Buying the warranty within the first 36mo

Buying Advice

With great advice from all of you I declined the warranty when I bought my car yesterday. However, the finance man said if I waited I would be charged more because the car would be considered used. I can’t find any supporting documentation for what he said. I felt like it was a sales tactic and I challenged him. He doubled down. I still declined. Has anyone ever heard of this rate increase if you don’t buy at the time of the sale?

Posted Sep 15, 2023, 1:33 PM UTC

131
MiniMarsRover•

You can add the Subaru extended warranty anytime before your original warranty ends. You don't have to go to the original dealer where you bought the car, and you can shop around to see what different dealers are charging. If I remember correctly, the "top" plan should cost about $2500. It's probably increased a bit since the last time I saw that information.

I do recommend the warranty if you plan to keep the car long term, unless you're fortunate enough to have a substantial repair fund that you'll be able to replenish. Repairs can become expensive, so I genuinely recommend the warranty for anyone who isn't financially able to manage a surprise repair bill.

1
AddictiveTVOP•

I’m going to buy the warranty. I don’t drive a lot and plan to keep the car 10+ years so I’m interested in the 10 year plan. I just didn’t want to buy it yesterday. I actually had to tell him there was a 10 year plan and he argued with me there wasn’t. He finally looked it up and then apologized.

It seemed he was more interested in getting the sale than anything else. Desperation is a poor trait in a salesperson.

I’m going to email some dealers in my state and get some offers.

1
MiniMarsRover•

There's a really good post somewhere in this subreddit about the Subaru warranty. I'm on mobile (and am supposed to be working) so I don't have easy access to the search features, but check the wiki and any pinned posts.

1
AddictiveTVOP•

Thank you. I’ll look for the post.

1
Rick919812023 Legacy Touring XT•

I believe this is the post he's referring to: https://www.reddit.com/r/SubaruAscent/comments/vs5gxc/subaru_pricing_and_warranty_faq/

u/MiniMarsRover the post is pinned on r/subaruascent if you ever need to find it easily

1
sleepdog-c•

On our 23 I googled the price of the warranty and told them either I buy it at the non marked up price or I'll buy it from another dealer. But, I like being able to roll it into the financing if you finance. We paid outright this time so it didn't make much difference other than we have it from mile 1

1
AddictiveTVOP•

I plan on buying the warranty before the 3yr/36k miles but for me it all comes down to honesty and I felt like I was being misled. I was going to pay cash because I don’t want to pay finance charges on the warranty.

1
sleepdog-c•

I didn't see your last post so I don't know what they were misleading you on. Not sure what you are paying in interest but usually on a 3 year, for me, it was $500 or less in total finance costs so 2k additional would have been a few dollars more in interest. We've paid cash for the last 2 subies we've bought so we justin get them to give us the warranty at cost.

1
AddictiveTVOP•

They were asking 4130 for the 10yr/100k mile plan.

1
sleepdog-c•

First googlable result today

https://www.newmotorssubaru.com/added-security-extended-warranty-pricing.htm

Subaru allows the dealers to charge whatever they want as long as subaru gets this much

1
Rick919812023 Legacy Touring XT•

That's twice what you should pay

1
Rick919812023 Legacy Touring XT•

Common lie from the finance guy. They want to pressure you into buying from them for an overpriced amount. You have until right before the 3/36 expires. It will not be more expensive (unless Subaru raises rates as a whole, which they do every few years).

1
Fluid_Breath_7800•

I got the 10 year/100k/100 deductable for $1900. Call various dealerships in your area and ask for a quote from each.

1