Charlotte will not become mistress of Longbourne if...

...the "olive branch" she is expecting at the end, along with any subsequent olive branch, is a girl and Mr Collins dies before Mr Bennet. People commonly die at all ages at this point in time, so the latter could very possibly happen, as could the former. If this happens, the lawyers will move onto the next male cousin, assuming there is one somewhere.

I don't think Austen intends for us to find this outcome desirable. Charlotte doesn't deserve to be faced with poverty and neither do her hypothetical daughters. But I've always disliked Lady Lucas for her greedly calculations as to how long Mr Bennet is likely to live, and though I think we're meant to forgive her for it (of course she wants security for her daughter) and see her good qualities (reaching out to the Bennets during Lydia's scandal), I'm not above feeling smug at the prospect of her seeing the possibility I've floated become reality. Yes, I'd probably be a better person if it wasn't so.

Posted Sep 24, 2023, 4:30 PM UTC

167
FeelingDepth2594•

I've never read Lady Lucas visiting at the time of the scandal as caring. I always assumed it was a nosy neighbor who wants first crack at any juicy gossip.

1
Reliant20OP•

That's fair. Maybe since I'm wishing ruin on her daughter, I feel the need to be kind in other ways:)

1
kit-kat_kitty•

Here's my q, why are you wishing ruin on her?

Charlotte isn't meant to be a villain.

1
Reliant20OP•

I'm not actually wishing ruin on her. Like I said, part of me would want Lady Lucas to see her daughter fail to become mistress of Longbourne after her calculation as to how many years Mr Bennet might live, which has always struck me as her hoping on whatever level he doesn't live too long.

1
OrindaSarnia•

You seem to have some issue separating the facts of life from the personal morals of the characters.

Austin isn't always attempting to critique the character, she is most often critiquing the societal circumstances that the characters find themselves in.

Lady Lucas is commenting on a fact of life. Mr Bennet is most likely to die before Mr Collins, and because of the ridiculous nature of the entail, that then means Mr Collins will get Longbourne, which happens to be to the benefit of her daughter.

The point is not to bring attention to Lady Lucas as a character with moral failings for thinking about someone else's inevitable death... the point is to again draw attention to the absurdity of the law that makes the entail work that way.

You are not supposed to be rooting for the absurdity of the entail to later enact karma on characters you think deserve it (Lady Lucas being unhappy if Charlotte has daughters) you are supposed to be thinking about how the entail itself is ridiculous and should not exist as a legal principal, at all.

1
Waitingforadragonof Mansfield Park•

I can't really blame Lady Lucas for her feelings. As a family, they don't have a lot to offer to Charlotte as she gets older, especially as they have so many other children. So I can understand why Lady Lucas is so happy to have Charlotte get married to someone with good prospects. Plus, it means that Charlotte will likely one day move back to the area with any potential grandchildren, which is a huge plus for her.

Also, she isn't a scheming woman. She does nothing to promote the match between Charlotte and Mr Collins. Charlotte does all of that. So it's not like she planned it, from her perspective, it just happened.

In a scenario where Charlotte finds herself a widow, either alone or with daughters, I'm not sure she'd be in poverty. Yes, she would lose her home and her husbands income, and she would also be excluded from inheriting Longbourn. But I imagine that Mr Collins has some property or money of his own, that he got from his father. They must have had a decent income to be able to send Mr Collins to University and into the Church. And as far as we know, there are no entails there, to stop her inheriting Mr Collins's personal property. It's just that Longbourn is the plumb.

1
Reliant20OP•

I think that's all solid reasoning, but we're told that the Collinses can't afford to socialize or travel much, which makes me think Mr Collins doesn't have many other resources beyond his rector's pay. I imagine it's a situation like the Bennets: there'll be money when Charlotte's a widow that your average person at this point in time would regard as a fortune, but that would mean a very poor way of life by these characters' standards.

1
CallidoraBlack•

The good news is that Lizzie would never let Charlotte struggle that way. She'll be living in a separate house on the property with any children she might have and they'll play with any little Darcys daily.

1
katygglsof Northanger Abbey•

Huh? Charlotte's motives for marrying Mr. Collins were 100% self interested. She didn't do it to "protect" the Bennet family. Protect them from what? Mr. Collins being out of sorts until he went away? Mrs. Bennet's tantrums, which she had every other week about something or the other anyways? She married Mr. Collins because she saw a chance to provide a comfortable life for herself, and that's it. I don't blame her for that, but it wasn't done to benefit any other person besides Charlotte.

1
CallidoraBlack•

Well, I guess I totally misunderstood everything then. I thought part of it was that Mr. Collins would be less likely to put the girls out with nothing if his wife was there to put her foot down. Better that someone who would try to help them marry him than a stranger. Much like young Mr. Dashwood might have made some genuine effort to help his stepmother and sisters if he had married someone who wasn't awful. But maybe I misunderstood that too?

1
davis_away•

He's also only just started his career, and part of the reading he sucks up to Lady Catherine is that she can give him additional church positions.

1
Cayke_Cooky•

I expect Charlotte is well aware of the risks and is working to save money.

1

And to keep her husband on Mr. Darcy's good side for when the living once intended for Wickham falls vacant. He could then assign one to a curate but benefit from both.

Of course Lizzy would help her friend in this scenario.

1
Katharinemaddison•

Assuming Mr Collins settled that money on her/any daughters. Which he might have, Lady Catherine was quite pro women inheriting. But it wouldn’t be automatic and a wife’s inheritance was usually linked to how much dowry, and I don’t think she bought much with her.

Ironically Charlotte could be condemned to going through multiple pregnancies if she’s hit with a sequence of daughters like the Bennett’s were. And probably sucking up to Lady Catherine as much as possible just in case on the chance of being taken in as a dependent.

1
Lumpyproletarian•

I wonder if there were pensions or charitable provision for clergy widows.

1
Katharinemaddison•
1
Writerhowell•

Hence the Bates family living in genteel poverty.

1
enigmasaurus-•

He'd probably settle money on his daughters (in terms of saving a dowry for them).

A good living would typically be perhaps 300-500 a year, maybe pushing up to 600-700 a year if glebe land was well farmed. The Collinses income is described as not allowing for frequent journeys too, and their style of living well below the neighbourhood (so their income is less than most genteel families in the area; Lady Catherine pays them special attention because she is their patroness, and it's possible their other neighbours, such as lady Metcalfe and the Popes, are a bit snobby as it would generally be considered good breeding to socialise with the local clergy despite their often having a lower income). If we assume the Collinses have around 500 a year this sort of income should allow for saving decent dowries.

Mr. Gardiner (elder) likely had a similar income as a prominent tradesperson (attorney) and he was able to save 4000 for each of his daughters (Mrs. Phillips and Mrs. Bennet) and he likely have his son at least 3-4 times this in start up capital for his London business. (In fact this highlights just how negligent Mr. Bennet is as a father, as anyone on his income level should definitely have been able to put aside reasonable dowries for his daughters. Even the Morlands, with their ten children, have 3000 set aside for Catherine).

Mr. Collins seems like the sort who'd be financially responsible (and I'm sure Lady Catherine would have plenty of opinions on the necessity of supplying appropriate dowries and providing for future children). Society would also frown on someone who didn't save appropriately for future children.

He would be less likely to settle money on Charlotte however it's unlikely she doesn't have a dowry of at least 2000 herself. The average dowry in this social class was about 3000 pounds and the Lucases seem to be roughly as well off as the Bennets (Sir Lucas, using the money he acquired in trade, was able to purchase an estate and this should generate at least 1500 a year).

1
Basic_Bichetteof Lucas Lodge•

Highlighting this:

They must have had a decent income to be able to send Mr Collins to University and into the Church.

Not necessarily. There were actual classes of students, and the lowest class, the "servitors" (as they were called at Oxford), didn’t pay for their lodging, lectures, or most of their meals, but instead were expected to act as servants to the higher classes of students; they basically paid their way through menial service. Servitors quite often had their other meagre expenses paid either by their families, by the students they served, or by a patron - a local landowner or clergyman where they grew up, even a charity. It's even remotely possible that Mr. Bennet himself subsidized Collins; ten or twenty pounds a year would hardly break the bank.

Scholarship students at Oxford had to prove proficiency in Latin and Greek before entering, but other students only had to keep enough terms - spend enough time at the university - and before 1810 sit one fairly easy examination to earn a Bachelor of Arts degree. This is what Mr. Bennet is referring to, by the way; it was perfectly possible, at least at Oxford before 1810 (and he would have had to graduate before 1810 if he was ordained in 1811; a prospective priest would have to spend six months to a year serving as a deacon before his final ordination), to graduate without obtaining more than a basic education in Latin and Greek.

1
Waitingforadragonof Mansfield Park•

That's really interesting, I didn't know that.

I still think it shows a certain level of wealth though, because otherwise he would have had to go straight into a job of some sort, to contribute to the family.

1
Demon-DM0209•

That’s so interesting thank you.

1

He could have saved a lot of his income as a clergyman. Not saying he earned a lot but Rosings was a wealthier neighbourhood, surely his 'salary' as a clergyman was higher than other less well off areas. He was a single guy and given the ever-looming sermons of Lady Catherine, she might have made him save as well

1

Let's not forget Lady Catherine de Bourgh. A bit of schmoozing of her ladyship and Charlotte would find herself appointed the companion of Miss Anne de Bourgh. Not a bad option. And I'm sure Charlotte would be clever enough to secure such a position for herself.

1
OutrageousYak5868•

I never considered this before, but find this highly likely!

1
renska2•

But prob not if she had girl children. I don't think Charlotte would be considered suitable in that case.

1

but with children?

1
Rabid-tumbleweed•

Women died due to complications of childbirth, and children died of various causes in infancy/childhood, but Mr. Collins is a young, apparently healthy man. Now that he's survived to adulthood, he's not particularly likely to die anytime soon. Of course there's no guarantee he will father a son, but he likely has plenty of time to try.

1
ChiaKmcof Pemberley•

It’s a bit of a misnomer that people often died in the 17/1800’s. Mortality rates were lower due to the high rate of infant deaths, but actually if you survived being an infant you were likely to live into your 70’s (although shout out to women who could often die in childbirth…).

I think if Mr Colin’s died though, Charlotte would fall back on a brother. Charlotte sort the match and wanted it because she wanted a home of her own without having to rely on family, but there wasn’t an implication that she was destitute without the match. The issue for her was that she was 27 and so becoming less and less desirable and she wanted a home of her own and for her that was more important then actually loving her husband.

She was pragmatic rather than emotional. Many woman at the time were. She’s a contrast to Lizzie in that sense, who values emotions over being pragmatic. Arguably though, she makes a really good match. Mr Colin’s is a pain in the arse, but he isn’t going to beat her or abuse her. She finds solutions to avoid him, and seems very happy with her choice, even though we’re told that through Lizzies perspective, which would obviously hold her opinions.

1
Reliant20OP•

My contention that it was fairly common for people to die at all ages during the period in question comes from having studied a lot of upper class British Regency and Victorian family trees. Yes, Mr Collins will probably outlive Mr Bennet, but I think death was common enough among people in, say, their forties and fifties that the possibility that he won't can't be easily dismissed.

I certainly think Charlotte's family network would preserve her and any children from actual want, but we can assume she would be living in a very narrow way as a dependent and would be considered poor.

1
ChiaKmcof Pemberley•

It’s honestly a misnomer. I say this as someone who has studied UK history. By the time we meet Mr Colins in the book his life expectancy is well over 60. Here are some stats from the UK Government for you: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/lifeexpectancies/articles/howhaslifeexpectancychangedovertime/2015-09-09

As soon as someone hit the age of 5 their life expectancy went up massively.

These figures do not account for the poverty of someone living in inner city squalor in comparison to countryside living with much more space, less people to passion fatal illnesses and most essentially - access to clean uncontaminated water.

When Jane Austen was writing about Mr Colin’s I really doubt there was any intention from her for readers to believe he would die before Mr Bennet. Nor for them to care one way or the other if he had a son.

Mrs Bennet would have cared a lot less about losing Longbourne when Lizzie and Jane both married well. She knew that their sisters and her were forever more protected if Mr Bennet died. And that was really all she cared about.

Charlotte would have been considered poor in the same way that Jane Austen herself would have been considered poor. It was a hard life living as someone within the gentry without any money. She would have felt obliged to her brothers and seen as a sort of nanny to any children. But it is what it is in a sense. Unfortunately that’s the way society was at that time.

There isn’t any implication from the books that Mrs Lucas orchestrated Charlottes match. It very much seems to be her own doing and seeing an opportunity that she wanted and took.

1
Reliant20OP•

It’s honestly a misnomer. I say this as someone who has studied UK history. By the time we meet Mr Colins in the book his life expectancy is well over 60. Here are some stats from the UK Government for you:

But Jane Austen's brother James died in his fifties. Anna Lefroy's husband died at 38. Fanny Knight and her father both had multiple children die after childhood but before they were old. This was more common in the ninetheenth century.

When Jane Austen was writing about Mr Colin’s I really doubt there was any intention from her for readers to believe he would die before Mr Bennet. Nor for them to care one way or the other if he had a son.

I don't think she intended it either. I'm just floating something that could have happened.

Mrs Bennet would have cared a lot less about losing Longbourne when Lizzie and Jane both married well. She knew that their sisters and her were forever more protected if Mr Bennet died. And that was really all she cared about.

I agree, not that I don't think it would have been a wrench for her to give up her home and relative financial independence.

Charlotte would have been considered poor in the same way that Jane Austen herself would have been considered poor. It was a hard life living as someone within the gentry without any money. She would have felt obliged to her brothers and seen as a sort of nanny to any children. But it is what it is in a sense. Unfortunately that’s the way society was at that time.

I agree with this too.

There isn’t any implication from the books that Mrs Lucas orchestrated Charlottes match.

I haven't said anywhere that there was.

1
ChiaKmcof Pemberley•

I’m not going to argue with someone about life expectancy in the 1800’s when it’s really widely accepted in the academic world that people who lived to 5, especially men, would usually live to old age. (Usually being the word).

Jane’s brother dying is like me pointing out my Aunt died in her 30’s in the 2000’s. It’s a sad fact of life, but people do die before old age even now… it really wasn’t that much more common then it is today.

Women died of child birth, that was common. Men randomly dying wasn’t. Obviously more people died because they didn’t have antibiotics so common things we can cure now, were incurable then. But it wasn’t common and people weren’t often just dropping down dead. Especially if they had access to clean water and were rich and had a cushty life like Mr Colin’s.

The far more likely one to die is Charlotte in quest of having a son. So pray for her that her first born was a boy! 😊

1
Cayke_Cooky•

I thought the jump (another jump?) in life expectancy was if you made to ~15yo. A 5 yo still had some risk of contracting childhood diseases. And today we know that the risk of dying of Pediatric Shock can continue after age 5 (even if it is not as common for the older children, an EMT is still going for immediate transport to the closest hospital because they still will just quit living.)

1
renska2•

I had never heard of pediatric shock.

1
jquailJ36•

The thing is, yes, dying in your forties or fifties wasn't totally unheard of, at least not to the extent it is today. But it's just not probable, for Mr. Bennett or for Mr. Collins. Neither are in a position to be at risk from more common causes of premature deaths in men (accident or injury related to work.) Neither seems indulgent enough (or rich enough to be indulgent) in the lifestyle choices of the very wealthiest that could contribute to heart disease, complications from gout, or diabetes-related illnesses striking at a relatively young age. Definitely neither is in a position to pick up the sort of social disease that could well get Wickham in the end.

And even if Mr. Collins were to receive an unadulterated compliment from Lady Catherine and be in such paroxysms of joy he drops dead from the strain, IF they had a son, then the entail should pass to him. And we have no particular reason to think the odds are they won't have children or that they're worse than 50-50 for having girls.

I mean sure, it's possible in a fan fic sense that he gets run over by the stage the day after the book ends and Charlotte's left a widow, but it's also possible Mary changes her name and goes on the stage or Kitty chops off her hair and enlists in the regiment as a boy. Mr. Bennet could live to be 97.

1
bananalouise•

the sort of social disease that could well get Wickham in the end

I really worry about Lydia's long-term health. The last chapter, where their habits of living are sketched out, doesn't mention Wickham racking up thousands of pounds of debt while "enjoying himself in London or Bath," but it doesn't sound like he's there to listen to chamber music and drink tea, either.

1
RoseIsBadWolfof Everingham•

While you are totally right, there is always a much higher chance in the Regency of someone just dropping dead compared to today. A bad case of influenza, some tetnus, an infection, and you're done.

If today we have a 0.001 chance of dying on any given day, in the Regency they might have a 0.01 chance. (Made up statistics)

1
SofieTerleskaof Northanger Abbey•

Also, for the next fifteen or twenty years, Charlotte will be at much higher risk of early death than Mr. Collins -- although both are likely to live to see sixty, Charlotte will be undergoing childbirth at least once and probably several times. That isn't a risk Mr. Collins will ever have.

1
SeriousCow1999•

And Charlotte is beginning her childbearing years after 25...the chances of a problematic birth are higher after that age. It's far more likely Mr. Collins will be the widower and susceptible to a Mrs. Elton. Egads!

1
SofieTerleskaof Northanger Abbey•

Oh good heavens, I hope not -- those poor children! However, I can't imagine a widowed Mrs. Elton being approved of by Lady Catherine, so maybe she'll advise Mr. Collins not to propose and the world will be spared a terrifying union.

1
Cayke_Cooky•

Farming accidents for men, farming was very dangerous and severe injuries were not uncommon. Although not for the class of characters in JA, but the tenant farmers actually working the land.

1
World_in_my_eyesof Bath•

Unless something dire should happen, like a carriage accident or some suddenly fatal disease, Mr. Collins will likely outlive Mr. Bennet. I don’t particularly care for Lady Lucas either, but I wouldn’t wish hardship upon Charlotte, though marriage to the odious Mr. Collins would be hardship enough.

1
OkeyDokey654•

But if none of Charlotte’s children are male, she’ll still find herself in the same position as Mrs. Bennet - living in the house until her husband dies, and then seeing it go to another male relative.

1
World_in_my_eyesof Bath•

I’m aware. I was just addressing the Mr. Collins early death aspect of the post.

1
Reliant20OP•

I think it likely he will outlive Mr Bennet, but I've studied enough Regency and Victorian family trees to know that death was common enough among people of all ages to think the possibility is very real. People certainly lived to old age (most of Jane Austen's brothers), but they died younger in much greater numbers (her brother James, her nephew-in-law Benjamin Lefroy).

1
Wriothesley•

I don't understand why everyone is fighting your thought experiment over the likelihood or lack thereof that Collins might die before Mr. Bennett. I'm from a country with a high life expectancy, and both of my parents died in their early forties, along with two of their siblings, all of different natural causes. This stuff happens, perhaps not often, but often enough to consider the consequences.

1
EagleIcy5421•

There was a certain amount of income that came along with Longbourne, but the Bennett parents didn't bother to save anything.

Charlotte was smarter than that.

1
OkeyDokey654•

Yes, Charlotte would be smarter than the Bennets and would certainly save some money.

1

Can you elaborate more on this? 'certain amount of income that came along with Longbourne'? I thought it was established his 2k pounds a year income was all from his property

1
harmonicacaveof Northanger Abbey•

Mr. Collins and Mr. Bennet both sought early marriages, if I’m remembering correctly, which means Mr. Bennet is about 25 years older than Mr. Collins. Definitely possibility of Mr. Bennet outliving his younger cousin, but more difficult than I first thought because I expected they were closer in age.

If we’re looking at who’s the most likely to be murdered, though? Mr. Collins before anyone. 😭

1
SameOldSongs•

Charlotte saw a chance and she took it without hurting anyone else (no matter what Mrs. Bennet says) and I would hate it if she were punished for it.

In any case, if her husband were to die young, I can see her finding a way to remarry. Might be hard, but not impossible. Her standards aren't high (a man who could offer her a respectable home - it's not like she was playing the long game because her concerns were more immediate) and Charlotte might not be young our pretty but she's a woman of sense and good companion. Someone's bound to appreciate that.

1
IgniteCordaof Highbury•

In fairness, by that measure one should wish disgrace on both Jane and Lizzy to punish Mrs Bennet (?)

1
Goose_Trick•

I've always been curious about the entails. I've read different things about how they work. One said that entails would be created for a set amout of time like so many generations, then the final person would have the choice to stop it or create a new entail and that a new one was usually started due to family pressure to continue it

1
Reliant20OP•

I have very little idea how such things were set up. It would seem to make more sense if Mr Collins's name were Bennet. Then it would be clear he's a male-line descendent of whoever set up the entail. But clearly Austen thought it would be too confusing to have another Mr (and later Mrs) Bennet, and I think she is meticulous enough that it's perfectly realistic somehow for him to have a different surname from the estate-holder.

1
Goose_Trick•

Mr. Collins inheriting follows proper entail first male rules. What I ment by generation is more of the the entail would be passed down to say 4 males then be finished. So say Mr. Bennet's father, Mr. Bennet, Mr. Collins then the 4th being Mr. Collins first son. The son would be the 4th male so the entail would have met the legal requirements and be done. But to make sure the money stayed in the family the son would be pressureed to create a new entail ensuring the how many next generations wouldn't be able to sell the property

1
RitanFP•

By Austen's time, entails had to have a limit on generations. You could only have an entail that lasted through the living generations and "one unborn." Meaning that assuming our Mr. Bennet was not yet born, His grandfather could make the entail apply to Mr. B's father and (yet unborn) Mr. B. But given that Mr. C. is described as a distant relative, it is likely that the entail was created by an earlier ancestor.

1
IridescentShell•

The sins of the father will be visited upon the son. Awful philosophy.

You want Charlotte and her innocent daughters to live in abject poverty with no security, protection or happiness just because Lady Lucas made a passing comment? Sorry, I can’t get behind that whatsoever.

1
foolishle•

Entails were generally limited by a certain number of generations.

Mr Bennet states that if he were to have a son, that son would “break off the entail” and that A sufficient number of generations would have happened so that that son would have been able to cancel the entail and divide the estate and/or will it to anyone he liked.

The son was to join in cutting off the entail, as soon as he should be of age, and the widow and younger children would by that means be provided for.

This shows that Mr Bennet’s hypothetical son is not bound by the entail. If Mr Bennet’s son gave Mr Bennet permission to break up the estate, and Bennet would be able to split up the estate and provide for his daughters that way.

We see in Sense and Sensibility that the Old Man wills his estate to be passed on whole and complete to Henry Dashwood’s grandson, Harry. This means that although Henry inherits the estate, he is not able to pass any of it on to his daughters. When he dies the estate passes to John.

But John is likewise bound. He must leave the estate to Harry and any future daughters will be unable to inherit any part of Norland.

Harry is not bound by the entail. When Harry comes of age he can do what he likes with Norland and sell it or break it up or will it to a daughter or to be shared equally amongst his children.

This, I believe, is the situation we find ourselves in with Mr Collins. Mr Collins is the last generation of the entail and can do what he likes with Longbourn—including willing it to a daughter or some other relative.

1
RitanFP•

Exactly, Mr. Bennet needed the next tenant/heir in order to break the entail. He never had that much needed son.

Entails were limited by a certain number of generations - an entail could apply to living generations and one yet unborn. The reason that entails continued was due to the fact that the last inheritor often/usually signed a strict settlement extending the entail to the next generation. He did this to have an allowance and/or money with which to marry. It is likely that Mr. Bennet himself was the last inheritor of the entail and signed such a settlement to have the money to marry Miss Gardiner. He planned on having a son to break the entail. He did not. Ellie Dashwood has a very good video explaining this - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SPFeB2bOO-0&t=1049s.

1
foolishle•

Ooof. That would certainly make Mrs Bennet’s ranting about entails more justified.

“Oh! my dear," cried his wife, "I cannot bear to hear that mentioned. Pray do not talk of that odious man. I do think it is the hardest thing in the world, that your estate should be entailed away from your own children; and I am sure, if I had been you, I should have tried long ago to do something or other about it."

Jane and Elizabeth tried to explain to her the nature of an entail. They had often attempted to do it before, but it was a subject on which Mrs. Bennet was beyond the reach of reason, and she continued to rail bitterly against the cruelty of settling an estate away from a family of five daughters, in favour of a man whom nobody cared anything about.”

1
RitanFP•

Actually I think it's Mrs. B's comment in Chapter 23 that convinces me that he did sign the strict settlement entailing the estate away from the girls. "I never can be thankful, Mr. Bennet, for anything about the entail. How anyone could have the conscience to entail away an estate from one’s own daughters, I cannot understand; and all for the sake of Mr. Collins too!" It is so very specific to him and not to a previous ancestor. And he doesn't deny it! Modern audiences dismiss this as more of Mrs. B's ranting, but I think Austen's contemporary audience knew exactly what was going on.

1
MadamKitsune•

I can't really be angry about Lady Lucas' speculation. If her and Sir William had a suitabley aged eligable son willing to marry Mary or Kitty then no doubt Mrs Bennet would be mentally redecorating Lucas Lodge from the moment they became engaged and redesigning the entire house every time Sir William has so much as had a sniffle.

Plus whether Longbourne passes to Mr Collins or not, it doesn't change the outcome for Mrs Bennet. There's more than likely another distant Bennet or Collins cousin who has the occasional idle daydream of two particular misfortunes throwing some good fortune their way.

1
OutrageousYak5868•

I always took her speculation in more of an idle "frenemy" way. It didn't mean anything. It was just one factor of many realistic/real-life things she happened to think of, now that Charlotte was engaged to Mr Collins.

1

I always wondered this. If Charlotte is 27 already, and the Lucases had like 10 kids, surely a son already exists that's at least a teenager or almost an adult. No adult male Lucas child is mentioned besides a 10 year old whom Mrs. Bennet argues with, but there's a high possibility one exists. Always made me wonder why Mrs. Bennet never schemed for one of younger Bennet girls to marry a Lucas boy.

1
MadamKitsune•

There's no mention of any Lucas children between Charlotte and Mariah (who seems to be aged somewhere between Lydia and Lizzie) so it could be that their station in life didn't comfortably allow for a large family until Sir William was elevated to the peerage. It's also possible that Sir William and Lady Lucas either had difficulty conceiving again or suffered losses until things somehow righted themselves and they went on to safely have multiple children. It's not unheard of for some people to struggle for years, have one and then be able to fall pregnant at the drop of a hat or even adopt and suddenly find themselves pregnant.

1

Yeah, only 2 Lucas children are mentioned by name (and are adult). Rest are seen as a growing, young brood.

1
psychosis_inducing•

I don't think Charlotte married him to get Longbourn. I thought she just saw him as a good provider who wouldn't cheat or abuse her. And he in turn... well, Lady Catherine De Bourgh told him to get a wife, so he did.

1
Reliant20OP•

That's what I think also.

1

I agree. We're told that Charlotte's dream was to have her own "establishment," which is very pragmatic of her. I think she realized that hoping for anything beyond that wasn't likely to happen for someone in her position. She saw Mr. Collins for what he was, but she knew that he would be a devoted husband and in turn fortunate to have Lady Catherine as his patron. I used to belong to a Jane Austen reading group, and everyone agreed that Mary Bennet and Mr. Collins were really meant for each other, but she was a little young.

One of the sequels that I read has a widowed Mrs. Bennet moving in with her also-widowed sister, Mrs. Philips, in Meryton. They are known as "The Merry Widows," (of course), where they have parties and gossip to their hearts' content. I would imagine that Jane and Elizabeth both contribute to Mrs. Bennet's finances.

1
an_imperfect_lady•

Mr Collins won't die young unless he is suffocated while kissing Lady Catherine's behind.

1
istara•

Or if...

Mrs Bennett carks it and Mr Bennett marries Caroline Bingley and squires an heir with (put that one in your fanfic!)

Or Mr Bennett gets drunk and there's a "change baby" just before Mrs B hits menopause. (I'll pass on reading that erotica, thanks!)

1
OrindaSarnia•

(I'll pass on reading that erotica, thanks!)

If only you had not typed the idea out at all...

1
AliceMayZing•

I've been writing a fanfic based on this premise actually! As someone said, mortality rates were skewed by infant deaths, but still possible to die from a myriad of illnesses/accidents surely.

If Mr. Collins died, Charlotte would likely go back to live with her parents, and after their passing, a brother - if she didn't choose to remarry.

Entailments from what I found in my research weren't usually in perpetuity, they didn't last forever. Usually three or four generations according to some websites. So depending on how many generations the estate goes through, the entailment could be broken with Mr. Collins' death.

Entailments could also be broken by agreement, though it would be hard for Mr. Collins to agree were he dead.

The scenario I operate on is that there are no any other living male heirs, and thus the entailment is broken.

1

While there was a lot less in terms of medical advancements during this period, there’s really no solid reason to think that Mr. Collins won’t outlive Mr. Bennet.

He is a young and healthy man who doesn’t overindulge in unhealthy habits or risky behaviours. He doesn’t do physically taxing work beyond tending his own garden or walking to Rosings, which probably benefits his health more than damages it. While living at Rosings, he will likely have access to a good surgeon and apothecary which, while not a guarantee in light of a lot of medical knowledge and practices, would still benefit him in the case of illness. Sure, sickness and accidents happen, but those things are more likely to kill Mr. Bennet rather than his heir.

1
EagleIcy5421•

Charlotte wasn't in any danger of facing poverty once she was married to Mr. Collins.

1
RitanFP•

She was still in danger, albeit a lot less. If Mr. Collins died before inheriting Longbourn, Charlotte would have nothing. And even after inheriting, depending on the entail and especially what Mr. Collins does with it, unless she has a male child, as a widow she might be SOL as well.

1
OutrageousYak5868•

In my head-canon, she does exactly what Mrs Bennet says, when the latter is taking to Lizzy after she returns from Kent: that Charlotte is frugal and saves, and will take care never to outspend her income. While Mr Collins technically has all the financial power, she's smart enough to guide him in making wise choices. So, I think she will have a nice nest egg in a few years.

1
EagleIcy5421•

Wouldn't a pastor's widow get some kind of pension?

1
RitanFP•

No, not really. The living would be quickly given to the next pastor. And I suspect that Lady C. would barely wait until Mr. C was cold in the ground before moving Charlotte out of the Hunsford parsonage. Witness Mrs. Norris in Mansfield Park or Mrs and Miss Bates in Emma. And of course Jane Austen's life after her father retired and then died.

1
Amiedeslivres•

Entails were not typically permanent, but tended to go through a fixed set of generations unless a father an his adult son collaborated to break it, or a father died before his heir’s marriage and therefore did not establish it for the ensuing generations. These things were usually set at the time of the heir’s marriage, during the writing of the settlements.

1
Caterpi11ar0•

TBH I don't think Charlotte married him just to get Longbourn.

Also Mr. Collins lived a sedate country quiet life and was relatively healthy, the likelihood that he outlived Mr. Bennett was pretty high anyway. If he had died, well, fine, she reenters the marriage market as a respectable widow.

1
Demon-DM0209•

If any of the Bennett daughters have a son they won’t get it either as entails go to the nearest male relative. So Mr Bennett’s Grandson will inherit. Hence why Mr Collins wanted to keep it in the family initially and Marry one of the eldest Bennett’s.

1
Quelly0•

Are you sure? If that were true, the Miss Bennetts could have married anyone and one would surely have had a son. No "marrying well" would've been necessary. The whole premise of the book falls apart.

1
Demon-DM0209•

No it doesn’t render the premise moot. In the first instance regardless of the entail there was very little money so marrying well was still very important. 2. Letting them marry ‘anyone’ would not have been acceptable given their social standing (landed gentry) and money was important. 3. As the Bennett’s had found out to their extreme disappointment sons are not guaranteed so taking a risk on allowing their daughters to marry anyone in the hopes that one of them would drop a kid with the right genitals would have been stupid in the extreme.

An entail on the male line basically meant that the land had to go to the next male direct descendant. The oldest grandson of Mr Bennett the current landowner would be higher in the hierarchy than a cousin from another branch.

The Royal Family is a good example So it was Elizabeth, Charles, William and then Harry. When William had George then Harry moved further down the line of succession, then they had Charlotte and Louis - so the line of heirs with Charles now King is William, George, Charlotte, Louis and then Harry. When George has a child this will change again with George’s child being next in the line of succession before Charlotte.

If William succeeds to the throne and George were to pass before he succeeded but after he had had a child the next in line would be George’s child and not Charlotte.

My understanding, from my research thus far (and happy to stand corrected should citations refute this as I have only just started researching for my book so very early on the process) an Entain works in the same way but in this case the relevant provision is that the heir must be male.

Should Mr Bennett die without a male grandchild then the house passes to Mr Collins and cannot then revert back to the Bennett’s so a male child born after that event would have no claim and Mr Collins male issue becomes the next inline, unless of course he and Charlotte do not have a male baby - in which case ironically one of the male Bennett’s children could then become the heir.

This is my understanding, however I am happy to be corrected if someone more informed is able to oblige.

1