction or if not issue a statement about why they are separate and what the individual sanctions are. Essentially a unified World Rugby review with consistency applied rather than a media circus in the week and individual panels making individual decions applied inconsistently.
Good idea
Angus Ta'avao red card vs Ireland last year feels comparable to this.
Accidental but a 3 week suspension in 2022, felt a bit harsh at the time.
Compulsory tackle school for 3 weeks. Alumni's reference letter reduce it to 2 weeks.
Rules are stupid-nobody watching could comprehend how an accidental head clash is a red card, while a deliberate jumping butt to the head is a yellow. Why are they trying to pansify Rugby? If you are that worried about head trauma then make head protection compulsory instead.
Look at the Scotland vs SAF game yesterday- fun little brawl & then the players stopped & made up themselves, then the ref decides to come & give them some big lecture for something they sorted out on their own-what next? Making it a non-contact sport?
Two panelists with PTSD from the Farrell fallout. 0 chance of a fair hearing.
Im not sure how the committee is decided, but it does seem like having them involved is going to create additional and unnecessary media circus that perhaps would have been better off avoided.
An England fan worrying about fairness in world rugby institutions, hilarious.
You'll be fine. Not that he'd deserve a long ban in this case though.