Stuck and need some professional advice.

I live in the New England area and the previous owners installed a high efficiency furnace in the attic. The condensate pump and line freeze in the winter and the guy who originally installed the furnace has tried multiple attempts to solve it.

Long story short I'm tired of dealing with it so I had a couple companies come give me quotes to replace it. The first guy pushed heat pumps and literally wouldn't quote me on an 80% furnace (extremely reluctant to cut a vent hole in the roof). The second guy initially said 80% furnace with a Cozy Collar but said a heat pump would be fine too.

One final detail. The same system has a coolant leak somewhere which they haven't been able to track down so I'll eventually need to pay for repairs on that as well.

The quotes were ~$6k for the 80% furnace, ~$14k for Amana heat pump, ~$17k for Mistubishi heat pump (I can probably reduce the heat pumps by a couple thousand through state refunds).

So I'm left with these questions:

  1. The cost for the 80% furnace is obviously much cheaper than the heat pump but will it still be cheaper once I fix the coolant leak (he said it may still be under warranty).
  2. Assuming that the 80% furnace plus the coolant leak fix comes out to the same cost as a heat pump should I do it or go with the heat pump? Our electric rates are pretty low.
  3. If I go with a heat pump is Amana a good brand or should I spend a few thousand more for a Mitsubishi?
  4. Why was the first guy so nervous to put a vent hole in the roof and the second didn't think it was a big deal? Is the Cozy Collar solution not good?

Posted Oct 11, 2023, 5:24 PM UTC

18

No comments yet

Nobody commented on this post, or the comments weren't captured.