Charlotte will not become mistress of Longbourne if...
...the "olive branch" she is expecting at the end, along with any subsequent olive branch, is a girl and Mr Collins dies before Mr Bennet. People commonly die at all ages at this point in time, so the latter could very possibly happen, as could the former. If this happens, the lawyers will move onto the next male cousin, assuming there is one somewhere.
I don't think Austen intends for us to find this outcome desirable. Charlotte doesn't deserve to be faced with poverty and neither do her hypothetical daughters. But I've always disliked Lady Lucas for her greedly calculations as to how long Mr Bennet is likely to live, and though I think we're meant to forgive her for it (of course she wants security for her daughter) and see her good qualities (reaching out to the Bennets during Lydia's scandal), I'm not above feeling smug at the prospect of her seeing the possibility I've floated become reality. Yes, I'd probably be a better person if it wasn't so.
Posted Sep 24, 2023, 4:30 PM UTC
I've never read Lady Lucas visiting at the time of the scandal as caring. I always assumed it was a nosy neighbor who wants first crack at any juicy gossip.
That's fair. Maybe since I'm wishing ruin on her daughter, I feel the need to be kind in other ways:)
Here's my q, why are you wishing ruin on her?
Charlotte isn't meant to be a villain.
I'm not actually wishing ruin on her. Like I said, part of me would want Lady Lucas to see her daughter fail to become mistress of Longbourne after her calculation as to how many years Mr Bennet might live, which has always struck me as her hoping on whatever level he doesn't live too long.
You seem to have some issue separating the facts of life from the personal morals of the characters.
Austin isn't always attempting to critique the character, she is most often critiquing the societal circumstances that the characters find themselves in.
Lady Lucas is commenting on a fact of life. Mr Bennet is most likely to die before Mr Collins, and because of the ridiculous nature of the entail, that then means Mr Collins will get Longbourne, which happens to be to the benefit of her daughter.
The point is not to bring attention to Lady Lucas as a character with moral failings for thinking about someone else's inevitable death... the point is to again draw attention to the absurdity of the law that makes the entail work that way.
You are not supposed to be rooting for the absurdity of the entail to later enact karma on characters you think deserve it (Lady Lucas being unhappy if Charlotte has daughters) you are supposed to be thinking about how the entail itself is ridiculous and should not exist as a legal principal, at all.