Actually OK with ENM

NSFW

Hey all! I’ve (M36) recently decided after a year of trying ENM with my partner (F36) that I no longer feel comfortable talking about her sexual encounters with separate play partners.

I know it’s fairly common to not want to know details but I’m uncomfortable hearing she even had a date. And I definitely don’t want to hear details of their sex. But why? If it makes me uncomfortable to hear those things then is this really for me? I don’t think I mind in general that she sees other people, as long I never hear about it, but it got me thinking about a philosophical question.

Am I actually ok with ENM if I never want to hear anything about my partner and their play partners? Is that healthy?

Posted Sep 22, 2023, 2:00 PM UTC

135
DaddyEvergreenTree•

I’d say that if you trust your partner to make safe choices in areas that you don’t have visibility into, and you can let them have the freedom to make those choices and enjoy themselves, then you are OK with ENM.

I suspect some purists might suggest that you’re on a lower level of ENM by not being open to knowing any details, but I don’t think that matters.

Although, one thing does jump out at me on a second reading. You said you think you don’t mind in general that she sees other people. I’d advise you to search your feelings and really find out whether you mind or not.

1
JimJam_Kin•

Great response here. I feel and do the same. I trust my partners to be safe since they are adults so I don't think knowing the details matters either.

3
PitifulDraft433OP•

Thank you so much for your response! I guess to clarify, I only say I think I’m ok with it because I needed some answers from this post. Yours has made me feel a little more at ease. I truly don’t mind if she does have other partners it just seems weird to have a sexual part of our relationship I’m not comfortable discussing. It feels like a secret.

But I have a consultation with an ENM therapist today so hopefully I can get some clarity on my on emotions surrounding this through that as well. I do intend to try to get to a point where I can hear about her dates again and be supportive

1
DaddyEvergreenTree•

What is it that you think you or her might be missing out on due to your boundary of not wanting to know about things?

1
PitifulDraft433OP•

That major part of her life

1
boredwithopinions•

Can you define the discomfort you're feeling when hearing she simply has a date? Because the dit says you won't be upset so I'm trying to understand.

There is a world of difference between simply not caring and actively not wanting to know. I've been in a relationship where we each did our own thing with no communication. It worked fine. But there were no rules saying we couldn't discuss, we just felt no need.

1
PitifulDraft433OP•

Makes me feel icky? Like, I’m not gonna die and it won’t cause a fight, but I’d just rather not know for now till I can get a better handle on it through therapy.

1
Justadudefromnz•

So you and your partner live together. If so do you think that this may create an unhealthy dynamic in your relationship. That is. Your partner will now be forced to lie to you if she’s going out on a date at night leaving you at home. Lying in a relationship is never a good thing and would likely make her feel very uncomfortable as well.

1
PitifulDraft433OP•

No, not yet. That is the plan in a year. We are taking this time to do therapy and get ready for that transition.

I don’t believe she has to lie. Just if she doesn’t have to, don’t let me know she has a date. She has a buddy system with a friend for safety. If I want to make a plan to see her (she lives in another city so we only see each other once a week) then she can just tell me she has plans and let’s try another night. If that’s lying through omission then I guess it is. But I don’t feel that way.

And this is not a permanent solution. Just until I can get a better handle on my feelings around this in therapy. I would like to eventually get to a point of being able to talk about her feelings surrounding her other partners, I’m just not there right now.

Do you have any thoughts on the posted question?

1
Justadudefromnz•

Ok your living situation will obviously make your arrangement easier for your both.

Is this healthy? My view is that I don’t consider DADT arrangements to be healthy ones at all. But then that is simply my view.

1
PitifulDraft433OP•

Yeah. And I guess that’s what I’m trying to get to the bottom of. If I don’t like hearing about my partner having sex with other men without me, does that mean I don’t like ENM?

1
Justadudefromnz•

Probably not in my view. I mean it’s perfectly normal in ENM relationships to not want to hear any details about the other partners dates. But not wanting to know that they are even going on a date or been on a date at all suggests that you aren’t really ready for an ENM relationship

1
mrjim2022•

Many go along with a NM relationship fearing their partner will leave them if they don't go along.

You hear the phrase - "Don't set yourself on fire to keep someone else warm" which aptly describes the situation.

Books, therapy, podcasts, and self-introspection may get you to a place of comfort with nm relationships, but it is not a sure thing and in my view not a failure if you simply are not "wired" for this relationship style.

1
2Have15min•

This is what i was wondering.. the proximity means either she lies about why shes getting all dolled up <presumbaly> Or hes gonna know without her saying a thing.

1
Charming-Sir6557•

Nobody wants to hear that, even more if yourself isn't getting any dates to make it worse. Find someone that you can have sex with since that's the reason why people open at the end

1
PitifulDraft433OP•

Thanks for the advice. I’ve been trying to find other people to have sex with but it is proving difficult.

1
al3ch316•

That's totally fine, OP; lots of people would rather not hear about a partner's exploits with others.........especially if they're also struggling in finding their own partners. I'm interested in knowing my wife is saying and sticking to our core agreements, but other than that, the less I know about her dates, the better it is for both of us.

1
PitifulDraft433OP•

Thank you for the response. I love her dearly and want to make sure we are compatible long term so this eases my anxiety.

1
SuddenSando•

ENM is a big tent. My wife and I are poly, so we are ENM, but I don't want to know any of the intimate details of her other relationship(s). I'm perfectly happy to set that boundary for myself. It was an adjustment for her to not tell me about that part of her life, but she respects my boundary and does her best to keep those details private.

I also have a girlfriend. She's mono, but if she decides to date I would set the same boundary. Do your thing and let me know if the STI risk profile has changed, but other than that I don't want to know details. Just not my thing.

1
PitifulDraft433OP•

Thanks for the feedback. I love your reasons for starting enm. Those are admirable goals. I’ll admit, I just kinda said what hell. I’ve wanted to check it out for a while.

1
LaughingIshikawa•

Per your edits: it matters a lot if this is about hearing her talk about dates with one specific person you really dislike, versus dates in general. Also, I'm unclear on whether or not it's actively a negative experience for you, or just one you don't care about much either way. To be frank about it, it sounds like you are a person who is trying to rationalize your way towards being "ok" with it even though you really aren't, but that's just my impression FWIW.

Personally I am neither excited, nor repulsed at hearing about a partner's dates. I think that's the most ideal and also most common attitude.

It's hard if you're actively resentful of a partner going on dates; being excited to hear about dates is a little easier, but can lead to problems if someone doesn't respect basic privacy boundaries. I like to hear about what my partner is up to in general, and dates are just a part of that - it's not much different than them telling me about having seen friends and family. It's all social events they went to with people who weren't me... that's about it 🙃.

If your partner has a partner Aspen who just... really rubs you the wrong way, but you're fine hearing about days with other partners, that's a little different. Same with things like being overwhelmed by how much your partner wants to gush about a new connection. Anything where not wanting to hear about other partners is the exception rather than the rule, basically.

1
PitifulDraft433OP•

I’m definitely not resentful of my partner. I want her to be happy and to have the experiences she likes. I didn’t like the one guy she was seeing but I loved the other guy and we have a threesome planned. Not sure what kind of wrench that throws into your figuring.

I’m finding out it’s pretty common not to really want to hear about that part of your partner’s life of it makes you uncomfortable to think about them having sexual with someone else.

It comes down to a philosophical question for me. If I don’t like thinking about my partner having sex with other people who I know personally, does that mean enm isn’t for me? We love fantasizing together but that’s different. Does youhave to be ok with hearing the sexual details or even knowing a partner is on a date if overall I’m fine with her seeing g other people?

And the fact that you don’t care about who your partner has sex with is great. I don’t either. I just don’t really need to know about it for now. That may change and we hold space for each other for those changes of heart.

1
DutchElmWife•

I am 100% A-OK with my teenaged daughters (off at college) having sex with their boyfriends, but I do NOT need to hear the details!

I think it is absolutely normal and fine if you don't want to hear the details of anyone else's sex lives.

Just knowing that she's going out with someone else, though, is a bit trickier, since it borders on DADT, which is a "tell" for your discomfort level with ENM at all.

On the other hand, if that's where you are -- that's okay too. And if it's about FOMO, or feeling jealous (not of the partners, but of her opportunities compared to yours), that's normal too.

1
PitifulDraft433OP•

Thank you for your thoughtful response. If I know she’s going on a play date, then I’m going to think about the sex they have. It’s like someone saying, dont think of a purple horse. How do people do the mental gymnastics necessary to not go there in their brain?

1
DutchElmWife•

Plenty of people move to a plausible-deniability system. "I'm going out tonight" or putting "busy" in the shared calendar. They also say and do this for all of their non-sex dates (drinks with the girls, pottery class, gym time), so it creates a wash of "none of my business" privacy wrt personal time.

It's less DADT and more "I'm on a need-to-know basis," which is a subtle but perhaps helpful distinction.

1
PitifulDraft433OP•

Thank you. That’s very helpful!

1
mrjim2022•

Many in the nm community will tell you that sex is nothing too special, no different than a tennis date.

I believe them, but if you are not "wired" this way it is difficult to process.

1
Sprinklefux•

It's healthy as long as you are whole-heartedly consenting to it.

I personally would not want a "don't ask don't tell" policy for basically the same reasons your speaking about. I would assume that if my partner couldn't handle hearing about it, then it's not as ok as I'd like it to be and that's more conflict than I want to deal with in a relationship.
But you get to define your own relationship, so if you feel like you're ok with it, then you're ok with it.

1
PitifulDraft433OP•

Thank you!

1
Sprinklefux•

I think you have a really good question there, and it's one you have to find your own answer to. I don't think there are any hard rules about what's "healthy".

By whole heartedly, I mean, do you really want to do it, even with the occasionally difficult feelings that come up.
It's just what you want to experience and what you don't. If you understand that parts of the dynamic will be challenging for you and you want to do it anyway, then you are whole-hearted. The fact that there are parts of it you don't love doesn't detract from that decision - for example, I wholeheartedly love my dog and am happy to have him in my life, even though I hate walking him when it's cold out and picking up his poop. It's not perfect all the time, but I am resolved that I definitely want to keep him.
It's also totally valid to decide that those feelings are too much and you don't want to have a relationship style that challenges you in that way.

1

So it sounds like you are at least somewhat genuinely interested in ENM. It also sounds like you have a lot of anxiety which is making it extra difficult for you to know when she is on a date or what was sexually done. This doesn't make you less poly, it does however mean you probs need to do some extra work towards working through those feelings. There very much could be an aspect of jealousy, but from the way I'm reading your post and comments, I think your anxiety and paraonoia to a degree is what is making this so difficult for you. And then your anxiety is making it even worse by saying well if I feel that way do I really like polyamory?

​

I think you need to focus on self-soothing and coming up with coping skills. Work with a therapist. I have a very similar issue. I legitamitely have no issue with and am happy with my partners having other partners, however, especially if I'm hanging out alone, knowing that they are on a date and that sex might happen just makes my brain reel. It's not really jealousy and like you said just mostly FOMO. In this instance, you just need to help get your brain to look beyond the FOMO so it stops getting activated into fight or flight/dysregulated.

​

It is totally valid for this to be where you are. I would even say with time, and coping skills, it is def very possible for you to be more comfortable with some of this stuff in the future. Anxiety is a *bad word*, polyamory unfortunately happens to be a relationship style where anxiety makes its extra hard, doesn't mean you can't get past it, just takes a bit more work.

1
mrjim2022•

DADT is used because knowing your partner is with another is indeed upsetting to many. You seem to feel shame about this. The idea that if you don't know about it, it cannot cause you grief is understandable.

Many in the nm community will say you "need to do the work" to come to grips with your discomfort(likely jealousy) around your partner's sexual encounters with others. This is a complicated emotional process that often fails(but generates a lot of book sales)!

The frequent mismatch between men and women finding outside partners further complicates and already emotionally tricky dance for many of us.

My guess is you may not be too comfortable with NM relationships, whether you can get there is an open question and only you know how it actually makes you feel.

1