Do you think it’s a bad thing if a surgeon doesn’t do digital mock-ups of post surgery outcome?

Just curious what you think about this. Found a surgeon I like for a rhinoplasty, but they don’t do a digital mock up to see what your post surgery might look like. It would give me peace of mind to at least know the surgeon is exactly on the same page as me and I feel like it’s hard to do that without seeing what they are thinking visually.

Posted Sep 28, 2023, 3:32 PM UTC

115

I think it’s not a bad thing at all. In many cases you just need to have a look at the surgeon’s before/afters to know if they are able to give you the desired result

1
Weather53OP•

That’s another thing too, I don’t think they have before and afters available. This is a surgeon at a hospital and not a private practice so I guess that’s why.

1

No before and afters would give me pause... I nixed a surgeon who didn't have enough pictures. They only had, like 5 on their website and no more to show me for my consult. I thought that was a red flag personally.

1
AverageCanadianEhh•

Big red flag. My first rhinoplasty I went just off of how I felt about the surgeon (he seemed genuine and gave good vibes and was local) but had few images and didn’t do mock ups.

Well I got completely botched and it basically ruined my self esteem until I had a revision with a new doctor.

1
Weather53OP•

Yikes, sorry you had to go through that.

1
YayVacation•

You should ask for pics at the consultation. They may just not be online on the website.

1
Minimum_Cat4932•

No photos is a huge red flag— even if they are new to an independent practice, any PS who has gone thru residency and fellowship should have some before and afters that they helped with during their training!

1

So that’s the problem. No surgeon can mimic “exactly” what is on a 2-D mock up. Some patients have extremely unrealistic expectations, and this is why many surgeons have turned away from doing mock ups.

1
prima_facie2021•

I am exactly the wrong kind of person to give a mock up to. Anything that deviates would seem like a terrible result, even if the result was a giant improvement. I didn't get a mock up from my surgeon. We talked about what would be best to improve my nose. Even on surgery day, I didn't have a sense of what it would look like after. But I am thrilled with the result.

I would want a surgeon with good reviews and previous patient pics though.

1
Weather53OP•

Maybe I just need to have another consultation with them and get more specific, because I do like them and they have good credentials.

1
prima_facie2021•

What is most important is your comfort. You know you best. It doesn't hurt to have a consult with another doc that offers the morph and see how you feel. You might pay for the morph but get an idea of what you want. I don't know if you can take a morph from one doc to another as an example?

1
Weather53OP•

Thought about doing that

1

No I don’t think it’s a bad thing. Go more by his real before and afters than a fake rendering

1
Lucycoopermom•

5 surgery’s and have never been offered that or asked.

1

No but you need to accurately communicate the result you want. You can take Photoshop altered pics you do yourself and show them this is the result I am looking for. They can tell by your anatomy if it's possible. You can also take pics of people with noses you think will suit your face too. How much tip rotation, width, are where both have to be in agreement.

1